image
Consumer Defensive - Packaged Foods - NYSE - US
$ 21.57
-1.19 %
$ 4.54 B
Market Cap
18.92
P/E
EARNINGS CALL TRANSCRIPT
EARNINGS CALL TRANSCRIPT 2015 - Q4
image
Executives

J.T. Rieck - Managing Director of Investor Relations/Financial Analysis Allen L. Shiver - President, Chief Executive Officer & Director R. Steve Kinsey - Chief Financial Officer & Executive Vice President.

Analysts

Farha Aslam - Stephens, Inc. Eric R. Katzman - Deutsche Bank Securities, Inc. Timothy S. Ramey - Pivotal Research Group LLC Amit Sharma - BMO Capital Markets (United States) Akshay Jagdale - Jefferies LLC Brett Michael Hundley - BB&T Capital Markets.

Operator

Welcome to the Flowers Foods' Fourth Quarter and Full Year Earnings Conference Call and Webcast. My name is Ellen, and I will be your operator for today's call. At this time, all participants are in a listen-only mode. Later we will conduct a question-and-answer session. Please note that this conference is being recorded.

I will now turn the call over to J.T. Rieck, Managing Director, Investor Relations. Mr. Rieck, you may begin..

J.T. Rieck - Managing Director of Investor Relations/Financial Analysis

Thank you Ellen and good morning everyone. We realize today is a very busy day with multiple earnings releases and calls, so we appreciate you taking the time to join our call. Our fourth quarter and full year 2015 results were released yesterday evening and we expect to file the 10-K before the end of this month.

You'll find the earnings release on the Flowers Foods' website. Slide presentation that supports our discussion today is posted on the conference call page along with the information about our independent distributor program and our updated two-page factsheet.

Before we begin, please be aware that our presentation today may include forward-looking statements about our company's performance. Although we believe those statements to be reasonable, they are subject to risks and uncertainties that could cause actual results to differ materially.

In addition to matters we'll discuss during the call, important factors relating to Flowers Foods business are fully detailed in our SEC filings. Before we get started with our discussion of the quarter and year's results, I want to alert you that Flowers Foods will host its Investor Briefing at the New York Stock Exchange on Wednesday, April 13.

Now let's get started. Participating on our call today, we have Allen Shiver, Flowers Foods' President and Chief Executive Officer; and Steve Kinsey, our Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer. We will open your call – open the call for your questions following our prepared remarks. Now Allen, I'll turn the call over to you..

Allen L. Shiver - President, Chief Executive Officer & Director

its killer taste and texture and ingredients that are organic and non-GMO. The brand itself will remain headquartered in Oregon, where the team's innovation and grassroots marketing efforts continue to drive excitement and grow sales. Looking ahead, as our guidance demonstrates, we expect 2016 to be a year of strong growth for Flowers.

Our brands are performing well relative to the category, which helps us grow share across our geographic reach. In addition, we are working to realize the growth potential from our recent acquisitions.

Before I turn the call over to Steve for the financial review, I want to take this opportunity to recognize and thank the Flowers' team members who continue to work tirelessly to produce the fresh quality bread and baked goods that our company is known for.

I also want to thank the thousands of independent distributors who, as demonstrated during the recent winter storms, continue to meet the needs of retailers and foodservice customers in their territories. We recognize that there may be some questions in the marketplace on the independent distributor business model.

It is important to remember that our competitors and others across a broad range of industries use very similar models. Flowers has utilized the independent distributor program for over 30 years. During that time, thousands of these entrepreneurs have grown their business and built wealth.

As I am out in the market, I often encounter distributors and it is a pleasure to hear their stories first-hand as they talk proudly about how they've grown their business. I'm confident in the distributor program; it is good for both the distributor and good for Flowers.

Recently, we posted on our website some additional information about the program as well as a few frequently asked questions. That information can be found at FlowersFoods.com. With that, I'll turn it over to Steve..

R. Steve Kinsey - Chief Financial Officer & Executive Vice President

Thank you, Allen, and good morning everyone. I'll start by going over the items that affect year-over-year comparisons for both the quarter and the year. Then I'll discuss the fourth quarter and fiscal 2015 results, and finally, take a look at our outlook for fiscal 2016.

Turning to slide nine, as Allen mentioned, it is important to remember that 2014 was a 53-week fiscal year and 2015 was a 52-week fiscal year. The extra week contributed approximately $63.2 million to sales and approximately $0.01 to earnings per share for fiscal 2014. As you know, during the back half of the year, we made two acquisitions.

Acquisition-related sales contributed $39.7 million during the quarter and approximately $49.5 million during the year. As expected, the acquisitions were neutral to earnings per share for both the quarter and the year. This year, adjusted EPS was $0.16 in the fourth quarter and $0.92 for the full year of fiscal 2015.

