Good afternoon, ladies and gentlemen, and welcome to the LiveRamp Fiscal 2024 First Quarter Earnings Call. After the speakers remarks there will be a question and answer session. [Operator Instructions]. As a reminder, this conference call is being recorded.
I would now like to turn the call over to your host, Drew Borst, Vice President of Investor Relations..
Thank you, operator. Good afternoon, and welcome. Thank you for joining our fiscal 2024 first quarter earnings call. With me today are Scott Howe, our CEO; and Lauren Dillard, Interim CFO.
Today's press release and this call may contain forward-looking statements that are subject to risks and uncertainties that could cause actual results to differ materially. For a detailed description of these risks, please read the Risk Factors section of our public filings and the press release.
A copy of our press release and financial schedules, including any reconciliations to non-GAAP financial measures is available at liveramp.com. Also during the call today, we'll be referring to the slide deck posted on our website. At this time, I'll turn the call over to Scott..
one, new marketing channels that possess scale and sophistication similar to walled gardens in both Retail Media Networks and CTV; two, the shift from cookies to true consumer authentication; three, cloud computing; and four, generative AI.
Our leadership and foundational identity and interoperability across the digital advertising ecosystem puts us in a position to benefit from the growth in retail media and CTV. Let's start with Retail Media Networks or Commerce Media Networks more broadly defined beyond the retail CPG complex.
This is hardly a new trend but it is poised for significant growth over the next 5 years.
According to the media buying agency GroupM, Retail Media Networks already represent the third largest advertising platform at $110 billion globally, and it is forecast to be the fastest-growing platform over the next 5 years, with a compound annual growth rate of 9%. These media networks benefit LiveRamp in two ways.
First, our data collaboration platform powers Retail Media Networks by enabling the secure first-party data sharing between retailers and brands. Many of the world's largest retailers are using our data collaboration for this purpose, and we continue to add new customers every quarter, as we mentioned earlier.
The sales bookings for our data collaboration platform have great momentum. For a second consecutive quarter, we had strong sales bookings for our data collaboration platform with Q1 bookings accelerating.
The second way we benefit from the proliferation of Retail Media Networks as we help brands link customer identity across each of these Retail Media Networks, so they can holistically track and measure their addressable advertising. We have a similar opportunity in CTV and ad support and streaming.
From cord cutting and the rise of ad-supported streaming, the video market is going through a massive transformation. This transformation is fragmenting audiences across more video platforms. While we all appreciate where the puck is going, and that is clearly the streaming.
In the meantime, linear broadcast and cable television networks still have a 52% share of viewing on U.S. television compared to 38% for streaming services. And within streaming outside of YouTube and Netflix, each of the streaming platforms has a low single-digit share of audience viewing.
The challenge for marketers is holistically measuring audiences and advertising across these streaming walled gardens. LiveRamp solves this problem with our common privacy identifier and interoperability with all platforms.
To summarize, more choices and more complexity in the marketing ecosystem, make it even more important for marketers to use LiveRamp to simplify workflow and ensure true uniformity across all destinations. So we think the growth in these additional channels will be a long-term tailwind for our business.
A second major trend is third-party cookie deprecation. An impending rise of authentication that will usher in a new era in consumer privacy and digital marketing.
Google's announcement in May, confirming it will deprecate third-party cookies on chrome in the second half of 2024 combined with its rollout of publisher advertiser identity reconciliation or PAIR for its DSP, Display and Video 360 is a clear signal that the post-cookie era is rapidly approaching. Our payer rollout is going very well.
We have 75-plus publishers signed up across North America, Europe and APAC, and we are on track to have 100-plus publishers live by September. We continue to scale campaigns with our brands and have seen lots of brand interest in the alpha.
Anecdotally, the campaigns are meeting customer expectations and by our next earnings call, we should be in a position to share more detailed results.
We see this as a clear call to action for the entire digital advertising industry and our recent customer conversations including dozens of customer meetings at the recent Cannes Advertising Festival, proved this out.
We started preparing for the retirement of third-party cookies more than 5 years ago when we created the authenticated traffic solution, or ATS. ATS connects publisher and brand identity without the use of third-party cookies and enables addressable reach and measurement on our encrypted people-based identifier, RampID.
