Company Snapshot
Donegal Group Inc. investment report
Start with DGICA at a glance, then work through valuation, price history, fundamentals, management, competitors, and analyst expectations.
Donegal Group Inc.
NASDAQ:DGICAInsurance - Property & Casualty
-$0.01 today
- Market cap
- $708.73M
- Beta
- -0.01
- P/E (TTM)
- 9.7
- EPS (TTM)
- $1.80
- Dividend yield
- 4.22%
Volume 0.12M
Average 0.11M
Intrinsic Value
DGICA Intrinsic Value
Start with the valuation result. Compare the current market price with the system DCF estimate, then use the supporting sections below to decide whether the assumptions are reasonable.
Donegal Group Inc.
NASDAQ:DGICA
Intrinsic Alpha fair value
Locked
Current Price
$18.94
Unlock the intrinsic value to see where the current price sits on the valuation runway.
Valuation runway
LockedGet the intrinsic value and margin of safety with a free account.
Monitor DGICA
Get notified when the price moves into your range
Use alerts to turn the valuation into an action plan instead of checking the stock manually.
Price alerts
Get notified when DGICA drops below your target
Current price baseline
$18.94
Current price $18.94
Sign in to activate price alerts.
Price History
How has DGICA traded over time?
Review how the market has priced Donegal Group Inc. over time, alongside earnings and dividend events, before deciding whether today’s price is unusual.
Price history
Dividend-adjusted closing price
Period change
-2.82%
Period high
$20.52
Period low
$16.32
Latest
$18.94
Investment Notes
Capture the investment case
Write down the key idea, risks, and what would change your mind before testing the thesis against the fundamentals below.
My notes
Journal entries for DGICA
Sign in to keep notes
Keep your research and decisions in your personal journal.
Fundamental Analysis
Test company quality against your thesis
Work through profitability, revenue mix, financial position, cash generation, compounding numbers, and growth to see whether the business supports the investment case.
Earnings Quality
Follow revenue through to net income
Use the waterfall to see which costs, margins, and operating lines explain how much of each sales dollar becomes profit.
DGICA Earnings Waterfall · TTM
NASDAQ:DGICA · Revenue to Net Income
Key Ratios
Analysis
$969.2M of revenue converted into $65.6M of net income for the selected period. Gross margin is 29.1% and net margin is 6.8%, showing how much revenue survives after costs and taxes. EPS is $1.84, tying the income statement back to per-share earnings.
Revenue Mix
See which products and regions drive the business
Growth is easier to trust when you know where it comes from. Check whether one segment or region carries the company and how the mix is shifting.
Revenue by segment
Where DGICA earns its revenue, as reported in company filings
- Commercial Lines
- Personal Lines
- Property and Casualty, Commercial Insurance
- Property and Casualty, Commercial Insurance Product Line
- Property and Casualty, Personal Insurance Product Line
- Property and Casualty, Personal Insurance
| Segment · FY2024 | Revenue | Share | YoY |
|---|---|---|---|
| Commercial Lines | $539.68M | 57.6% | — |
| Personal Lines | $396.97M | 42.4% | — |
Figures in USD. Segments account for 94.6% of reported FY2024 revenue; $52.95M is not attributed to a segment.
Financial Position
Check what supports the company underneath the income statement
The balance sheet shows liquidity, debt, asset mix, and book value quality before you rely on earnings or growth assumptions.
Balance Sheet
Assets, liabilities & equity
| Cash & Equivalents | $35.5M |
| Short-term Investments | $475.4M |
| Receivables | $197.3M |
| Other Current | -$475.4M |
| Total Current Assets | $232.8M |
| PP&E (Net) | $2.3M |
| Goodwill | $5.6B |
| Intangible Assets | $958.0M |
| Long-term Investments | $1.0B |
| Other Non-current | -$6.0B |
| Total Non-current Assets | $1.6B |
| Total Assets | $1.9B |
Analysis
Selected assets total $1.9B for Latest. The largest visible component is Other Non-current at $6.0B, about 323.9% of the tab total. Use the mix to judge balance sheet concentration, liquidity, leverage, and how much of book value is supported by tangible operating assets.
Cash Generation
Test whether profit turns into cash
Free cash flow connects accounting earnings to owner earnings, showing how much cash remains after reinvestment needs.
Free Cash Flow
Net Income to FCF bridge
FY2025
Analysis
FY2025 free cash flow is $70.2M. FCF conversion is 88.5% of net income. Operating cash flow was $70.2M, with capex of -$425. The largest bridge item is Working Capital at -$11.6M.
Quality Snapshot
Check the numbers that compound value
Check whether earnings, revenue, equity, cash, and returns on capital are moving in the same direction as your written thesis.