The net effect of one-time items decreased reported earnings per share by $0.01 for the quarter and by $0.03 per share for the full year. Looking back at 2014, adjusted EPS was $0.20 in the fourth quarter and $0.90 per share for fiscal year 2014.

The net effect of one-time items in 2014 decreased reported EPS by $0.07 per share in the quarter and $0.08 for the full year. For more detail, please reference the non-GAAP reconciliations at the end of our slide presentation. Turning to the fourth quarter comments on slide 10.

As Allen mentioned, our results fell below our expectations in the quarter, driven primarily by softness in the topline. Looking back to November when we revised our guidance, we expected sales growth to moderate, but not to the extent we experienced.

With sales being less than anticipated, we were unable to leverage our cost structure, which resulted in earnings per share coming in below our guidance. Acquisitions performed relatively in line. And when looking across the business there was no one key factor that drove the topline.

As Allen said, during the quarter, we experienced more of a broad-based step down from the growth rates we saw in the second quarter and third quarter, which was also reflected somewhat in channel data for the category and food retail in general. Cash flow from operations was up over 2014.

We made capital investments and acquisitions to support the growth. We increased our dividend in 2015 and we repurchased shares. The full year consolidated gross margin remained flat, fourth quarter gross margin was 46.9%, down 140 basis points as compared to 48.3% in the fourth quarter last year.

In total, acquisitions negatively impacted the gross margin approximately 80 basis points as a percent of sales in the fourth quarter and approximately 30 basis points as a percent of sales for the full year. The impact from acquisitions is primarily the result of increased purchases of outside product, as well as higher cost for organic ingredients.

Excluding acquisitions, the decrease in gross margin during the fourth quarter is primarily due to cost inefficiencies as a result of sales coming in below plan and higher workforce costs driven primarily by higher head count to support our growth.

While acquisitions did impact gross margins negatively, they were a positive impact to selling, distribution and administrative costs, decreasing SG&A as a percent of sales. As a result, the impact of acquisitions to our adjusted EBITDA margin was minimal as a percent of sales for both the quarter and the year.

Adjusted EBITDA margin for the full year was 11.7%, an increase of 30 basis points over the prior year. This fiscal 2015 full-year increase in EBITDA margins was driven by lower ingredient costs, offset by higher workforce-related costs.

Adjusted EBITDA margin in the fourth quarter was 10.1%, down approximately 50 basis points over last year's fourth quarter adjusted EBITDA margin. The decrease in fourth quarter EBITDA margin is primarily due to gross margin contraction associated with a higher workforce cost.

For the DSD segment, adjusted EBITDA margin expansion for the full year was driven primarily by higher sales and lower ingredient costs as a percent of sales, offset by higher workforce-related costs. During the quarter, DSD adjusted EBITDA margins declined due to sales being below expectations.

The expansion in the Warehouse segment's EBITDA margin for both the quarter and the year was primarily due to lower ingredient and workforce-related costs, driven by improved sales mix. In the quarter, lower than expected sales offset a portion of the margin increase.

Adjusted corporate costs were elevated this year due primarily to higher consulting and legal costs. In the fourth quarter, consulting costs abated as expected, while legal costs remained elevated.

Fourth quarter carrying costs associated with the acquired Hostess bakeries were $2.3 million and for the full year, total carrying costs declined $6.6 million to $12.8 million as expected.

Early in 2016, we sold an additional bakery, which leaves us with eight closed bakeries, six remain under evaluation and we continued to market two non-strategic facilities. Net interest expense in the quarter was $1.5 million and we ended the year with total debt of just over $1 billion. Our net debt to adjusted EBITDA leverage is 2.3 times.

Maintaining a favorable credit profile is a priority for us. Prior to closing the acquisitions, we had reduced our debt by approximately $143 million. Also during the year, Standard & Poor's upgraded our credit rating from BBB minus to BBB.

With an eye toward maximizing shareholder value, we continue to balance capital allocation opportunities between strategic acquisitions, debt reduction, dividends and share repurchases.

Flowers has a strong foundation and we anticipate continued consolidation within our industry which supports our philosophy of maintaining conservative financial profile to take advantage of acquisitions. We also recognize the importance of returning capital to shareholders.

We have steadily increased our dividend over the years and have made – also made opportunistic share repurchases. Adjusted EPS for the year increased 2.2% to $0.92 for the full year. For the quarter, adjusted EPS was $0.16, down 20% from the fourth quarter last year. Adjusted EPS was approximately 4% below the low end of our revised guidance.

As detailed in the press release, of the shortfall, approximately $0.03 is related to the below sales expectations.