Today, ATS is a globally scaled solution with unrivaled reach and interoperability. ATS is interoperable with the open web, walled gardens, including CTV platforms and ad tech intermediaries, including over 165 DSPs and SSPs.
On the open web, ATS is interoperable with over 14,000 domains, including 80% of the comScore 50 and 90% of consumer time spent online in the U.S. Taken together, we believe the scale of our solution uniquely positions us to benefit from the final phase of cookie deprecation when it occurs next calendar year.
Continued education and evangelization will be an emphasis for us over the next 4 quarters. The shift of computing to the cloud is a third megatrend that will benefit our business.
According to a recent survey of CIOs, the proportion of workloads running on public clouds, whether AWS, GCP, Azure or others will increase from 30% today to 50% in 3 years. LiveRamp has a long history of successfully navigating technology platform transitions.
Starting with the transition from marketing databases to customer data platforms and now to cloud and cloud data warehouses. We have always enabled our capabilities where our customers' data lives, and we are well positioned to benefit from the shift to cloud computing.
Over the past year, we have deepened our partnership with each of these cloud providers, and we've been deploying native applications that embed our products in these cloud environments. It may sound cliche, but this is truly a win-win-win proposition.
It's a win for the cloud providers because embedding our solutions and their environment drives a material increase in storage and compute because there is a high volume of data and analytics associated with consumer marketing. And the cloud revenue model is entirely based on storage and compute.
It is also a win for our customers who desire a reduced movement of data. Less data movement is more efficient, more secure and reduces the risk of a data breach. Finally, it is a win for us because our products are more easily accessible for existing and prospective customers.
We recently debuted in Snowflake, our native applications for identity resolution. This means LiveRamp customers can seamlessly access our identity resolution and activation capabilities directly in their snowflake data environment, eliminating the need to move or copy data and thereby reducing security and privacy risks.
Initial customer feedback has been positive. But we are committed to making everything even easier to use. We are working with the other cloud providers in a similar manner and look for this to be a meaningful contributor to our growth going forward, if it continues to scale in the coming years.
Investors understandably have been asking us what Gen AI and machine learning means for our business. First and foremost, we expect Gen AI will leave us more firmly into the data fabric of the ecosystem.
At the heart of all data regulatory policy around the world, is the concept of consumer transparency and choice, and that requires the deterministic identity that LiveRamp provides. Second, we expect Gen AI to help stimulate our long-term top line growth.
We are already using AI and machine learning in our identity products to improve the effectiveness of addressable advertising for our customers. We developed deep learning models to improve match rates and match choice, especially when match PII is limited and touch points like e-mail, phone or address or shared.
We are also using machine learning models to determine who is the dominant user on shared devices like a laptop, tablet, CTV or even in some cases, a mobile phone.
Additionally, we think generative AI will open up additional data collaboration opportunities and a potential wave of new applications such as dynamic creative, optimal media buying and precision AI targeting. We are well positioned to seize this opportunity.
Because in addition to having a leading data collaboration platform, we are also the leader in deterministic foundational identity. We are interoperable across the entire ecosystem, and our network of turnkey integrations connects identity across any and every digital destination.
We also expect Gen I to drive growth in cloud and cloud data warehouses, where we have deepened our partnerships to my earlier point. LiveRamp can harness the power of cloud data warehouses assisting businesses and managing and analyzing their consumer data more efficiently.
This in turn, facilitates better use of AI, LLMs and deep learning technologies. Finally, we expect AI capabilities to improve our efficiency, development velocity and service capabilities. Like nearly every company, we are in the process of identifying ways we can integrate AI into our processes to improve our efficiency and productivity.
An example, the most brilliant data analysts all know that one of the most time-consuming tasks in using large data sets is writing SQL queries. AI can remove much of the repetitive manual elements to this effort, thus facilitating even more query efficiency and less technical specialization needs.
Over time, we see opportunities to leverage AI to enhance our product development and engineering, customer service and employee training. While we don't expect a meaningful financial impact from AI in the current fiscal year, we do believe that AI is a long-term tailwind for our business.
