MGIC Investment Corporation

MGIC Investment Corporation

MTGยทNYSE

$24.86

-0.80%
Financial ServicesInsurance - Specialty

MGIC Investment Corporation, through its subsidiaries, provides private mortgage insurance, other mortgage credit risk management solutions, and ancillary services to lenders and government sponsored entities in the United States, Puerto Rico, and Guam. The company offers primary mortgage insurance that provides mortgage default protection on individual loans, as well as covers unpaid loan principal, delinquent interest, and various expenses associated with the default and subsequent foreclosure. It also provides contract underwriting services, as well as reinsurance. The company serves originators of residential mortgage loans, including savings institutions, commercial banks, mortgage brokers, credit unions, mortgage bankers, and other lenders. MGIC Investment Corporation was founded in 1957 and is headquartered in Milwaukee, Wisconsin.

At a Glance

Live Snapshot
Market Cap$5.26B
EPS3.1700
P/E Ratio7.84
Earnings Date07/29/2026

Intrinsic Alpha Methodology

Thesis Lenses

Signal ยท Driver ยท Risk

Signal

High confidence

Valuation multiple is compressed (P/E 7.8).

Valuation inputs: P/E 7.8, earnings yield +12.8%, momentum -0.8%.

If multiples stay elevated while momentum fades, downside repricing risk rises.

Driver

High confidence

Return profile is acceptable (ROE +14.3%, ROIC +11.1%).

Profitability stack: net margin +60.8%, ROE +14.3%, ROIC +11.1%.

Quality deterioration often appears in margins before it shows up in headline EPS.

Risk

High confidence

Downside profile looks controlled across current risk inputs.

Risk factors: liabilities/assets +22.5%, momentum -0.8%, net margin +60.8%.

Higher leverage with weak momentum and thin margins can amplify drawdown severity.

mtg

MGIC Investment Corporation Market vs Earnings Trajectory

MTG ยท NYSE

Loading price and EPS data...

MGIC Investment Corporation

MGIC Investment Corporation Fair Value Envelope

MTG ยท NYSE

Our analysis suggests that MTG has a fair value of HIDDEN per share in the Base Case projection. With shares currently trading at $24.86, this represents a potential HIDDEN relative to our calculated worth for MGIC Investment Corporation.

Intrinsic Value
Current Price: $24.86
3Y+12.0%
5Y+142.0%
10Y+217.0%
3Y+3.0%
5Y+1.0%
10Y+14.0%
3Y-15.0%
5Y+66.0%
10Y+116.0%
3Y+31.0%
5Y+16.0%
10Y+288.0%
3Y+32.0%
5Y+17.0%
10Y+307.0%
3Y+7.0%
5Y-10.0%
10Y+16.0%
MGIC Investment Corporation

MGIC Investment Corporation Profit Bridge

MTG ยท NYSE
Revenue1.21B
Cost of Goods Sold (61.91M)
Gross Profit1.15B
Operating Expenses (223.24M)
Operating Income928.54M
Interest Expense (34.50M)
Other Income/Expense0.00
Pretax Income928.54M
Income Tax (190.19M)
Net Income738.35M
Net Income
738.35M

Profitability Analysis

Gross Margin

94.9%

Exceptional pricing power and cost management. The company retains over half of revenue after direct costs.

Operating Margin

76.5%

Outstanding operational efficiency. The company generates substantial profit from core operations.

Net Profit Margin

60.8%

Exceptional profitability. The company converts a significant portion of revenue to bottom-line earnings.

Effective Tax Rate

20.5%

Moderate tax rate typical for most corporations. Represents standard tax burden on profits.

Profitability Insight

Exceptional profitability across all levels: Strong pricing power, efficient operations, and healthy bottom line indicate a high-quality business with sustainable competitive advantages.

94.90%
Gross Profit Margin
-6%
3Y-21.0%
5Y+38.0%
10Y+11.0%
76.51%
Operating Profit Margin
-5%
3Y-18.0%
5Y+64.0%
10Y+42.0%
60.84%
Net Profit Margin
-4%
3Y-18.0%
5Y+64.0%
10Y+89.0%
14.34%
Return on Equity
-3%
3Y-23.0%
5Y+51.0%
10Y+7.0%
11.12%
Return on Assets
-5%
3Y-20.0%
5Y+83.0%
10Y+86.0%
11.12%
Return on Invested Capital
-13%
3Y-30.0%
5Y-
10Y+9.0%
MTG

MGIC Investment Corporation Cash Conversion Engine

MTG ยท NYSE
Net Income738.35M
Depreciation & Amortization0.00
Stock-Based Compensation0.00
Change in Working Capital64.18M
Others50.27M
Capital Expenditures-1.02M
Free Cash Flow851.77M

Cash Flow Quality Analysis

FCF Conversion Rate

115.4%

Excellent cash generation. The company converts earnings to cash at or above 100%, indicating high-quality earnings.