The remaining $0.01 per share is a result of costs related to our distributable program and new marketing expansion costs incurred in the fourth quarter related to our organic acquisition that was pulled forward from the first quarter of 2016.

Looking ahead to 2016, as stated in the press release, we expect sales for the fiscal year to be in the range of $3.96 billion and $4.08 billion or 5.5% to 8% growth over fiscal 2015. EPS is expected to be in the range of $0.98 to $1.04 per share.

As we stated when we announced the acquisitions, we were targeting total sales from our organic brands to be between $245 million and $265 million, increasing so consolidated sales by 5.2% to 5.7% after backing out the results from 2015.

Also, we see sales growth of approximately 0.3% to 2.3%, driven by a combined net impact of price, mix and volume from our revised promotional strategies, as well as growth from expansion markets. We see EBITDA margins expanding, driven by improved efficiency and leveraging our recent investments to support growth in expansion markets.

We expect costs associated with the conversion of the Tuscaloosa facility into organic production will impact first quarter earnings per share by approximately $0.01 per share.

Included in the recent acquisitions, we now forecast the full-year depreciation and amortization to be approximately $145 million to $150 million, and full-year net interest expense to be $10 million to $11 million. Our forecasted tax rate is approximately 35.9%.

We anticipate capital expenditures in 2016 to be in the range of $90 million to $100 million. For the past decade, Flowers has delivered strong shareholder returns by entering new markets and expanding our product offerings.

As our recent acquisitions demonstrate, there is opportunity for Flowers to continue to execute on this strategy by taking advantage of the changing consumer landscape and continued industry consolidation, as well as gaining share with our current brand portfolio.

Our strong financial position and experienced team gives us confidence in our ability to deliver value to shareholders. Thank you, and now, we'll turn the call back to Allen..

Allen L. Shiver - President, Chief Executive Officer & Director

Thank you, Steve. Simply put, 2015 was not the year it could have been. That being said, we made important progress positioning the company for future growth in 2016 and beyond. Our team is committed to executing on the opportunities before us. I have confidence in our 2016 guidance. We participate in one of the largest categories in the supermarket.

And our brands are among the strongest in their segments. The competitive landscape continues to consolidate and we have opportunities to expand our market share in both new segments and in new markets. Thank you for your time. And now, let's open the line for questions..

Operator

Thank you. We will now begin the question-and-answer session. Our first question is from Farha Aslam with Stephens..

Farha Aslam - Stephens, Inc.

Hi, good morning..

Allen L. Shiver - President, Chief Executive Officer & Director

Good morning, Farha..

Farha Aslam - Stephens, Inc.

Two questions, the first one is on sales. You discussed sales slowed in December.

Could you just give us some color on how they're starting off in January and your thoughts on the cadence of sales going into 2016?.

Allen L. Shiver - President, Chief Executive Officer & Director

As far as sales, as with many other food companies, sales were soft in quarter four, not just December, but for the majority of quarter four. We're encouraged that we've started this year in line with our expectations and we're looking forward to the year ahead..

Farha Aslam - Stephens, Inc.

Okay. And the second question relates to your cost of goods sold versus pricing. We would have thought you would get more of a benefit from the lower commodity input costs.

Could you share with us kind of what your ingredient basket outlook is for 2016 and how much you expect to keep versus how much will have to be passed on in the form of lower pricing?.

R. Steve Kinsey - Chief Financial Officer & Executive Vice President

Sure. I'm assuming you're talking about 2016..

Farha Aslam - Stephens, Inc.

Exactly..

R. Steve Kinsey - Chief Financial Officer & Executive Vice President

Yeah, looking ahead to 2016, obviously, you've seen a nice pullback in the wheat markets. And overall the general input basket, there is a nice tailwind coming into 2016. Saying that, there are some other costs that will be up, workforce costs will be up.

There will also be some continued costs related to the integration of the two recent acquisitions as well as some costs related to continued growing in our expansion markets. So, from that perspective, it's not a wash, but we will see some offset of the tailwinds for 2016.

Looking at the total basket for 2016, you're looking at mid-single-digit to slightly below from a – percent decrease year-over-year..

Farha Aslam - Stephens, Inc.

Great. Thanks for the added color..

Allen L. Shiver - President, Chief Executive Officer & Director

Thank you, Farha..

Operator

The next question is from Eric Katzman with Deutsche Bank..

Eric R. Katzman - Deutsche Bank Securities, Inc.

Hi. Good morning, everybody..

Allen L. Shiver - President, Chief Executive Officer & Director

Good morning, Eric..

Eric R. Katzman - Deutsche Bank Securities, Inc.