In summary, when we consider the cumulative impact of all 4 of these megatrends as well as our ongoing tactical initiatives, we are optimistic about our ability to return to sustainable double-digit revenue growth.
Top line growth is an important lever in the Rule of 40, a goal to which we remain steadfastly committed, but the bottom line is also important. We have made consistent methodical progress over many quarters, improving our non-GAAP operating margin.
This year, we expect our margin to be 14% to 15%, and an improvement of 400 basis points to 500 basis points. Looking ahead to FY '25, we see an opportunity for another year of significant margin expansion, driven by our new offshoring initiative which Lauren will discuss in a moment.
Our profitability improvement is also showing up at our GAAP results. Q1 was our first quarter ever with positive GAAP operating profit. And on a full year basis, we expect to post positive GAAP operating profit in FY '24. Finally, we continue to return excess free cash flow to shareholders through our share purchases.
In Q1, we produced $26 million in free cash flow, and we repurchased $20 million in shares. On a full year basis, we expect to use a significant portion of our free cash flow this year for share repurchases. At our current valuation and given the building momentum in our business, we think repurchasing our shares is an attractive investment.
In summary, Q1 represents a good start to our fiscal year, with the top line and bottom line coming in ahead of our expectations. The tactical moves we've made over the past year with our Salesforce channel partnership and product integrations are starting to pay off, and our business has good momentum.
Additionally, we are well positioned to benefit from the megatrends that are shaping the future of digital advertising, including retail media, CTV, cookie deprecation and AI. All of this puts us on a path to return to sustainable double-digit top line growth.
When combined with our margin trajectory, we expect to make meaningful headway toward our Rule of 40 objective over the next few years. Finally, we expect to continue returning excess free cash flow to shareholders through our share repurchase program. Thank you again for joining us today.
And a special thanks to our exceptional, exceptional customers, partners and to all LiveRampers for their ongoing hard work and support. We look forward to updating you on our progress in the coming quarters. And with that, I will now turn the call over to Lauren..
Thanks, Scott, and thank you all for joining us today. Today, I will cover 3 topics. First, a review of our Q1 financial results; second, an update on our offshoring initiative; and finally, our outlook for FY '24 and Q2. Starting with our Q1 results. In summary, results were above our expectations.
Revenue came in at $154 million, which was $7 million above our guidance, and operating income was $21 million, $6 million above our guide. Operating margin expanded by 11 percentage points to 14%, and we generated $26 million in operating cash flow. Let me now fill in some additional details. Please turn to Slide 5.
Unless otherwise indicated, my remarks pertain to non-GAAP results and growth is relative to the year ago period. Total revenue was $154 million, up 8%. Subscription revenue was in line with our expectations, while Marketplace & Other was significantly ahead, driven by a stronger-than-expected digital advertising environment.
Subscription revenue was $122 million, up 5%. ARR was $426 million, up 4%. Subscription net retention was 98%, and platform net retention was 102%. The sequential improvement was driven by subscription usage. Current RPO or our next 12-month contracted backlog, a was $351 million, up 19%.
Total RPO including contracted backlog beyond the next 12 months was up 25% to $497 million. There is an unusually large difference between CRPO and ARR growth this quarter. As we've discussed before, the RPO is very sensitive to the timing of renewals and the contract duration. And both of these factors flattered CRPO growth this quarter.
ARR normalizes for timing. And for this reason, we continue to believe it is a better leading indicator of subscription growth than trends in RPO. Digging into subscription further, our fixed subscription revenue grew by 5%, again, in line with our expectations.
Overall, the selling environment does remain challenging, although not materially different from the recent trend. Our average deal cycle in Q1 was about 1 quarter longer than in FY '22 and our conversion of pipeline into sales bookings also remains below fiscal '22 averages.
Subscription usage revenue grew 5% in the quarter and represented 13% of total subscription revenue near the midpoint of the historic 10% to 15% range. In the quarter, subscription usage benefited from improving trends in digital advertising and also some onetime items.
Marketplace & Other revenue of $32 million increased 21%, driven by data marketplace, which represents 80% of Marketplace & Other. Data Marketplace grew by 19%, fueled by a healthy digital advertising environment and above-average campaign spending from a select number of customers.
