Heritage Insurance Holdings, Inc.

Heritage Insurance Holdings, Inc.

HRTGยทNYSE

$20.88

-1.5%
Financial ServicesInsurance - Property & Casualty

Heritage Insurance Holdings, Inc., through its subsidiaries, provides personal and commercial residential insurance products. The company offers personal residential property insurance for single-family homeowners and condominium owners, and rental property insurance in the states of Alabama, California, Connecticut, Delaware, Florida, Georgia, Hawaii, Maryland, Massachusetts, Mississippi, New Jersey, New York, North Carolina, Rhode Island, South Carolina, and Virginia; commercial residential insurance for properties in Florida, New Jersey, and New York; and licensed in the state of Pennsylvania, as well as personal residential and wind-only property insurance. It also provides restoration, and emergency and recovery services; and property management, and reinsurance services. The company writes personal line policies through a network of retail independent agents, wholesale agents, and a partnership with a direct agency, as well as indirectly to approximately 1,500 retail locations through eight wholesale agency relationships; and personal and commercial insurance policies through a network of approximately 70 independent agencies. Heritage Insurance Holdings, Inc. was founded in 2012 and is headquartered in Tampa, Florida.

At a Glance

Live Snapshot
Market Cap$633.71M
EPS6.3300
P/E Ratio3.30
Earnings Date08/04/2026

Intrinsic Alpha Methodology

Thesis Lenses

Signal ยท Driver ยท Risk

Signal

High confidence

Valuation multiple is compressed (P/E 3.3).

Valuation inputs: P/E 3.3, earnings yield +30.3%, momentum -1.5%.

If multiples stay elevated while momentum fades, downside repricing risk rises.

Driver

High confidence

Return profile is strong (ROE +38.7%, ROIC +26.4%).

Profitability stack: net margin +23.1%, ROE +38.7%, ROIC +26.4%.

Quality deterioration often appears in margins before it shows up in headline EPS.

Risk

High confidence

Risk profile is balanced but has notable pressure points to monitor.

Risk factors: liabilities/assets +77.0%, momentum -1.5%, net margin +23.1%.

Higher leverage with weak momentum and thin margins can amplify drawdown severity.

hrtg

Heritage Insurance Holdings, Inc. Market vs Earnings Trajectory

HRTG ยท NYSE

Loading price and EPS data...

Heritage Insurance Holdings, Inc.

Heritage Insurance Holdings, Inc. Fair Value Envelope

HRTG ยท NYSE

Our analysis suggests that HRTG has a fair value of HIDDEN per share in the Base Case projection. With shares currently trading at $20.88, this represents a potential HIDDEN relative to our calculated worth for Heritage Insurance Holdings, Inc..

Intrinsic Value
Current Price: $20.88
3Y-208.0%
5Y+1818.0%
10Y+455.0%
3Y+28.0%
5Y+43.0%
10Y+93.0%
3Y-227.0%
5Y+1997.0%
10Y+478.0%
3Y-632.0%
5Y+7.0%
10Y+143.0%
3Y-473.0%
5Y+3.0%
10Y+137.0%
3Y-8.0%
5Y+5.0%
10Y+113.0%
Heritage Insurance Holdings, Inc.

Heritage Insurance Holdings, Inc. Profit Bridge

HRTG ยท NYSE
Revenue847.33M
Cost of Goods Sold (313.25M)
Gross Profit534.08M
Operating Expenses (274.82M)
Operating Income259.26M
Interest Expense (7.89M)
Other Income/Expense0.00
Pretax Income259.26M
Income Tax (63.67M)
Net Income195.59M
Net Income
195.59M

Profitability Analysis

Gross Margin

63.0%

Exceptional pricing power and cost management. The company retains over half of revenue after direct costs.

Operating Margin

30.6%

Outstanding operational efficiency. The company generates substantial profit from core operations.

Net Profit Margin

23.1%

Exceptional profitability. The company converts a significant portion of revenue to bottom-line earnings.

Effective Tax Rate

24.6%

Moderate tax rate typical for most corporations. Represents standard tax burden on profits.

Profitability Insight

Exceptional profitability across all levels: Strong pricing power, efficient operations, and healthy bottom line indicate a high-quality business with sustainable competitive advantages.

63.03%
Gross Profit Margin
188%
3Y+8261.0%
5Y+308.0%
10Y-37.0%
30.60%
Operating Profit Margin
202%
3Y-222.0%
5Y+8105.0%
10Y+137.0%
23.08%
Net Profit Margin
206%
3Y-199.0%
5Y+1369.0%
10Y+199.0%
38.71%
Return on Equity
83%
3Y-133.0%
5Y+1736.0%
10Y+309.0%
8.91%
Return on Assets
257%
3Y-238.0%
5Y+1895.0%
10Y+172.0%
26.40%
Return on Invested Capital
-66%
3Y-117.0%
5Y+735.0%
10Y+455.0%
HRTG

Heritage Insurance Holdings, Inc. Cash Conversion Engine

HRTG ยท NYSE
Net Income195.59M
Depreciation & Amortization-779.00K
Stock-Based Compensation5.39M
Change in Working Capital-28.85M
Others8.51M
Capital Expenditures-8.07M
Free Cash Flow174.16M

Cash Flow Quality Analysis

FCF Conversion Rate

89.0%

Strong cash conversion. Most reported earnings translate into actual cash flow, suggesting solid fundamentals.