Big Five Numbers
CAGR by period · ROIC shows average
| Metric | 10yr | 5yr | 3yr | 1yr |
|---|---|---|---|---|
EPS | N/A | N/A | N/A | +42.5% |
Revenue | N/A | N/A | +4.9% | -1.2% |
Equity | N/A | N/A | +11.3% | +25.9% |
Cash | N/A | N/A | +2.2% | -49.4% |
ROIC | N/A | 5.0% | 7.0% | 11.6% |
Analysis
Latest growth is strongest in EPS at +42.5% and weakest in Cash at -49.4%. Three-year average ROIC is 7.0%, which helps show whether that growth is being earned efficiently.
Growth Profile
Compare historical growth with forward expectations
Strong past growth matters more when analysts still expect the business to expand without relying on one temporary driver.
Growth Analysis
Historical CAGR & forward analyst estimates
| Metric | 10yr | 5yr | 3yr | Fwd Est. |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| EPS | N/A | N/A | N/A | -3.1% (3yr)1 analysts |
| Revenue | N/A | N/A | +4.9% | -2.3% (3yr)1 analysts |
| Net Income | N/A | N/A | N/A | -7.9% (3yr)1 analysts |
| EBIT | N/A | N/A | N/A | -6.4% (3yr)1 analysts |
Analysis
Recent growth has been strongest in Revenue at +4.9% over three years. Forward estimates point to Revenue at -2.3% (3yr), giving you a quick check on whether expectations are accelerating or cooling.
Management
Judge how Donegal Group Inc. allocates capital
Review returns on capital, owner payouts, dividend durability, insider activity, and the leadership responsible for these decisions.
Capital Efficiency
Returns on equity, invested capital, and assets help separate durable operators from businesses that only grow by adding more capital.
Return Metrics
ROE, ROIC & ROA over time
ROE
12.4%
avg 4.8%
ROIC
11.6%
avg 7.8%
ROA
3.3%
avg 1.2%
Analysis
ROE is currently the strongest return metric at 12.4% versus its period average of 4.8%. 1 of 3 return metrics are above their quality threshold, which helps indicate how efficiently the company turns capital and assets into profit.
Dividend Record
A dividend is more useful when growth, payout ratio, and free cash flow support the current yield.
Dividends
Dividend history, growth & yield
Yield
4.22%
Annual Div/Share
$0.74
Payout Ratio
40.1%
Frequency
Quarterly
Shareholder Yield
3.62%
Next Ex-Date
Not announced
Next Payment
—
1Y Growth
+2.8%
3Y CAGR
+3.1%
5Y CAGR
+3.3%
Dividend Payments, Annual Total (TTM) & Yield
Analysis
The current indicated dividend yield is 4.22%, with TTM dividends of $0.74 per share. Three-year dividend growth is +3.1%, which helps show whether payouts are compounding or flattening. The payout ratio is 40.1%, so compare payout growth against earnings coverage. Payments are currently quarterly.
Owner Returns
Dividends, buybacks, and debt paydown show whether excess cash is being reinvested, returned, or used to strengthen the balance sheet.
Shareholder Returns
Dividend, buyback & debt paydown yields
Dividend Yield (TTM)
3.71%
Buyback Yield (TTM)
0.00%
Debt Paydown (TTM)
0.00%
Total Yield (TTM)
3.71%
Analysis
Total TTM shareholder yield is 3.71% including 0.00% from debt paydown. The largest current contributor is dividends at 3.71%, which helps show whether capital returns are coming from direct cash payouts, share count reduction, or balance sheet cleanup.
Insider Activity
Insider transactions add context to ownership incentives and can reveal when leadership behavior diverges from the public investment case.
Insider Trading
SEC Form 4 transactions — last 12 months
Buys
68
$13.92M
Sells
18
$3.15M
Net Transaction Value
+$10.76M
Net buying
Most Active
DONEGAL MUTUAL INSURANCE CO
68 transactions
Transactions sorted by date, descending.
| Type | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| Nov 12, 26Nov 12, 2026 | CALLAHAN MICHAEL KEVIN Direct | Sell | $28.5K$28,500.45 |
| Nov 12, 26Nov 12, 2026 | CALLAHAN MICHAEL KEVIN Direct | Sell | $28.5K$28,517.25 |
| Nov 11, 26Nov 11, 2026 | DONEGAL MUTUAL INSURANCE CO Direct | Buy | $141.6K$141,630.75 |
| Nov 10, 26Nov 10, 2026 | ALTSHULER KRISTI SPENCER Direct | Sell | $114K$114,043.80 |
| Nov 10, 26Nov 10, 2026 | DONEGAL MUTUAL INSURANCE CO Direct | Buy | $141.8K$141,795.75 |
| Nov 9, 26Nov 9, 2026 | DONEGAL MUTUAL INSURANCE CO Direct | Buy | $141.1K$141,070.50 |
| Nov 6, 26Nov 6, 2026 | DONEGAL MUTUAL INSURANCE CO Direct | Buy | $140.5K$140,531.25 |
| Nov 5, 26Nov 5, 2026 | DONEGAL MUTUAL INSURANCE CO Direct | Buy | $142.3K$142,286.25 |
| Nov 5, 26Nov 5, 2026 | DONEGAL MUTUAL INSURANCE CO Direct | Buy | $338.7K$338,688.00 |
| Nov 5, 26Nov 5, 2026 | PANDEY SANJAY Direct | Sell | $20.9K$20,890.79 |
1–10 of 86
Summary
Insiders reported 68 buys worth $13.92M and 18 sells worth $3.15M over the last 12 months. That adds up to net buying of $10.76M. DONEGAL MUTUAL INSURANCE CO was the most active insider with 68 transactions.
