Good afternoon, ladies and gentlemen. My name is Mandeep and I will be your host operator on this call. [Operator Instructions] Please note that this call is being recorded on May 2, 2023 at 5:00 p.m. Eastern.
I would now like to turn the meeting over to your host for today's call, Mike Rost, Senior Vice President of Corporate Development and Investor Relations at Workiva. Please go ahead..
Good afternoon, and thank you for joining us for Workiva's First Quarter Conference Call. During today's call, we will review our first quarter results and discuss our guidance for the second quarter and full year 2023.
Today's call has been pre-recorded and will include comments from our Chief Executive Officer, Julie Iskow, followed by our Chief Financial Officer, Jill Klindt. We will then open the call up for a live Q&A session. A replay of this webcast will be available until May 9, 2023.
Information to access the replay is listed in today's press release, which is available on our website under the Investor Relations section.
Before we begin, I would like to remind everyone that during today's call, we will be making forward-looking statements regarding future events and financial performance, including guidance for the second quarter and full fiscal year 2023. These forward-looking statements are subject to known and unknown risks and uncertainties.
Workiva cautions that these statements are not guarantees of future performance. All forward-looking statements made today reflect our current expectations only, and we undertake no obligation to update any statement to reflect the events that occur after this call.
Please refer to the company's annual report on Form 10-K and subsequent filings for factors that could cause our actual results to differ materially from any forward-looking statements. Also, during the course of today's call, we will refer to certain non-GAAP financial measures.
Reconciliations of non-GAAP to GAAP measures and certain additional information are also included in today's press release. With that, we'll begin by turning the call over to our CEO, Julie Iskow..
Thank you for joining our earnings call, my first as Workiva's CEO. Jill and I look forward to sharing our strong Q1 results. We'll also discuss our continued growth opportunities and our outlook for Q2. The Workiva team delivered a solid quarter and continued to execute at a high level, resulting in subscription revenue growth of 21%.
Accelerating subscription growth drove revenue above the high end of our Q1 guidance. We also beat the high end of our guidance for operating results by $3.7 million. In Q1, we continued to see healthy market demand for our platform and our best-of-breed solutions even in an uncertain macro environment.
We believe this is a result of the rapidly evolving market trend of increasing stakeholder scrutiny of both financial data and nonfinancial or ESG data. And this has made our product offerings and our platform more relevant than ever. Workiva was born in the cloud.
It established itself in financial reporting and then expanded to a broad portfolio of solutions. Today, Workiva offers the only reporting platform that brings financial reporting, ESG and GRC together in 1 secure, controlled, audit-ready environment.
This unified platform offering known as Assured Integrated Reporting is a unique and key differentiator that sets us apart from our competition. And in Q1, we saw continued momentum of customers expanding their solution portfolio to include all 3 of our Assured Integrated Reporting solutions. I'd like to highlight a few examples.
First, one of the world's largest big-box retailers added ESG to their existing Workiva portfolio that included SEC, GRC and management reporting. This long-time SEC client began working with the big 4 advisory firm with their initial purchase and implementation of Workiva management reporting back in 2020.
This same advisory firm led the co-sell and the delivery of Workiva GRC in 2022 and then sourced an ESG opportunity for us in Q1 of this year. As a testament to the breadth of our partner ecosystem, the different big 4 firm will be providing advisory and implementation services for this ESG project. But that's not all.
This ESG account expansion was further influenced by 1 of our climate accounting technology partners. The Workiva ESG solution on our open platform can be complementary to any purpose-built climate accounting solution on the market. A second assured integrated reporting customer win was with a Fortune 100 diversified health care services provider.
During Q1, this existing SEC and GRC customer added ESG to their solution portfolio through a joint deal with 2 different big 4 firms. Both firms have a long-standing relationship with this customer and a robust and growing ESG solution practice with Workiva.
These 2 Workiva partners competed for the advisory and consulting services on this ESG project. Also critical to securing this ESG expansion was our platform's ability to connect to the customers already established carbon accounting system.
Because we're carbon solution agnostic, meaning our platform has the ability to integrate with any source system, including carbon accounting systems, we're able to set ourselves apart from other ESG reporting solutions.
These 2 account expansion multi-solution stories highlight that the value and the flexibility of our platform is being recognized and that businesses and partners are going all in with Workiva. As I mentioned, financial reporting has been the historical foundation of our platform.
And 15 years later, the market continues to invest in our leading financial disclosure, financial statement and industry-specific financial reporting solutions. During the first quarter, the Workiva team booked a number of new financial reporting logo wins and competitive SEC takeaways.