A couple of questions, Maybe to follow up on some of Farha's line of questions. I guess you had gone through – if you look over the last eight quarters or so, you had managed to get kind of some – either flat, or some pricing for seven of the eight quarters.

And so, what competitively occurred in the fourth quarter that pricing became much more challenging?.

Allen L. Shiver - President, Chief Executive Officer & Director

Eric, in certain core markets, we had competitive situations that we had to meet our market share or protect our market share. We are encouraged with IRI. You can look at the last quarter and really the month of December, the IRI number showed that there is improvement in competitive pricing.

And I mentioned on the call earlier that we have pricing underway, that is already being put into place last quarter. But we also are looking at our promotional activity to make sure that we get the return expected whenever there is a price promotion on a certain item. So, pricing is top priority, it has been, especially in the back half of last year.

And we expect to see results of that as we move forward..

Eric R. Katzman - Deutsche Bank Securities, Inc.

And Allen, would you say that the competitive pricing environment in the fourth quarter, was that a function of your branded competitors, or retailers and their private-label program, or both?.

Allen L. Shiver - President, Chief Executive Officer & Director

It was primarily branded competitors..

Eric R. Katzman - Deutsche Bank Securities, Inc.

Okay. And then Steve, I guess to the extent that you're forecasting core top-line growth that's very modest looking forward, including some expansion markets, which are typically like 1% or so.

So, when you look forward, are you assuming that price is kind of flattish, or what have you kind of built in to the forecast?.

R. Steve Kinsey - Chief Financial Officer & Executive Vice President

Sure. When you look at the upper end of that range, Eric, we're assuming roughly 1% to 1.5% of price mix and roughly 1% volume on the core business, with the rest coming from acquisitions. And on the low end of the range, we're assuming flattish price mix and slight volume increases on the core business..

Eric R. Katzman - Deutsche Bank Securities, Inc.

Okay.

And I know you can't talk specifically about the IO litigation, but can you just say how much legal expense occurred in 2015 and what you're kind of assuming in 2016?.

R. Steve Kinsey - Chief Financial Officer & Executive Vice President

Looking to 2015, obviously – and thank you for understanding, we can't really discuss the specifics of the cost itself, but for the year, we were up roughly $5 million to $6 million with regard to legal expenses. So, it was a couple of pennies from an impact perspective.

And then going into 2016, obviously, with the number of lawsuits increasing, we are forecasting that to be up slightly at this point..

Eric R. Katzman - Deutsche Bank Securities, Inc.

All right. And then I guess the last question – I guess I was a little bit – I think on the last call, you said that part of the acquisition challenge was – or the margins on the acquisitions was because demand was strong enough that you kind of had to use some contract manufacturers, et cetera, and that threw the production efficiencies off.

And so, that comment would suggest that demand for the organic side of things was pretty good. But even with that and the understanding that they're not huge businesses, but even with that, sales came in obviously below plan.

So kind of how do I gauge the success of the acquisition so far? Is demand still strong enough that it's screwing up your efficiencies by using outside manufacturing?.

R. Steve Kinsey - Chief Financial Officer & Executive Vice President

Yeah, when you look at the acquisitions in the fourth quarter, primarily the Alpine acquisition, the big risk is when you begin integration, things starting to maybe fall off slightly. There was some business that was projected to come in the fourth quarter with Alpine, it did not come about.

But the good thing is we're actually beginning to see that business come to fruition in the first quarter of 2016. So that did impact the projections for the organic business in 2015. So from a margin perspective, however, what I would say is we will continue to buy from co-packers.

Prior to the acquisition, Dave's was actually using quite a few co-packers primarily for distribution across the total U.S. As we ramp up that distribution, Tuscaloosa facility will primary fulfill part of the demand in the Southeast. So obviously we'll continue to have to rely on co-packers for Midwest markets and the Northern markets as well.

So that impact to gross margin will continue through the year, but we will see improvements over that as we move production into our Tuscaloosa facility..

Allen L. Shiver - President, Chief Executive Officer & Director

And Eric, just a comment on consumer demand, it remained strong and will remain strong for organics as we look forward. So, the sales adjustment Steve mentioned is more a function of timing, the consumer demand for organics is still extremely strong..

Eric R. Katzman - Deutsche Bank Securities, Inc.

Okay. I'll pass it on. Thank you..

Allen L. Shiver - President, Chief Executive Officer & Director

Thank you..

Operator

The next question is from Tim Ramey with Pivotal Research Group..

Timothy S. Ramey - Pivotal Research Group LLC

Hi, good morning. Thanks..

Allen L. Shiver - President, Chief Executive Officer & Director

Good morning, Tim..

