American Integrity Insurance Group, Inc.

NYSE:AII

Insurance - Property & Casualty

Financial Services
$29.58 -3.66%

-$0.64 today

Market cap
$579.63M
Beta
0.35
P/E (TTM)
4.1
EPS (TTM)
$4.16
Dividend yield
6.05%
52W Low $16.19High $26.36

Volume 0.26M

Average 0.12M

AII Operating Margin

Operating income as a percentage of revenue, showing the profitability of core operations.

American Integrity Insurance Group, Inc.NYSE: AII

Operating Margin · Q1 FY2026 · quarter ended Mar 2026

Operating margin narrows to 30.0%

Operating margin was 30.0% in Q1 FY2026, down 29.7 pp from a year earlier. On a trailing-twelve-month basis it was 33.6%, down 1.1 pp year over year.

Context

  • Operating margin widened in 2 of the last 2 fiscal years.
  • FY2025 was the highest level in the 3 fiscal years shown.

What to watch

Whether operating margin reaches the consensus estimate from 2 analysts of 8.8% for the fiscal year ending Dec 2026, down from 41.6% in FY2025.

Sources:Income Statement Analyst consensus estimates Text generated from reported figures; not investment advice.

Latest quarterMar 2026
30.0%-13.0 pp QoQ
Last fiscal yearDec 2025
41.6%+16.6 pp YoY
LTMMar 2026
33.6%-1.1 pp YoY
Operating Margin past and forecast change by horizon
Horizon Past Forecast Difference
Quarter-29.7 pp-24.9 pp+4.8 pp
1 year+16.6 pp-32.9 pp-49.5 pp
3 years—-35.0 pp—
5 years——
10 years——

Forecasts compare the consensus estimate with the latest reported period. Difference is forecast minus past, in percentage points.

Operating Margin history

Percent of revenue · from the income statement

Latest · FY2025
41.6%
Year-over-year change
+16.6pp
Reported Analyst consensus estimate Further estimates hidden. Sign in to unlock

Operating Margin vs competitors

How AII compares with its peers on the latest reported figures

  • AII's LTM Mar 2026 operating margin of 33.6% is the 5th highest of the 11 companies compared; the peer median is 21.7%.
  • Its year-over-year change of -1.1 pp is the 9th highest of 11, against a peer median of +2.7 pp.
AII Competitors Peer median
Operating Margin for AII and competitors
Company Period LTM level YoY 3-year change
GLADGladstone Capital CorporationLTM Mar 202671.5% -8.1 pp-4.8 pp
ACICAmerican Coastal Insurance CorporationLTM Mar 202642.6% +10.6 pp+41.8 pp
UNTYUnity Bancorp, Inc.LTM Mar 202638.1% +3.9 pp-7.4 pp
NRIMNorthrim BanCorp, Inc.LTM Mar 202635.1% +9.1 pp+6.9 pp
AIIAmerican Integrity Insurance Group, Inc.LTM Mar 202633.6% -1.1 pp—
BWBBridgewater Bancshares, Inc.LTM Mar 202623.6% +6.2 pp-21.3 pp
CBNKCapital Bancorp, Inc.LTM Mar 202619.7% +0.1 pp-6.9 pp
MSBIMidland States Bancorp, Inc.LTM Mar 202610.5% +25.1 pp-52.2 pp
GBLIGlobal Indemnity Group, LLCLTM Mar 20269.7% +1.6 pp+7.1 pp
DGICADonegal Group Inc.LTM Mar 20268.3% -0.4 pp+10.4 pp
ECCEagle Point Credit Company Inc.LTM Dec 2025-50.2% -51.4 pp-204.8 pp
Peer median (excluding AII) 21.7%+2.7 pp-5.8 pp

Competitors are the stored peer set for AII. Fiscal calendars differ, so each company's latest period is shown. Text is generated from reported figures; not investment advice.

Income Statement

USD
Metric
FY2023
Dec 2023
FY2024
Dec 2024
FY2025
Dec 2025
Revenue200.87M204.35M276.49M
Cost of Revenue122M122.36M98.03M
Gross Profit78.87M81.99M178.45M
Gross Margin39.3%40.1%64.5%
Research & Development000
Selling, General & Admin34.11M30.95M41.95M
Operating Expenses34.11M30.95M63.39M
Depreciation & Amortization1.22M2.84M2.28M
EBITDA45.98M53.88M117.34M
EBITDA Margin22.9%26.4%42.4%
Operating Income44.76M51.04M115.06M
Operating Margin22.3%25.0%41.6%
Interest Income000
Interest Expense000
Other Income / Expenses000
Income Before Tax44.76M51.04M115.06M
Pre-Tax Margin22.3%25.0%41.6%
Income Tax Expense6.96M11.3M15.44M
Net Income37.8M39.74M99.62M
Net Margin18.8%19.4%36.0%
EPS (Basic)1.841.945.78
EPS (Diluted)1.841.945.65
Weighted Avg Shares19.58M19.58M17.24M
Weighted Avg Shares (Diluted)19.58M19.58M17.24M

American Integrity Insurance Group, Inc.

NYSE:AII

Intrinsic Alpha fair value

Locked

Current Price

$29.58

Margin of safety hidden

Unlock the intrinsic value to see where the current price sits on the valuation runway.

Valuation runway

Locked

Get the intrinsic value and margin of safety with a free account.