We also continue to see growth in professional services, albeit off a smaller base. To provide a bit of additional perspective on services, services generated revenue of approximately $10 million in FY '23. And we expect it to roughly double in FY '24. While slightly loss-making this year, we see a path to positive margins next fiscal.
Just as importantly, services is providing an ancillary benefit to our subscription revenue in the form of higher customer satisfaction that is driving above-average renewal rates and higher upsell. Moving beyond revenue, gross margin was approximately 73%, down 2 points year-on-year and consistent with our guidance.
The decline was due primarily to higher data hosting from customer use and parallel costs related to customer migration projects as well as continued investment in our services business.
Operating expenses were down 11% to $92 million, driven by last year's cost restructuring and were also flattered by the timing of certain expense items which shifted into later quarters. Operating income was $21 million, up from $4 million a year ago, and our operating margin expanded by 11 points to 14%.
Stock-based compensation was $13 million, down from $24 million a year ago. due to the accelerated vesting of certain non-NEO RSUs in Q4 of last fiscal, which we did discuss on our last call. Operating cash flow was $26 million, up from negative $33 million a year ago, due primarily to the receipt of a $29 million federal tax refund for fiscal 2021.
Even without this refund, as Scott mentioned, our operating cash flow was near breakeven in a quarter that is seasonally negative. We repurchased 835,000 shares in the quarter for $20 million. There remains approximately $198 million under the current authorization that runs through December 31, 2024.
Our diluted weighted average share count in the quarter was down 3%, reflecting a repurchase activity over the past year. In summary, Q1 represented a strong start to fiscal 2024. We beat on both the top and bottom line.
Subscription revenue growth was in line with our expectations and marketplace outperformed, driven by the ongoing strength in the digital advertising market. Our operating margin expanded by 11 percentage points we generated $26 million in operating cash flow and repurchased $20 million in stock.
Let me now provide an update on our offshoring initiative. We recently moved into the execution phase of our offshoring efforts. We are working with a leading global outsourcer, a firm we've worked with on a smaller scale for several years to assist us in this process.
Over the next two years, we will transfer roles in our engineering, customer service and business support functions to Hyderabad, India. We believe this effort will position LiveRamp for success well into the future.
In addition to improving our cost structure, it will help us be more efficient, better serve our global customers around the clock, better compete for world-class talent and accelerate our product development velocity. And lastly, we believe this initiative will unlock another meaningful improvement in operating margin expansion in FY '25.
Finally, let me now turn to our financial outlook for FY '24 and Q2. Please turn to Slides 12 and 13. Please keep in mind our non-GAAP guidance excludes intangible amortization, stock-based compensation and restructuring related charges. Starting with the full year.
We are increasing our total revenue guidance by $10 million and now expect revenue to be between $620 million and $630 million, up 4% to 6% year-on-year. Our outlook for subscription revenue is unchanged. We continue to expect subscription revenue to grow in the mid-single digits.
We expect usage as a percentage of total subscription revenue to be near the midpoint of the historic 10% to 15% range. We also reiterate that subscription net retention is expected to return to at least 100% like Q4. Driven by improving sales productivity, benefits from our new channel partnerships and better retention.
The potential offset to this benefit, in addition to our own execution, would be the macro conditions and the associated impact they have on client budgets. We now expect Marketplace & Other revenue growth to be in the mid- to high-single digits for the full year, up from our prior expectation of approximately flat.
For Q2, based on what we are seeing quarter-to-date, we expect marketplace revenue to grow in the mid- to high-single digits. This growth rate is slower sequentially because Q1 benefited from a select number of unusually large ad campaigns that are unlikely to recur.
For the fiscal second half, we assume marketplace revenue is flat, given our limited visibility into digital advertising that far into the future. While the risk of a U.S. recession has receded in recent months, there remains uncertainty around economic growth. We think it is prudent, therefore, to remain cautious about the fiscal second half.
Should the advertising markets remain stable or improve, then we would expect our marketplace growth to be better. The same is naturally true on the downside.