Leadership
Leadership context helps you judge who is responsible for strategy, capital allocation, and execution.
Management
Key executives, compensation & ownership
| Name | Title | Compensation | Age | Shares Owned | Ownership % |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Kevin Gerard Burke | President, Chief Executive Officer & Chairman | USDÂ 1.74M | 60 | 0 | <0.01% |
Jeffrey Dean Miller | Executive Vice President & Chief Financial Officer | USDÂ 1.49M | 62 | 0 | <0.01% |
William Daniel DeLamater | Executive Vice President & Chief Operating Officer | USDÂ 1.2M | 53 | 2.34K | <0.01% |
Sanjay Pandey | Executive Vice President & Chief Information Officer | USDÂ 1.07M | 59 | 8.70K | 0.02% |
Jeffery Tim Hay | Executive Vice President | USDÂ 1.01M | 51 | 8.14K | 0.02% |
David Benjamin Bawel | Senior Vice President & Chief Accounting Officer | — | 39 | 0 | <0.01% |
Christina Marie Hoffman | Senior Vice President & Chief Risk Officer | — | 51 | 0 | <0.01% |
William Albert Folmar | Senior Vice President | — | 67 | 999 | <0.01% |
Rick Joseph Hecker | Senior Vice President & General Counsel | — | 38 | 3.00K | <0.01% |
Vincent Anthony Viozzi | Senior Vice President & Chief Investment Officer | — | 52 | 5.86K | 0.02% |
Compensation is shown in the reported currency; data updated Nov 7, 2026.
Ownership uses each executive's latest SEC Form 4 holding only when the full name maps to one reporting CIK; latest matched holding Nov 5, 2026.
Alternatives to DGICA
Compare Donegal Group Inc. with similar companies
A stock can look attractive in isolation and still be less compelling than a peer. Check competitors before committing to the thesis.
Competitors
Peer companies in the same sector
Slide Insurance Holdings, Inc. Common Stock
NASDAQ:SLDE
Market cap
$3.02B
Skyward Specialty Insurance Group, Inc.
NASDAQ:SKWD
Market cap
$2.80B
Universal Insurance Holdings, Inc.
NYSE:UVE
Market cap
$1.34B
United Fire Group, Inc.
NASDAQ:UFCS
Market cap
$1.31B
Heritage Insurance Holdings, Inc.
NYSE:HRTG
Market cap
$998.02M
American Integrity Insurance Group, Inc.
NYSE:AII
Market cap
$547.10M
American Coastal Insurance Corporation
NASDAQ:ACIC
Market cap
$485.66M
Orion180 Insurance Group, Inc. Class A
NASDAQ:OIG
Market cap
$417.17M
Global Indemnity Group, LLC
NASDAQ:GBLI
Market cap
$322.09M
NI Holdings, Inc.
NASDAQ:NODK
Market cap
$304.23M
Analysts
What Wall Street expects from DGICA
Compare consensus price targets and ratings with your own valuation to understand how much optimism the market is already pricing in.
Analyst Targets
See where analysts expect DGICA to trade next
Compare the latest consensus target range with the current share price to understand how much upside or downside Wall Street is pricing in.
Wall Street price targets
1-year price history with analyst consensus target
Unlock analyst target range
Sign in free to see low, average, high targets and implied upside for DGICA.
Analyst Ratings
How analysts rate DGICA today
See the buy, hold, and sell split behind the consensus and whether recent rating changes lean toward upgrades or downgrades.
Analyst ratings
Buy, hold, and sell recommendations and recent rating changes
Unlock analyst ratings
Sign in free to see the buy/hold/sell breakdown and recent rating changes for DGICA.
Company Overview
Understand how Donegal Group Inc. makes money
Ground the financial evidence in the company profile, business description, and key facts.
Key Information
Stock Analysis
Turn the DGICA report into your next decision
Record your conclusion, evidence, and concerns in a structured analysis workspace.
Investment analysis
Turn DGICA research into a decision
Work through Know the Business, Test the Moat, Management, and Intrinsic Value in one private, repeatable checklist.
Sign in on the next page to save a private analysis.
Start analysisFAQ
Common questions about DGICA
Resolve the remaining questions before moving into the detailed workspaces.
Explore
Continue your research
Open the detailed valuation, financial, health, and management workspaces.
Continue the stock analysis
Jump to another research area for this company.