Timothy S. Ramey - Pivotal Research Group LLC

I had a question about the sales outlook versus the statement you made in the FAQ section of the independent distributor piece on your website. So, I mean, one of the key issues here is independence and how much control the IDs have over how their distributorship is run. None of these cases are going to get settled this year, I'm pretty sure.

But I guess my assumption is that you would back off from some of the kind of more overt control steps, making drivers deliver to Dollar Store's, Burger King's and so on where they really don't view those as profitable stops. And that would have an impact on 2016 sales.

How do you think about balancing those two needs to continue to have sales growth, but also to make sure that you're not being too aggressive on the control of their business?.

Allen L. Shiver - President, Chief Executive Officer & Director

Tim, some of the comments you just made, we do not agree with. Our independent distributors are independent business people. They run their business. They are in charge of their operations. And the items that you just mentioned are not accurate. We are continuing to be very confident in our independent distributor model.

The lawsuits that are in place, we believe, do not have merit and our intention is to vigorously defend our position. And that being said, really today is about earnings and we'll be happy to take it offline if you have further questions..

Timothy S. Ramey - Pivotal Research Group LLC

Okay. Thank you..

Operator

The next question is from Amit Sharma with BMO Capital Markets..

Amit Sharma - BMO Capital Markets (United States)

Hi, good morning everyone..

Allen L. Shiver - President, Chief Executive Officer & Director

Good morning, Amit..

Amit Sharma - BMO Capital Markets (United States)

Steve, a couple of modeling questions first.

From a margin perspective, acquisitions, are they still expected to be gross margin dilutive in 2016? And will they remain dilutive as long as you're buying from co-packers?.

R. Steve Kinsey - Chief Financial Officer & Executive Vice President

Yeah, from a gross margin perspective, you will see them remain dilutive as we continue to buy from our co-packers. But again, that is key to the integration of the acquisitions and making sure we have the production to meet the market needs.

What you will see though, with the Tuscaloosa facility coming on line at the end of the first quarter, you will see that impact begin to abate some as the year progresses..

Amit Sharma - BMO Capital Markets (United States)

And when do you expect to be fully producing the Organic Bread segment or anytime soon?.

R. Steve Kinsey - Chief Financial Officer & Executive Vice President

I mean I think when you look at the demand for the products and you look at the production capacity, Tuscaloosa will only meet some of the incremental needs. We will, over the next two years to three years, will continue to rely on some co-pack production to be able to fill markets.

But again, as we bring more of that into Tuscaloosa, some of that into Alpine, you will see the impact of that begin to decrease..

Amit Sharma - BMO Capital Markets (United States)

But given that this has lower SG&A structure, is it at least accretive on an operating margin basis or not yet?.

R. Steve Kinsey - Chief Financial Officer & Executive Vice President

Yeah, from an operating margin perspective, we do anticipate they will be accretive. Looking at – in 2016, we do expect $0.03 to $0.05 accretion from the acquisitions from our earnings perspective..

Amit Sharma - BMO Capital Markets (United States)

All right.

And then you said legal expense is slightly higher in 2016, were you saying incremental $5 million to $6 million or more than that or are you saying incrementally just sort of maybe a couple of million higher than they were in 2015?.

R. Steve Kinsey - Chief Financial Officer & Executive Vice President

At this point, it's hard to forecast that, Amit. Again those costs can be lumpy from quarter-to-quarter..

Amit Sharma - BMO Capital Markets (United States)

Right..

R. Steve Kinsey - Chief Financial Officer & Executive Vice President

Looking at 2015 we were up roughly $5 million to $6 million and then projecting for 2016 currently, we're just saying – we anticipate incremental..

Amit Sharma - BMO Capital Markets (United States)

Okay. And then Steve, from – sorry – Allen, from a longer-term perspective, I mean, yes, we definitely hear what's happening from a category perspective.

But this lack of visibility, even in the near term, is very surprising, right? And it raises serious question that do we have the ability to lead the category in terms of pricing, promotions or other growth initiatives? I mean, I hear that some of the competitive activity is beyond your control, but at this time, what can you tell us that gives us a little bit more confidence that this isn't going to happen again in the first quarter, second quarter or the rest of the year at this point?.

Allen L. Shiver - President, Chief Executive Officer & Director

Amit, again looking at the fourth quarter, the market was soft and we have heard that from retailers. We've heard it from other food companies. And whatever the reasons were, whether it was weather that was warmer than usual or other reasons, the fourth quarter was soft.

I don't see any of the factors that influenced the fourth quarter dramatically changing the profile going forward. We're, as I mentioned earlier, we've started this year pretty much on track from a sales standpoint. We're very excited about the brand portfolio that our company has.