We also landed with financial reporting outside of our SEC solution with a diverse cohort of new private and government reporting customers. Although the IPO market has yet to rebound, we continue to drive account expansion, and we closed a record number of capital market follow-on offerings.
An important financial reporting wins secured during the quarter. with a mid 6-figure new logo deal with the Big 4 accounting firm. The firm purchased our fund reporting solution to be used as a managed service to deliver reporting services to their investment firm clients.
We believe the continued trust that the world's top accounting firms place in Workiva as the platform they can standardize on is a testament to the power of our solutions. I'll now turn to GRC. During the first quarter, we saw strong demand and momentum for our GRC suite of solutions in both the U.S. and in Europe.
Our R&D investments in new functionality and an enhanced user experience continued to support our solid growth in this market. A few key GRC highlights during the quarter include a mid-6-figure deal with a British multinational bank for controls management to replace the legacy GRC platform.
This long-standing customer had already invested in SEC, ESEF, ESG and our financial services solutions. This U.K. SOX opportunity then was a joint pursuit with a Big 4 advisory partner that had an existing relationship with the bank's SOX team. This partner will be providing both advisory and implementation services for this deal.
Another notable GRC win was with a European-based global airline that purchased our controls management solution. This new logo win was a competitive replacement of a legacy on-premise GRC platform. This deal was a joint pursuit with a regional advisory firm who will be providing the implementation and advisory services.
Landing with DRC provides a great future account expansion opportunity for both financial reporting and ESG. Now I'll cover some ESG highlights. ESG remained one of our top solution bookings in Q1. We added several Fortune 500 clients who are already elite roster of ESG account expansions.
The best of the best are investing in Workiva for their ESG reporting. And our partner-first strategy is driving results. The vast majority of our ESG opportunities continue to be either sourced or a co-sell with a Workiva advisory or technology partner.
Yes, there's ongoing political debate in the U.S., and there is an extended evaluation period for the proposed SEC climate disclosure regulation. But we continue to see strong demand for the Workiva ESG solution. This observation is supported by a joint PwC-Workiva survey published in March.
70% of business leaders report their companies will proceed with ESG compliance regardless of when the SEC climate disclosure rule becomes law. This survey also reported that 96% of executives say they'll proceed with independent assurance, whether it's required in the final rule or not.
We're hearing from our ESG customers and prospects that ESG reporting is a board-level mandate. It's driven by a number of stakeholders, including investors, customers, vendors and employees.
Organizations that have made public ESG commitments or have published science-based targets have set their own standards for what they've committed to report on and disclose. More than 3,000 businesses and financial institutions are working with the science-based targets initiative to reduce their emissions in line with climate science.
With this market momentum, we anticipate that companies will continue to consider their investment in ESG, a critical factor in driving sustainable long-term value creation for their enterprises regardless of politics. I'll turn now to highlight some of our investments in R&D, which continue to be an important part of our strategy.
Our ongoing innovation expands the capabilities of our platform, keeps our solutions differentiated and opens up new TAM. At Workiva, we continue to provide new functionality that prioritizes our customers' experience and success and plays a significant role in driving strong gross retention and long-term subscription growth.
Our R&D team released several platform and solution enhancements during Q1. We updated the capabilities for regulatory disclosure, including the release of full featured in platform access for the 2023 U.S. GAAP XBRL taxonomy. And we released it the same day it was published by the SEC.
Our customers' SEC reporting teams are on the clock with locked-in reporting deadlines. By providing instant access to a new taxonomy within our solutions, it allows them the valuable time to explore assess and implement changes to their XBRL tags and deliver on-time validated quality disclosures.
For our European customers, we released important enhancements for design reporting to better support Assured integrated reporting. We worked with both our design agency partners and our current customers to provide highly stylized and design reports that are also audit ready and can deliver XBRL output.
For our GRC customers, we released meaningful new features supporting more advanced risk assessments, enhanced navigation for audit management and a fully enabled modernized user experience for all GRC solutions.
To support rapidly evolving ESG reporting requirements, including the EU's Corporate Sustainability Reporting directive, we released important new enhancements, including the support for and the integration with CDP, which is cited as the gold standard of environmental reporting. More than 13,000 companies disclose through CDP.
As an accredited CDP solution provider, Workiva was also selected to pilot the new CDP API. This API will support automated data transfer which provides an enhanced and streamlined disclosure experience, reducing the need for manual data entry. We also released enhancements in our ESG Explorer to better enable new versions of frameworks and standards.