We continue to expect gross margin to be approximately 75% with the second half slightly higher than the first half, reflecting ongoing hosting optimization initiatives as well as the timing of investment in our services business.
We continue to expect non-GAAP operating income of between $90 million and $93 million, representing a margin of 14% to 15% or up 4 to 5 percentage points. Operating income guidance remains unchanged despite the Q1 beat and the increase to our revenue guide.
We do, however, remain committed to the 50% operating income growth, as we outlined on the last call. We still expect our operating expenses to decline this year in the low-single digits, but we think it is prudent to make some additional investments in areas that we believe will fuel future top line growth.
This includes investments in our sales force and cloud strategy as well as some upfront investment to ensure our offshoring initiative is successful. We expect stock-based compensation for the year to be $72 million, which benefits from the $23 million in accelerated vesting in FY '23 and is lower than our prior guide.
We now expect $7 million in restructuring charges, primarily associated with our offshoring initiative. We continue to expect GAAP operating income to be positive and to be between $2 million and $5 million for the year.
And lastly, we continue to expect to return a significant amount of our FY '24 free cash flow to shareowners through our repurchase program. Now moving to Q2. In Q2, we expect total revenue of $152 million, non-GAAP operating income of $19 million and an operating margin of approximately 13%. A few other call-outs for Q2.
We expect subscription net retention to be flat to Q1, give or take a point. We expect marketplace and other revenue to grow by mid- to high-single digits, as discussed earlier, and we expect gross margin to be roughly 73%. Before opening the call to questions, I'll conclude with a few final thoughts.
First, Q1 represented a strong start to the year, and we're pleased with the team's execution. Next, while we like our momentum exiting the quarter, a single quarter does not make a trend.
It is still early, and given this, we've attempted to be balanced and conservative with respect to our outlook for the remainder of the year and see the potential for further upside if market conditions hold. And finally, we've long talked about our aspiration to be a Rule of 40 company, with mid-teens top line growth and a 25% plus operating margin.
We're encouraged by the ongoing momentum in our sales bookings and improvements in churn and downsell that put us on a path to return to double-digit revenue growth. And we will continue to pull on the following 3 levers to drive this improvement.
First, improving our sales force productivity; second, leveraging recently announced channel partnerships and adding new ones, and finally, improving customer retention led by our enhanced services offering. Faster top line growth is the biggest margin lever we have over time, but certainly not the only one.
Our cost reduction efforts, including our offshoring initiative, will unlock meaningful margin improvement in FY '25 and beyond. And we will continue to be thoughtful about our expenses. And will prudently invest in opportunities that we believe will drive future top line growth.
With that, on behalf of all LiveRampers, thank you again for joining us today. Operator, we will now open the call to questions..
[Operator Instructions]. Your first question comes from the line of Sean Paul with Susquehanna..
This is Aaron on for Sean. We have two. First, last quarter, you talked about automotive as a new use case for your data collaboration platform.
I was wondering, if you could give us an update if there are any other new industries or new use cases using the data collaboration platform? And then secondly, is there any color you can give us on how to think about the net customer number over the coming quarters? Anything to call out in terms of SMBs rolling off? Or maybe some -- I think on the last call, you talked about some tailwinds in the second half related to the Snowflake sales partnership..
Yes, Aaron, it's Scott. I'll take the first one. And I'm really glad you asked that because it's a question we've been getting from investors with increased frequency. They see the success that we've had in Retail Media Networks.
And they ask themselves, "Hey, how long is the cycle for that? Are you reaching a point of saturation." And my response is an emphatic no. That within the retail space, we still have a lot of room by filling in the partner networks underneath each one of the major retailers.
But more importantly, we recognize that marketing is nothing if not a me-too industry. People copy what they see working. And the success that so many major retailers have had globally by collaborating with their Retail Media Networks and their group of partners is now starting to spread to other industries.
You mentioned connected cars, and we have a couple of major automotive clients. Recently, I got back from Europe. And I met with one of the largest packaged goods companies in the world. And they're using RampID to power their media network capabilities all across the globe.
I met with one of the largest travel companies in the world, just a couple of weeks ago here in the U.S. and they're spinning up a global travel network. And they have turnkey already 150 partners that they could activate and do really interesting collaborations with. If we win that, that would be a great new logo.