When you look at the brands we've developed and the brands that we've acquired, now we have a strong brand in every segment of the marketplace. And the good news is that there's a lot of room to grow from a market share standpoint.

I'd like to point out the specialty bread category and also the breakfast category are our two segments that are very much underdeveloped. Dave's Killer Bread and Alpine, again those also fit well in underdeveloped segments. So we have opportunities from a brand standpoint. We also have opportunities from a geographical expansion standpoint.

Even though that we have – we're now serving 85% of the U.S. with DSD distribution, a large percent of that, our market share is underdeveloped because we haven't been there that long.

So, we have tremendous opportunity to grow in new markets like Omaha, Indy, Kansas City, Denver; the list goes on and on, that we have tremendous opportunity to grow our market share simply by developing our brands in these new markets.

So – and I think it's also worth reminding that this fresh bakery category is the third largest category in the supermarket. And so, even the category is flat to down slightly, it's still the third largest category, which is significant.

So, we're bullish about 2016, and we feel like we have all the elements of growth that are going to be needed in place..

Amit Sharma - BMO Capital Markets (United States)

Allen, I think I appreciate that. And I think the longer term view or longer term picture is clear, like what the opportunity is. But what happens when you have a couple of disappointing quarters and even the guidance doesn't look like it's going to get you back on track completely. That's what I'm trying to get a better sense of.

Like – and appreciate the detail on pricing on your different categories in the presentation. But if you look at pricing trend, one of your biggest competitor has taken more pricing in the last year than you have, right.

So, that's what I'm thinking going forward – and you talk about being more focused on pricing, but is it beyond your control if that competitor comes back and is no longer taking pricing? Are you still able to take pricing in this environment or no?.

Allen L. Shiver - President, Chief Executive Officer & Director

Amit, at the end of the day, the consumer determines what the correct price is for products. We're running our offense based on our cost structure and what price should be for our products. And based on what happens in the marketplace, we'll make adjustments if necessary.

But we're very confident in all of the work that has already been done to maximize pricing, whether that's promotional pricing or increases in everyday pricing..

Amit Sharma - BMO Capital Markets (United States)

And the last one is, the discussion that you've had with retailers, they seem open to that opportunity that you have on pricing, or hard to negotiate?.

Allen L. Shiver - President, Chief Executive Officer & Director

Yeah. Through category management, our retailers realize the profit contribution that this fresh bakery category makes to their store. And they understand the need for improved pricing. Again, that is a general statement. You do have specific supermarkets or retailers that may have a different philosophy.

But in general, the retail trade understands the value from a profit standpoint of the category..

Amit Sharma - BMO Capital Markets (United States)

Got it. Thank you very much..

Allen L. Shiver - President, Chief Executive Officer & Director

Thank you..

Operator

The next question is from Akshay Jagdale with Jefferies..

Akshay Jagdale - Jefferies LLC

Hi, good morning..

Allen L. Shiver - President, Chief Executive Officer & Director

Good morning, Akshay..

Akshay Jagdale - Jefferies LLC

I just wanted to understand a little bit better what happened this quarter. I understand you are calling out category softness, but maybe I'm missing something.

But from a category perspective, sequentially, the growth slowed down, it seems like, by 50 basis points or 60 basis points and your DSD sales slowed down sequentially organic growth by about 340 basis points.

And then in November, the guidance you gave in November versus where you ended up, you missed by about $50 million or 4% relative to your own expectations for the quarter with less than two months remaining, right? So, I understand there was a softness, I get it.

But the softness from what we're seeing and the data you presented about categories doesn't seem nearly as much as the numbers that you reported.

So, what am I missing there?.

R. Steve Kinsey - Chief Financial Officer & Executive Vice President

When you look at the components of the growth primarily in DSD, I think, Eric mentioned it earlier; we did see some pricing softness. When you look at price mix, it was relatively flat for the quarter.

We had seen some improvement from that perspective in the first three quarters, so that did fall off in the fourth quarter and continued to progressively probably decelerate a little bit or accelerate a little bit more than we had anticipated.

As I mentioned, the Alpine acquisition did come in slightly below plan, so some of that business did not come on as we had anticipated. That was roughly, I think, $9 million to $10 million of revenue. And then our volume and DSD did get softer in the fourth quarter than we had anticipated as well.

We did not have as strong of a holiday around Thanksgiving or Christmas than we had forecasted. So those were two big factors and part of the falloff as well..

Akshay Jagdale - Jefferies LLC

Is there something going on – I mean, the DSD business inherently has more visibility than warehouse, right, because you're getting data pretty regularly. And your category has pretty high turns as well. So it's not like there's some inventory reductions that you're seeing at large customers either.