This included the addition of GRI sector standards. More than 10,000 companies around the world communicate their impacts using GRI standards. These examples are just a few of many enhancements that we released that demonstrate our commitment to enable our customers to optimize their investments with us.
We believe that we will see improved R&D operating leverage over time and remain committed to our long-term operating model. To summarize my comments this afternoon, Workiva delivered another solid quarter.
We're focused on subscription revenue growth while improving our operating leverage, and we remain committed to delivering on both our short-term and our long-term operating margin targets.
Our unified platform offering, known as Assured Integrated Reporting is a unique and key differentiator that sets us apart from the competition, and it underpins our multi-solution and account expansion strategy. The value of our platform is being recognized. Businesses and our partners are going all in with Workiva.
And finally, investments in our platform, in our solutions and in our people have positioned us well to drive greater performance and productivity through focused execution of our strategic initiatives.
In closing, I'd like to thank our talented team of dedicated employees, their commitment to our values and the way they support our customers and our communities and each other have yet again earned us a spot on the list of Fortune's 100 Best Companies to work for, and it's our fifth consecutive year.
This award celebrates the world-class culture we've created. And thank you, too, to our customers, our partners and our shareholders for your continued trust in Workiva. We believe we have the right team the right technology at the right time to capitalize on the increasing global opportunities to power transparent reporting for a better world.
And with that, I'll turn it over to you, Jill..
customers, partners, shareholders and employees. We will now take your questions. Operator, we are ready to begin the Q&A session..
[Operator Instructions] Our first question comes from the line of Matt Stotler from William Blair..
Maybe just to start off, one on the international opportunity here. I would love to get an update on what you're seeing in terms of demand and progress in international markets growth outside of North America. Obviously been a focus for the company for the last several years.
You got a little bit of a different go-to-market approach in the last couple of quarters. We'd love to get an update there, how that's rolling out and then how ESET, ESG and the rest of the geography-specific opportunities there are playing out even though they're early days..
Sure. I will start with that one. Looking at our workover in Europe. I will say we've had some improvement over there, both in Q3, Q4, Q1. We're, of course, closely monitoring our pipeline, any changes to our buying behavior. But we've taken a partner-first approach there.
We are focusing in the areas we can win, where we've got sales teams on the ground, referenceable customers, again, strong partner relationships. And certainly, we're leading with our messaging around Assured Integrated Reporting, which is resonating. So is there work to do? Yes. Have we made some changes? Yes, around leadership, as you know.
And we have centralized teams and so forth, but we're very optimistic about our ability to continue to execute there..
Got it. That's helpful. And then maybe for Jill. Just following up on the billings dynamic. Just wondering if you could kind of double-click on what's happening there? It sounds like, to your point, it's more kind of the renewal timing.
And so if that's the case, maybe what the implication there is for -- we should expect the progress in Q2? And then maybe if you're seeing anything from a macro perspective in terms of large deal cycles continuing to get incrementally stressed out or anything like that? Any color there would be helpful as well..
Sure. So just to, I guess, expand on the prepared comments a little bit, you might recall that we do have some amount of variability in contract lengths that we've had over time.
And that goes -- that has in the past given a little bit of -- we've had some lumpiness in our deferred revenue in the past, and this is just another example of that quarter, Q1 coming in with some some movement related to timing of renewals.
And as we always see then also its movement away from those contracts with the 3-year pay upfront, more of the 3-year, 1-year, 3-year with annual payments, and when we have that, it does cause some lumpiness in deferred.
To your question further in the year, we do expect to return more to our historical norms of it as far as billings and deferred it goes. I would also always push you back and point back towards RPOs. We think that the RPO number is a better metric for our business. It has less of that lumpiness.
Although there is some amount of impact, of course, when you have the timing issue, it does smooth out some of the lumpiness around contract length and payment terms and that sort of thing. And we're -- we feel like that was a really good result for Q1 for us..
Our next question comes from the line of Steve Enders from Citibank..
Okay. Great. Maybe if I could just follow up on the last comment on the RPO and billings dynamics.
I guess, for one, I guess, is there a way to quantify how much of billings maybe shifted from 1Q to 2Q on the timing there? And then, I guess, secondarily, on the RPO dynamic, I guess, was there a bit a timing impact, it would have hit that number as well? Or is that a little bit more muted on that side?.
I think a good way to look at it, Steve, would be to look at some of our historical Q4 to Q1 transitions and and see what would have been more normalized there.