But we're seeing a lot of interest in travel. And then importantly, I talked a little bit in the prepared remarks about CTV. I'll tell you who's got great data sets, the CTV companies. They have deep viewership and demographic information. And for too long, they haven't used that effectively.
What a great opportunity for them to collaborate with advertisers start to share permission data in a way that is more effective for advertisers.
So I think we're going to see a wave over the next 5 years of data collaboration across the leading companies and they'll benefit because they'll generate more value, but consumers will benefit because they'll get a better value exchange. Importantly, we think we've positioned ourselves to be right in the middle of that..
Hey, Aaron, Lauren here. I'd be happy to address your question on net customers. The first thing I mentioned is that in the quarter, gross adds were stable.
And importantly, the composition of those ads was better, skewing to larger enterprise accounts, which is really a direct result of the tightened sales focus that we talked about on the last call where we continue to feel a bit of pressure is with our lower ACV customers and specifically our nonbrand customers whose business models are just more economically sensitive.
In addition, in the quarter, we were impacted by some unusual events in the form of M&A and account consolidations as well as a couple of bankruptcies. Looking ahead and for modeling purposes, we would expect Q2 could look like Q1. However, based on our pipeline of new deals, we do expect to see a rebound in ads in the second half.
And again, I would go back to what I started with, we feel really good about the quality of the customers we're adding. These are household names. These are larger deals, multi-year deals in many cases and customers that we believe will have a higher LTV..
Your next question comes from the line of Chris Quintero with Morgan Stanley..
This is Chris Quintero on for Elizabeth Porter. Some of the strong results here.
I wanted to ask around the bookings trend you saw in Q1 versus what you saw exiting last fiscal year, kind of how are you tracking versus the targets of a steady improvement throughout the year?.
Yes. Chris, thanks for the question. I would characterize our Q1 bookings as solid. And there's a lot to like. I would tell you, amongst things to like, I feel like we have capacity back to where we want it to be. So if I look at our sales capacity overall versus a year ago, it's probably flat to even down.
But that said, if you look at the number of ramped reps people that have been with us for longer than 6 months, who we would describe as just better sellers and the numbers would prove that out. Well, we are 50% higher on that measure than we were in the first half of last year. Importantly, those ramped reps they are productive.
The new folks that we've hired now that they've gotten up to speed, they are winning some really notable deals. Second thing I really like is the state of our pipeline. And first, let me caveat because any of our sales reps who might be listening to this call are saying, "I can't believe you saying that." Because internally, it's never enough.
We can always do better on pipeline. But if you look at it empirically, I would tell you, we're going into Q3 in another 1.5 months here with the strongest ever qualified pipeline in LiveRamp's history. So I like that. Now that said, now let me temper everything, which is, hey, 1 or 2 quarters does not yet a trend line make.
The nature of SaaS is it's a gradual slow when your bookings are soft. We saw that last year, and we're paying for it now. It's also a gradual reacceleration when you start to rediscover that success. And so really happy with last quarter, happy with this quarter. We got to do it again next quarter.
We've got to do it again throughout the back half of the year. We do that we're going to be in a really good position to be well above 10% growth for next year, but we have to execute..
And Lauren, I wanted to ask around the incremental investments you're making, like anything changed in the quarter where you saw this as being a really nice opportunity you, guys, wanted to lean into..
Yes, happy to. And I would point to a couple of areas of investment. First, our sales force, nothing new in the quarter other than as Scott mentioned, we've rebuilt capacity. We want to maintain adequate capacity as we move through the year.
We don't want to find ourselves in the position we found ourselves in, in the first half of last fiscal, without adequate selling capacity. So we're going to continue to invest behind revenue-generating headcount. The second area where we've continued to see nice momentum is with our cloud and collaboration offerings.
And there, we're seeing growing momentum that we like and that we're going to invest behind as we move through the year. The final area of investment, which I mentioned in my prepared remarks, is there some upfront investment required this year to ensure the rollout of our offshoring initiative next year and through FY '26 is successful.
That was incremental in the quarter..