CapEx Intensity

0.1%

Asset-light business model. Low capital requirements leave more cash available for shareholders and growth investments.

FCF Growth Trend

+17.7%

Strong FCF growth demonstrates improving cash generation and business momentum. Positive signal for sustainability.

Working Capital Impact

+$64.18M

Working capital inflow boosted cash flow. Efficient management of receivables, inventory, and payables contributing positively.

Cash Flow Quality Insight

Exceptional cash generation: High-quality earnings converting to growing free cash flow. The company demonstrates strong pricing power, efficient operations, and disciplined capital allocation.

mtg

MGIC Investment Corporation Funding & Solvency Profile

MTG ยท NYSE
Cash & Cash Equivalents235.09M
Net Receivables202.48M
Inventory0.00
Other Current Assets14.40M
Total Current Assets6 B
Property, Plant & Equipment31.95M
Goodwill & Intangible Assets7.96M
Long-Term Investments16.30M
Other Non-Current Assets189.96M
Total Non-Current Assets238 M
Total Assets
6.42B

Financial Health Analysis

Current Ratio

10.40x

Excellent liquidity position. The company can easily cover its short-term obligations with substantial cushion.

Debt-to-Equity Ratio

0.27x

Conservative capital structure. The company relies primarily on equity financing, indicating low financial risk.

Working Capital

6 B

Strong working capital position provides significant operational flexibility and financial cushion.

Asset Composition

96% Current

Asset-light business model with high liquidity. Majority of assets are easily convertible to cash.

Financial Health Insight

Strong financial foundation: Excellent liquidity combined with conservative leverage suggests the company is well-positioned to weather economic uncertainties and fund growth opportunities.

mtg

MGIC Investment Corporation Street Expectations Map

MTG ยท NYSE

Wall Street analysts project that MTG stock may rise significantly over the coming 12 months. The consensus 1-year price target stands at 29.00, with estimates ranging from a low of 28.00 to a high of 30.00.

Lowest Target
28.00
12.63%
Consensus Target
29.00
16.65%
Highest Target
30.00
20.68%

The consensus 1-year price target stands at 29.00, with estimates ranging from a low of 28.00 to a high of 30.00.

Analyst Consensus Analysis

Upside Potential

+16.6%

Strong upside potential. Consensus indicates attractive return opportunity with favorable risk-reward profile.

Analyst Agreement

6.9% spread

High analyst agreement. Narrow target range indicates strong consensus on valuation, suggesting clear investment thesis and predictable outlook.

Analyst Conviction

Very High

Strong buy conviction: High upside with tight consensus suggests compelling investment opportunity backed by analyst confidence.

Market Sentiment Insight

Monitor and evaluate: Current analyst consensus suggests limited conviction or near-term catalysts. Stay informed on company developments and reassess positioning as new information emerges.

mtg

MGIC Investment Corporation Insider Positioning

MTG ยท NYSE

During the last 12 months, insiders have sold $23.50M worth of MTG shares, with no buying activity reported.

3 Months

Bought

0

0.00

Sold

171.1K

4.51M

Net Activity

-4.5M

-$4.51M

3-6 Months

Bought

0

0.00

Sold

173.1K

4.69M

Net Activity

-4.7M

-$4.69M

6-9 Months

Bought

0

0.00

Sold

249.2K

6.84M

Net Activity

-6.8M

-$6.84M

9-12 Months

Bought

0

0.00

Sold

279.2K

7.47M

Net Activity

-7.5M

-$7.47M

Top Buyers

No buying activity

Top Sellers

1
MTJ

Mattke Timothy J.

Director, Officer: Chief Executive Officer

480.7K sharesโ€ข4 transactions

$12.79M

2
MSA

Miosi Salvatore A

Officer: President & Coo

310.9K sharesโ€ข11 transactions

$8.55M

3
MPC

Maggio Paula C

Officer: Evp And General Counsel

80.9K sharesโ€ข4 transactions

$2.16M

Insider Activity Analysis

Net Insider Sentiment

Bearish

Strong bearish signal with $23.50M net selling. Heavy insider selling may indicate concerns about valuation or near-term prospects.

Buy/Sell Ratio

0.00:1

Very poor ratio. Heavy selling with minimal buying suggests insiders may be concerned about valuation or outlook.

Recent Trend (3 Months)

$4.51M

Heavy recent selling activity. Recent insider sales notably exceed purchasesโ€”may warrant investigation into company developments.

Insider Participation

High Selling

3 insider sellers vs. 0 buyers. Widespread selling across multiple insiders may signal concerns.

Insider Activity Insight

Multiple red flags: Heavy selling, numerous sellers, and continued recent selling create a concerning pattern. Investigate fundamental drivers and consider whether company guidance or industry conditions have deteriorated.

0.62%
Dividend Yield
23%
3Y-20.0%
5Y+40.0%
10Y-
ย 

mtg Dividend History

MTG
10Y CAGR +0%
Latest $0.15
Annual $0.73
Stable dividend payments
Last Period: +0%