AII - NYSE

American Integrity Insurance Group, Inc.

AII·NYSE

$16.59

-1.0%

Financial ServicesInsurance - Property & Casualty

American Integrity Insurance Group, Inc. is an insurance provider that offers a range of coverage options, including policies for homeowners, new home construction, vacant homes, condos, rental and seasonal dwellings, manufactured homes, and golf carts. The company also provides insurance for watercraft and services like binding arbitration.

Statements Value Model

At a Glance

Live Snapshot

Market Cap$325.01M

EPS5.7800

P/E Ratio2.87

Earnings Date06/08/2026

aii

Operating Income

Last Annual Value

115.06M

3-Year CAGR

37%

5-Year CAGR

21%

10-Year CAGR

10%

Adjust for Inflation

American Integrity Insurance Group, Inc. Competitors Analysis of Operating Income

AII · NYSE

Company	Operating Income	CAGR 3Y	CAGR 5Y	CAGR 10Y
American Integrity Insurance Group, Inc. NYSE:AII	115.06M	37.0%	N/A	N/A
Bridgewater Bancshares, Inc. NASDAQ:BWB	61.48M	5.4%	-0.0%	11.2%
Donegal Group Inc. NASDAQ:DGICA	97.59M	168.1%	26.3%	9.0%
American Coastal Insurance Corporation NASDAQ:ACIC	142.73M	14.1%	N/A	N/A
Eagle Point Credit Company Inc. NYSE:ECC	-87.39M	N/A	N/A	N/A
Global Indemnity Group, LLC NYSE:GBLI	54.96M	16.3%	2.7%	-0.3%
Gladstone Capital Corporation NASDAQ:GLAD	80.39M	23.5%	-0.9%	N/A
Capital Bancorp, Inc. NASDAQ:CBNK	70.61M	15.2%	5.6%	16.3%
Northrim BanCorp, Inc. NASDAQ:NRIM	86.15M	39.7%	12.4%	15.1%
Midland States Bancorp, Inc. NASDAQ:MSBI	-103.24M	N/A	N/A	N/A
Unity Bancorp, Inc. NASDAQ:UNTY	75.51M	12.5%	9.4%	13.9%

American Integrity Insurance Group, Inc. Fair Value Envelope

AII · NYSE

Our analysis suggests that AII has a fair value of HIDDEN per share in the Base Case projection. With shares currently trading at $16.59, this represents a potential HIDDEN relative to our calculated worth for American Integrity Insurance Group, Inc..

HIDDEN

Intrinsic Value

Current Price: $16.59

Related Guides

Blog Categories

Continue your AII research with focused valuation guides.

Fundamentals

Decode statement quality and operating durability.

Accounting

Interpret line items with cleaner analytical framing.

Forecasting

Translate historical performance into forward scenarios.

Reference

Use practical frameworks for statement-led valuation.

Research Paths

Pick your next lens

Snapshot

Start with context, operating signals, and key market metrics.

Value Model

Stress test fair value across bear, base, and bull assumptions.

Statements

Validate revenue quality, margins, and balance sheet durability.

Earnings Call

Read management commentary and compare it with reported outcomes.

Dividends

Check payout sustainability and long-term distribution behavior.

Analyst Expectations

Review consensus spread and where estimate risk is concentrated.