Your next question comes from the line of Brian Fitzgerald with Wells Fargo..
Two quick questions. Any impact from MediaMath in the quarter? Or do you anticipate any dislocations relating to the situation over the next quarter or 2 is just some of their advertiser clients are transitioning to newer DSPs. Second question is just any dynamics to call out international versus domestic.
You highlighted multiyear deals and large enterprise focus.
Do you generally think you're seeing an acceleration in multiyear deals?.
Thanks, Brian. This is Lauren. I'm happy to take the first and Scott can jump in on the second. With regard to MediaMath, in short, we anticipate minimal, if any, impact as a result of their bankruptcy. And any impact has been accounted for in both our guidance and in our AR reserve.
We work with all of the major DSPs and would expect other DSP partners to absorb the volume that was previously running through the MediaMath platform..
And Brian, on your question on international, I would say that was one of the disappointments of our revenue performance. But when you look beneath the top line there, I actually think it is pretty reassuring. So remember, our Head of International was also our CFO when he transitioned out. So there's always a little bit of disruption there.
But I just got back from Europe. And if you peel apart our European numbers, I believe they were slightly up, not where we want to be, but over the course of two weeks, I met with the largest television companies in the U.K. and France, some of the largest retailers. I mentioned one of the large packaged goods companies.
And it wasn't like deep in the organization. I was meeting with CMOs and CEOs and they look at LiveRamp as an important part of their future. So I emerged from that, pretty excited about the opportunity for us in Europe.
And I think I mentioned a couple of wins that we had internationally including essentially the biggest retailer and property manager in the Middle East. So that's exciting. Now what's not exciting is what's happening in APAC. So if you look at our international business, it was down materially.
Well, Europe, slightly up, APAC down precipitously, and that's China. And we like probably every company you cover are thinking hard about how we're going to participate in the Chinese market going forward. I don't think I'm surprised at anybody to say over the last 10 years, that has been a material change in the business environment.
And I think a lot of companies have just pulled out entirely. You're not going to see us do that. We're hopeful that what became tighter will open back up again because, obviously, it's a large market and a huge population base.
But in the meantime, until that happens, we're taking a hard look at China, thinking about our overall investment there, and I just don't expect significant growth in that market..
And Brian, I think if I can just add on to that, you mentioned multiyear deals accelerating. This is absolutely the case, and you can see this in our RPO trends. And we believe this is a real positive for our business..
Your next question comes from the line of Mark Zgutowicz of Benchmark Company. Your line open..
This is Alex on for Mark. Just a couple from me. I was curious if you could quantify the drag on subscription revenue from non-brand exposure. And what gives you the confidence that, that can start to recover towards the back half of the fiscal year, perhaps upside, of course, into '25.
And then separately, it sounds like the advertising market from your perspective, is improved faster than expected.
So just curious what level of conservatism remains baked in to your conversion trends, especially in the back half of the fiscal year?.
Yes. Thanks for those questions. I'm happy to take both. So with respect to your first question, I would say that the drag from lower ACV customers probably represented a couple of point drag on subscription revenue. And you're seeing this also in a couple of our key growth metrics, namely net adds as well as our subscription net retention.
As we move through the year, and we talked about this on our last call, we've implemented several initiatives, both product and support and services oriented to reduce churn and down sell with our smaller customers. And we're seeing early signs of success there. And as a result, have already pulled down our outlook for contraction in the back half.
So we feel like while there's more work to do, we're taking the right steps to address that SMB contraction I mentioned. With regard to conservatism in our outlook, we continue to expect for bookings specifically, we continue to expect to see an improving trend in bookings as we move through the year.
As we mentioned on our last call, we're not forecasting a hockey stick nor have we forecasted a material improvement in conversion rates. So I think we feel pretty good about our outlook for our subscription business where we see the potential for upside in the second half would be in the data marketplace business.
As we've mentioned, we have less forward visibility here than we do in our fixed subscription business. And the last year has demonstrated this area can be a bit volatile. We had a good Q1 and but it's still early in the year, and Q1 did benefit from some onetime things we just don't expect to repeat.