There's always going to be some amount of movement between quarters we just saw in Q1, in particular, we have some larger contracts that add delays with getting closed on those renewals into Q2. And so we -- I don't have a direct and exact number for you.
But I think if you just look back at some of the historical Q4 to Q1 transitions, hopefully, that will help normalize what what we would have expected to see there aside from those larger impacts. The same would hold true for RPL. .
Okay. Got you. That's helpful there.
And I guess if we look at some of the partner investments and those initiatives that you've been investing in quite a bit here, just where are we at kind of in terms of the partners driving opportunities towards you? And how much of that is making an impact on the ESG front as well?.
Sure. When we look at ESG, it is the solution with the highest work with our partners, and that work comes in terms of co-selling, comes in terms of sourced and influence deals, so quite significant when you look at the combination of those plus delivery. So we have particularly in ESG..
Our next question comes from the line of Adam Hotchkiss from Goldman Sachs..
Great. Just a follow-up on your comments from the fourth quarter around your ESG momentum. I think you had mentioned ESG bookings were 85% ahead of your expectations in that quarter, and that drove quite a bit of momentum in the business.
Could you just give us a little bit more color on the sort of trends more broadly around momentum and where that shook out this quarter on the ESG side relative to the ahead of expected results last quarter?.
Sure. So we did see good momentum still in Q1. ESG, as we talked about all last year, ESG continues to be right in the in the mix for top bookings solutions. And we're really excited to see that..
Yes, it remains in the top 3 solutions, again, for third quarter in a row, plus also top for bookings growth solution as well..
Great. That's super helpful.
And then could you just talk a little bit about the traction that you mentioned you're seeing with the private companies? I recognize a lot of that is tied to capital markets activity, but where we are today versus a year ago -- where would you think we are today versus where we were a year ago as things began to soften and could you just review for us what the go-to-market motion looks like for this cohort of companies? How much of that is inbound versus outbound?.
So just to start off, I would say that we continue to really focus on trying to get that private to public movement, and so we are continuing to put focus on moving -- trying to close deals with price companies, especially ones that are more likely to be moving through an IPO and the feature or looking for other types of financing.
We think that we can be a really great bulk to them as they move through that and try to come public ready. As you've seen, there's not really an uptick in that. We did help a couple of companies start a process in Q1. But for the most part, anything related to capital markets was all secondary operators. So it's really the business that we saw.
And this is something that you all know about us is that if that market does pick back up, then we're likely to play in it quite well. but we will continue to just try and work with private companies and just in that whole readiness preparation that they go through as they're thinking about becoming public..
Absolutely. And financial reporting and private market has been a focus for us with a compelling offering and as you see companies are preparing years out for a public offering. A good market for that..
Our next question comes from the line of Alex Sklar from Raymond James..
Great. Julie, on ESG reporting, you referenced the survey that you published a few weeks ago, 40% of company survey had invested in some sort of ESG reporting technology.
Can you help frame that in the context of your own installed base? And any color on what percent of your base you've cross-sold ESG to to date?.
Sure. I mean we see in our installed base is what that is borne out by that survey. I believe the survey, as I have mentioned, said 70% of the companies reported that they will be investing in ESG regardless of regulation. And we're seeing that certainly in our base. There is momentum for -- interest in the momentum and demand for our ESG offering.
So absolutely seeing what the survey we're out..
Okay. And then I guess, Jill, I appreciate all the additional commentary on deferred revenue.
Can you just clarify what you mean by deferred revenue will track back in line with historical run rate?.
So if you look back to the past few years and what we've seen just quarter-over-quarter, we expect to get back towards more of the more historical trends. We did -- we will see some of those renewals resolved in Q2. But past that, we would expect to get back more towards normal quarter-over-quarter transition..
So just to make sure I'm interpreting it right, what a normal Q1 sequential increases versus this Q1 will be kind of additive to the rest of the year?.
Correct. Yes. So the sequential -- yes..
Our next question comes from the line of Joe Meares from Truist Securities..
This is Connor Passarella on for Joe. Just wanted to start with an update on the ParsePort acquisition as it pertains to cross-selling and upselling to legacy customers with Workiva products and then maybe the other side, what are the dynamics around the growth of their legacy products to new customers as well..
Sure. Just for those who aren't fully aware, ParsePort is a leading ESET financial reporting provider that's been providing XPERL conversion software in Europe for more than a decade now. And we acquired them a year ago. In fact, it was exactly a year ago last week or so that we were -- we had acquired them. So we celebrated their 1-year anniversary.