CapEx Intensity

4.4%

Asset-light business model. Low capital requirements leave more cash available for shareholders and growth investments.

FCF Growth Trend

+120.8%

Strong FCF growth demonstrates improving cash generation and business momentum. Positive signal for sustainability.

Working Capital Impact

-$28.85M

Minimal working capital impact on FCF. Changes in operating assets and liabilities well-managed.

Cash Flow Quality Insight

Asset-light with strong cash conversion: Low capital requirements combined with efficient cash generation creates significant shareholder value through dividends, buybacks, or strategic investments.

hrtg

Heritage Insurance Holdings, Inc. Funding & Solvency Profile

HRTG ยท NYSE
Cash & Cash Equivalents517.07M
Net Receivables93.99M
Inventory0.00
Other Current Assets0.00
Total Current Assets611 M
Property, Plant & Equipment46.75M
Goodwill & Intangible Assets28.64M
Long-Term Investments0.00
Other Non-Current Assets0.00
Total Non-Current Assets47 M
Total Assets
2.02B

Financial Health Analysis

Debt-to-Equity Ratio

2.88x

High financial leverage. Heavy reliance on debt may indicate increased financial risk and potential solvency concerns.

Working Capital

611 M

Strong working capital position provides significant operational flexibility and financial cushion.

Asset Composition

30% Current

Capital-intensive business with significant long-term investments in property, equipment, or intangibles.

hrtg

Heritage Insurance Holdings, Inc. Street Expectations Map

HRTG ยท NYSE

Wall Street analysts project that HRTG stock may rise significantly over the coming 12 months. The consensus 1-year price target stands at 36.00, with estimates ranging from a low of 36.00 to a high of 36.00.

Lowest Target
36.00
72.41%
Consensus Target
36.00
72.41%
Highest Target
36.00
72.41%

The consensus 1-year price target stands at 36.00, with estimates ranging from a low of 36.00 to a high of 36.00.

Analyst Consensus Analysis

Upside Potential

+72.4%

Substantial upside potential. Analysts see significant value gap, suggesting the stock may be materially undervalued at current levels.

Analyst Agreement

0.0% spread

High analyst agreement. Narrow target range indicates strong consensus on valuation, suggesting clear investment thesis and predictable outlook.

Analyst Conviction

Very High

Strong buy conviction: High upside with tight consensus suggests compelling investment opportunity backed by analyst confidence.

Market Sentiment Insight

Rare opportunity: Exceptional upside potential with strong analyst consensus creates a compelling setup. The combination of significant price target premium and tight agreement suggests high-conviction undervaluation that may attract institutional capital.

hrtg

Heritage Insurance Holdings, Inc. Insider Positioning

HRTG ยท NYSE

During the last 12 months, insiders have purchased $24K and sold $4.99M worth of HRTG shares, resulting in $4.97M of net selling activity.

3 Months

Bought

1.0K

24.45K

Sold

86.3K

2.31M

Net Activity

-2.3M

-$2.28M

3-6 Months

Bought

0

0.00

Sold

39.7K

1.08M

Net Activity

-1.1M

-$1.08M

6-9 Months

Bought

0

0.00

Sold

60.2K

1.60M

Net Activity

-1.6M

-$1.60M

9-12 Months

Bought

0

0.00

Sold

0

0.00

Net Activity

+0

+$0

Top Buyers

1
WPL

Whiting Paul L

Director

1.0K sharesโ€ข1 transactions

$24K

Top Sellers

1
GEJ

Garateix Ernie J

Director, Officer: Chief Executive Officer

87.9K sharesโ€ข13 transactions

$2.40M

2
MT

Moura Timothy

Officer: See Remarks

52.8K sharesโ€ข2 transactions

$1.39M

3
LK

Lusk Kirk

Officer: Chief Financial Officer

28.3K sharesโ€ข3 transactions

$719K

4
BS

Binnun Sharon

Officer: Chief Accounting Officer

17.1K sharesโ€ข2 transactions

$491K

Insider Activity Analysis

Net Insider Sentiment

Bearish

Strong bearish signal with $4.97M net selling. Heavy insider selling may indicate concerns about valuation or near-term prospects.

Buy/Sell Ratio

0.00:1

Very poor ratio. Heavy selling with minimal buying suggests insiders may be concerned about valuation or outlook.

Recent Trend (3 Months)

$2.28M

Heavy recent selling activity. Recent insider sales notably exceed purchasesโ€”may warrant investigation into company developments.

Insider Participation

High Selling

4 insider sellers vs. 1 buyers. Widespread selling across multiple insiders may signal concerns.

Insider Activity Insight

Multiple red flags: Heavy selling, numerous sellers, and continued recent selling create a concerning pattern. Investigate fundamental drivers and consider whether company guidance or industry conditions have deteriorated.

0.00%
Dividend Yield
3Y-100.0%
5Y-100.0%
10Y-100.0%
ย 

hrtg Dividend History

HRTG
10Y CAGR +2%
Latest $0.06
Annual $0.3
5 year growth trend
Last Period: +0%