So relative to marketplace, based on what we're seeing quarter-to-date, we're going to take up our outlook for Q2 but aren't yet ready to pull it up for the back half. So if macro trends and trends in overall digital advertising hold, we would expect the potential for further upside in our marketplace business..
Your next question comes from the line of Kirk Materne with Evercore ISI. Your line is open..
Lauren, I was wondering if you can just expand a little bit on the year-over-year growth in current RPO. That's a pretty good lift. I assume that speaks to some of the positive bookings trends you're seeing.
But I was also just wondering if you could comment on how that sort of impacts your visibility into the remainder of the year from a subscription perspective. I assume you're feeling better about visibility today than 6 months ago based on those trends continuing. Just wondering if you could add a little bit more on that side..
Sure. Happy to, Kirk. In short, yes, we do feel better today than we did 6 or even 3 months ago, and this is a result of the recent bookings momentum that both Scott and I have talked about on the last couple of calls.
With respect to CRPO specifically, as you know, both CRPO and are very sensitive to the timing of renewals as well as to the length of contracts. And both of those factors benefited CRPO growth this quarter. So as an example, we had a couple of large deals closed on 6/30 this year, whereas a year ago, they closed in early July.
So that benefited our CRPO comp. In addition, and this is a really positive thing for the business. We've been successful in shifting some of our largest customers to multiyear deals. So positive for the business but can create an unequal comparison that can flatter RPO and CRPO growth rates in any given quarter.
So I guess, net-net, we like what we're seeing would probably continue to point you to ARR as a better forward indicator of growth because it normalizes for some of the variables I just mentioned..
Your next question comes from the line of Dean Sublet with Stephens Inc. Please go ahead..
This is Dean on for Nick. We were just curious, so on the Pinterest relationship, we were wondering if there's anything you could call out on how you think about the progression there? I think you started with the clean room piece and then expanded into more measurement and analytics.
Does that progression capture the general strategy? And maybe any thoughts on what the long-term monetization opportunity looks like?.
Yes. Dean, thanks for asking that question. I think what you just described is a trend not just at that particular partner but indeed an opportunity we see across all major publishers. In a world where publishers are authenticating and building their own valuable first-party data sets, in some case, it could be retail purchase information.
It could be audience engagement or viewership. It could be demographic information. Depending on the partner, they each have a pretty unique data set. And so it's an incredible opportunity for us to work with them in a number of ways.
Number one, to ensure that they can continue to have authenticated users and deploy targeting that is even more powerful than perhaps what they had in a world of cookies, more precise and certainly more consumer-friendly.
Number two, to prove definitively especially in a market where there's still some uncertainty, ample uncertainty around where things are going from a macroeconomic perspective. It is the case that almost every CEO turns to their CMO and says, prove to me that our advertising is working.
So those publishers or partners that can prove that their audiences, monetize better respond to advertisements more effectively and can make the definitive ROI case are going to attract more dollars than those that can't.
And then finally, where does that go? I think ultimately, it goes to a decade of really interesting collaborations between all these partners and advertisers and potentially other partners as well and their publisher partners.
Everybody has unique data and now that it's possible to collaborate in a way that doesn't expose you to risk, doesn't expose the movement of data and is consumer-friendly. I think some really interesting things are possible. And what I like best of all, I mentioned this earlier, is we're neutral, we're agnostic. We work with everyone.
And so often, we can be right in the middle of all the fun..
There are no further questions at this time. I will turn the call back to Lauren Dillard..
Thanks so much, and thanks, everyone, for joining us today. I'd love to conclude with just a few final thoughts. First, Q1 represented a strong start to the year, and we're making consistent progress against the key initiatives we've talked about on recent calls.
Next, while we like our momentum exiting the quarter, a single quarter does not make a trend, it is still early. And given this, we've attempted to be balanced and conservative with respect to our outlook for the remainder of the year.
And finally, while not yet fully reflected in our results, we are encouraged by the ongoing momentum in our sales bookings and improvements in churn and down sell that we believe put us on a path to return to double-digit revenue growth. With that, I look forward to speaking with many of you in the days and weeks ahead. Thanks again for joining..
This concludes today's conference call. Thank you for joining. You may now disconnect your lines..