So, I know there was a slight category slowdown, but you had a pretty – you had a more pronounced slowdown in your own sales. So, I appreciate the color on sort of the pieces, the acquisition coming in a bit lower than expected, but you had a $50 million miss with two months to go on the DSD business. So, I'm just a little bit lost there.

Is it a share issue? Is it customer reducing inventory? Because in the measured channel, we don't see that level of a slowdown, if you understand where I'm going with that..

R. Steve Kinsey - Chief Financial Officer & Executive Vice President

Yeah. From a share perspective, we actually, I think, improved our share slightly within our DSD business. Again, part of it is just from an execution standpoint, we didn't meet some of the targets we had set. And then another factor would be obviously some of the slowdown in the category.

But generally speaking, there's really no one factor that we can point to..

Akshay Jagdale - Jefferies LLC

Okay.

And then just taking a – sorry?.

R. Steve Kinsey - Chief Financial Officer & Executive Vice President

Akshay, I was going to add that if you look at the IRI data for the quarter, obviously the category was down slightly, but our share did not decline. So, any sales that we did not capitalize on did not to go to competition. We still maintain our growth trend within the category.

But the problem is that the category declined in the fourth quarter for, as Steve said, a multitude of reasons..

Akshay Jagdale - Jefferies LLC

Okay. And then just taking a little bit of a long-term view, taking into account the midpoint of your guidance and sort of taking out the acquisition contribution. So, if you take out $0.04 from your $1.01 guidance for 2016, get to $0.97, and if you meet that number you would have grown EPS at a CAGR of 2% over three years.

I know there's – the base there has a massive growth number. But you've been talking a lot about long-term opportunities for growth, market share gains, etcetera, etcetera.

Can you just help us understand then in that context why should – if there's opportunities for growth, you have commodity costs down, you have rational pricing starting to take hold, why should a company like yours with good execution only grow at a 2% CAGR over a three-year period?.

R. Steve Kinsey - Chief Financial Officer & Executive Vice President

When you look over the last two years we've made several acquisitions, there has been a lot of cost coming into the system. Obviously based on the topline performance you can see we've not gained the topline growth that we had forecasted.

So as you look to 2016 and coming off a couple of quarters here where there's been, from a earnings perspective and a topline perspective, we feel like, we're cautiously optimistic coming into the year, but what I would say is as we look at the growth opportunities we're betting down (49:00) a lot of that in 2016.

We have a history of being the low cost producer. So if cost and revenue aren't matching, we'll take the necessary measures to make sure that cost is in line with the revenue structure.

But I do believe with this organic acquisition, the on-trend growth there, we have a significant opportunity to get back on track from a revenue perspective, and then if we hit our revenue targets then you should see the earnings come back in line with what you would expect from Flowers from a growth perspective as well..

Akshay Jagdale - Jefferies LLC

Yeah. That's helpful. I just feel like the focus could be more on margin enhancement. Just looking at the category it doesn't seem like there's a lot of growth left ahead that's margin enhancing, right, or margin accretive. I mean, you're trying to grow share, but the margins are getting hurt as a result.

So, I mean, I think shareholders would also appreciate it if you're focused a little bit more on margins instead of just expansion. But that's just a comment, but thanks for taking my questions..

R. Steve Kinsey - Chief Financial Officer & Executive Vice President

Yeah, thank you..

Operator

The next question is from Bill Chappell with SunTrust..

R. Steve Kinsey - Chief Financial Officer & Executive Vice President

Good morning, Bill.

Hello?.

Operator

Bill, your line is open. We'll go to the next question. It's from Brett Hundley with BB&T Capital Markets..

R. Steve Kinsey - Chief Financial Officer & Executive Vice President

Good morning, Brett..

Brett Michael Hundley - BB&T Capital Markets

Hey. Good morning, guys. Thank you. I wanted to just tag one more question on to pricing just to make sure I'm crystal clear, Steve.

So, within your guidance it sounds like you're assuming anywhere between zero and 1.5% price impact, and can we assume that the majority of that assumption will be realized in Q1, and then thereafter assuming no decisions are made relative to demand trends that your full benefit of expectations would then flow in in following quarters?.

R. Steve Kinsey - Chief Financial Officer & Executive Vice President

Yes. You should see in the first quarter of 2016 some of the pricing actions take fruition. And you should see a majority of those will be in place for most of the quarter..

Brett Michael Hundley - BB&T Capital Markets

For Q1?.

R. Steve Kinsey - Chief Financial Officer & Executive Vice President

Q1. Yes..

Brett Michael Hundley - BB&T Capital Markets

Okay, all right. I appreciate the clarification there. And then I wanted to go back, Allen, to just the soft variety competition in core markets during the quarter.