Was just their on site, actually completed about 900 disclosures over the last 4 months and integrating well with the company. But we're pleased with the execution of it over the last year, and we're executing on a program, to your question, around cross-sell and very happy with the momentum we're seeing there..
Our next question comes from the line of Daniel Jester from the Bank of Montreal..
This is Kyle on for Daniel Jester. So Julie, you've been with the company for more than 3 years, and you've seen a lot during that relatively short time.
So as you plan on as you point out how you're going to drive the company forward, what are like some key strategic goals you're focused on to really drive that success?.
Sure. You're right. I've been here for 3.5 years, the day of the transition. And we've developed a strategy that we continue to execute on. It's intact. We have a large TAM. And our focus, of course, remains both on growth and operating leverage.
So strategy execution, operating margin improvement and growth, and really going after that opportunity that I described in the comments earlier around Assured Integrated Reporting..
Our next question comes from the line of Andrew DeGasperi from Berenberg Capital Markets..
This is Stephanie on for Andrew.
Wondering if there have been any noticeable changes in demand trends so far in the second quarter that would differ from the first quarter? Or even if there were any changes in demand towards the end of Q1?.
So we saw, as we said in Q1, we were pleased with our bookings, and going into Q2, we do think that everybody is keeping a really close eye on the of macro. Of course, we’ve got a potential rate increase tomorrow, we’ll see how that trends out. There is some uncertainty.
Especially if we’re looking at EMEA, there’s – they have a lot of factors with the ore in the Ukraine and other more – they sometimes have been seeing a more significant impact from some of those factors. We are watching it very closely.
We’re pleased with the way that we’ve been able to execute – and it’s something that we feel like we’ve still been able to make progress. But you – in certain deals, you maybe do feel a little bit of pressure, but sometimes we move forward. So I think that it can just vary. But we’re not seeing an overall negative impact from the macro environment.
It’s just something we’re watching along with all of our customers and just the whole market..
Our next question comes from the line of Mike Grondahl from Northland..
It's Mike Pochucha for Mike Grondahl. Maybe just on CDP, that integration.
Can you talk about what the kind of cross-sell or different solutions outside of ESG looks like there?.
So with the CDP, certainly, that for us is clearly early. I mean, regulation is only a few quarters old. Although the law passed, details of the regulation are still in progress. But for us, it's really -- it's more of a trigger event for a sales conversation, and it enables us to have conversations around Assured Integrated Reporting.
And that message, as I mentioned, is resonating, of course. And it's all about the clients that use it, a great cohort of clients that --.
Our next question comes from the line of Brad Reback from Stifel..
That's great.
Looking into 2Q with Carport now getting into the NRR calculation, can you give us a sense of how we should expect that to trend?.
I don't really think that it's going to impact our overall company trend. The deal sizes there are pretty small, and so any individual customer impact is going to be a lot smaller if you do see churn there. They have really good retention at the client base.
So I wouldn't expect you to see a very large impact from the overall just historical trends that we've seen..
Perfect. That's helpful. And then, Jill, just following up. The deals that slipped out of 1Q, have most of them already closed or the expectation is they will close in the coming weeks..
Expect maybe either closed or the expectation is that we would close them out here very quickly..
Our final question comes from the line of Patrick Schulz from Baird..
I appreciate the color you provided on the strength you're seeing in ESG. It's pretty good to hear that. Can you just touch on what you're seeing in terms of the average selling prices for ESG solutions.
Are these customers going all in with their initial investment? Or are they breaking the spend up over time? And for your ESG sales and pipeline, how should we be thinking about the breakdown between the mix of new account growth versus existing customer expansion?.
So I'll touch on both those. So I would say that our average deal size, as we talked about in the last call, it was trending higher than our just general average deal size for -- across all solutions.
We still have been seeing that there's a lot of expansion within our existing customer base as opposed to new logos, not that new logos aren't happening within ESG. We certainly are getting some of that business.
But we just have such a really strong base of customers, especially in North America, that it's -- we're seeing a lot of account expansion there with strong deal sizes..
I would also have different segments in the market. There are some mature customers who have their ESG program solidified and have a much better idea of where they're going, what they're doing and strategy in place and deal size there is very different than those that are emerging and beginning their journey.
So while we can see some very large deal sizes, we're also moving in the lower part of the market as well..
Thank you, ladies and gentlemen. This does conclude today's call. Thank you for your participation. You may now disconnect..