Nicolet Bankshares, Inc.

Nicolet Bankshares, Inc.

Financial Services

NYSE:NIC · New York Stock Exchange

Market Cap $2.34B Beta 0.68 P/E (TTM) 16.5
$148.55 +0.90%

+$1.33 today

52W Low $114.12High $163.11

Vol 0.27M · Avg 0.17M

EPS (TTM)$9.00
Div Yield0.89%
Banks - Regional

Management

Put operating results in leadership context

Review returns on capital, executive background, insider transactions, and growth quality to judge whether management is compounding value well.

Return Metrics

ROE, ROIC & ROA over time

Management

ROE

12.0%

avg 9.4%

ROIC

1.6%

avg 7.1%

ROA

1.6%

avg 1.2%

Analysis

ROE is currently the strongest return metric at 12.0% versus its period average of 9.4%. 0 of 3 return metrics are above their quality threshold, which helps indicate how efficiently the company turns capital and assets into profit.

Management

Key executives, compensation & ownership

Management
NameTitleCompensationTenureAgeShares OwnedOwnership %

Michael E. Daniels

Co-Founder, President, CEO, Chairman & Director$2.55M62$61,452.000.39%

H. Phillip Moore Jr.

Chief Financial Officer$1.11M65$37,921.000.24%

Eric James Witczak

Executive Vice President & Secretary$1.08M55$35,894.000.23%

Brad Vincent Hutjens

Executive VP & Chief Credit Officer$1.01M44$36,620.000.23%

William Bohn

EVP- Wealth Mngmn, Private Client & Trust Services, NNB$992,185.0060$16,585.000.11%

Robert Atwell

Co-Founder$31,500.0069$10,259.690.07%

Eric Radzak

Senior Vice President of Corporate Development & Investor Relations47$35,894.000.23%

Jeff Gahnz

Senior Vice President of Marketing & Public Relations

Michele McKinnon

Corporate Secretary

Insider Trading

SEC Form 4 transactions — last 12 months

Management

Buys

5

$275,059.95

Sells

13

$4.09M

Net Sentiment

$3.81M

Net selling

Most Active

ATWELL ROBERT BRUCE

10 transactions

DateInsiderTypeSharesPriceValue
Mar 12, 2026

ATWELL ROBERT BRUCE

Direct

Sell1.3K$150.26$198,944.24
Mar 12, 2026

ATWELL ROBERT BRUCE

Direct

Sell1.9K$149.49$281,788.65
Mar 12, 2026

ATWELL ROBERT BRUCE

Direct

Sell100$150.27$15,026.50
Mar 5, 2026

ATWELL ROBERT BRUCE

Direct

Sell400$151.34$60,536.00
Mar 5, 2026

ATWELL ROBERT BRUCE

Direct

Sell2.8K$150.52$423,713.80
Mar 5, 2026

ATWELL ROBERT BRUCE

Direct

Sell116$152.05$17,637.80
Feb 18, 2026

ATWELL ROBERT BRUCE

Direct

Sell6.4K$155.47$994,386.12
Nov 18, 2025

MOORE HUBERT PHILLIP JR

Indirect

Buy25$120.35$3,008.75
Nov 4, 2025

Ghidorzi Christopher J.

Direct

Buy105$121.52$12,759.60
Oct 30, 2025

MOORE HUBERT PHILLIP JR

Direct

Buy240$115.84$27,801.60

1–10 of 18

Analysis

Insiders reported 5 buys worth $275,059.95 and 13 sells worth $4.09M over the last 12 months. That adds up to net selling of $3.81M. ATWELL ROBERT BRUCE was the most active insider with 10 transactions.

Growth Analysis

Historical CAGR & forward analyst estimates

Metric 10yr5yr3yr Fwd Est.
EPSN/AN/A+81.5%
+14.7% (12yr)3 analysts
RevenueN/AN/A+18.8%
+21.8% (12yr)3 analysts
Net IncomeN/AN/A+55.6%
+27.3% (12yr)3 analysts
EBITN/AN/A+56.3%
+23.4% (12yr)3 analysts

Analysis

Recent growth has been strongest in EPS at +81.5% over three years. Forward estimates point to Net Income at +27.3% (12yr), giving you a quick check on whether expectations are accelerating or cooling.

Who manages NIC?

Nicolet Bankshares, Inc. (NIC) lists 9 active executives. The top listed executive is Brad Vincent Hutjens, Executive VP & Chief Credit Officer.

Are NIC insiders buying or selling?

Recent insider activity shows net selling of $7.74M.

Explore More

Continue the stock analysis

Jump to another research area for this company.