You can tell me if I'm just misunderstanding you, but the way that you had said it leads me to believe that maybe competition in soft variety wasn't as heightened in some of your more expansion markets relative to core markets, am I my understanding you correctly there?.

Allen L. Shiver - President, Chief Executive Officer & Director

Bill (sic) [Brett], of course our Nature's Own brand is the number one brand in soft variety. Price competition is different from one market to the other. We did have some activity in our core markets that we had to react to.

But we also in expansion markets, we basically are growing our Nature's Own brand and expansion markets by being very competitive with the market leader as we move forward. So there's really no – it's a market-by-market situation. And we want to make sure that we protect our brand share. But at the same time, we're very focused on maximizing margins.

So, we have a lot of focus on making sure that we're making the right decisions when it comes to pricing..

Brett Michael Hundley - BB&T Capital Markets

Allen, what do you think led to heightened competition in that category in your core markets. I mean, do you think that it was just maybe that you had lagged on pricing relative to some competitors. I know we're here in the Virginia market and we had seen pretty good trends here in this market. We saw a little bit of a de-emphasis on private label.

We saw some pretty good price gaps actually. And we saw some pretty good pricing from some of your competitors.

And so I'm just curious if you have a sense on what led to that heightened competition in your core markets and if you really think that that can sustainably get better here maybe as you follow on with additional pricing as we move into 2016?.

Allen L. Shiver - President, Chief Executive Officer & Director

Yeah, as I mentioned earlier, our average price in the soft variety category is roughly 9% higher than the market. So because we have the number one brand, our competition is always aiming at that brand. But in terms of moving forward, I don't anticipate any deterioration of pricing.

I'm encouraged by the IRI numbers in the fourth quarter showing overall pricing increasing. And as I mentioned earlier we're very focused, starting to see some of the results of that pricing in the last few weeks. So we're optimistic about improving pricing in 2016 not deteriorating pricing..

Brett Michael Hundley - BB&T Capital Markets

Okay. And I know before you've talked about how there can be differences between your performance and IRI data.

But in this specific instance you believe that price trends that are coming through across IRI are a good indicator of what you can see in future performance?.

Allen L. Shiver - President, Chief Executive Officer & Director

Yeah. That's correct..

Brett Michael Hundley - BB&T Capital Markets

Okay. And then just my last question is on merchandising efforts in store. I was just thinking about this the other day, and I'm just curious, kind of, maybe how you measure merchandising effectiveness on a month-to-month or quarter-to-quarter basis. And I'd be interested in any comments you might have on your measurement as of late.

Maybe how you think you're performing from a merchandising effort in store? I appreciate it..

Allen L. Shiver - President, Chief Executive Officer & Director

Yeah. I think that's probably one of our strengths. Our team, whether it's account team or the individual bakeries, we work very closely with the retailers that help them manage their overall bakery department.

And I feel like from a merchandising standpoint they recognize the benefit of strong brands and they also understand that selling branded products is the best thing for their margin.

So I feel like that in terms of merchandising, we have direct influence with many of our retail customers and we're helping them to merchandise their stores to the benefit of their business, which also helps us along the way.

In terms of – actually activity within each individual store, our distributors are very important, the relationship between our distributor and that local store manager, they're able to do things from merchandising standpoint, they can help him build his business as well.

So, really working on merchandising improvement at many different levels, and I like to think that's one of our distributors' strength and one of our strength..

Brett Michael Hundley - BB&T Capital Markets

Thank you..

Allen L. Shiver - President, Chief Executive Officer & Director

Thank you..

Operator

And we have no further questions. At this time, I'd like to turn the call back to Allen Shiver for closing remarks..

Allen L. Shiver - President, Chief Executive Officer & Director

Very good. Again, thank you for your interest in our company. We're excited about 2016 and the momentum that we have moving forward into the New Year. And we look forward to visiting with you at the end of the quarter. Thank you for your attention this morning..

Operator

Thank you, ladies and gentlemen. This concludes today's conference. Thank you for participating. You may now disconnect..

ALL TRANSCRIPTS
2024 Q-3 Q-2 Q-1
2023 Q-4 Q-3 Q-2 Q-1
2022 Q-4 Q-3 Q-2 Q-1
2021 Q-4 Q-3 Q-2 Q-1
2020 Q-4 Q-3 Q-2 Q-1
2019 Q-4 Q-3 Q-2 Q-1
2018 Q-4 Q-3 Q-2 Q-1
2017 Q-4 Q-3 Q-2 Q-1
2016 Q-4 Q-3 Q-2 Q-1
2015 Q-4 Q-3 Q-2 Q-1
2014 Q-4 Q-3 Q-2 Q-1