image
Healthcare - Medical - Care Facilities - NYSE - US
$ 3.84
-3.76 %
$ 534 M
Market Cap
-1.27
P/E
EARNINGS CALL TRANSCRIPT
EARNINGS CALL TRANSCRIPT 2016 - Q3
image
Executives

Ross W. Comeaux - Community Health Systems, Inc. Wayne T. Smith - Community Health Systems, Inc. W. Larry Cash - Community Health Systems, Inc. Tim L. Hingtgen - Community Health Systems, Inc..

Analysts

A.J. Rice - UBS Securities LLC Brian Gil Tanquilut - Jefferies LLC Chris Rigg - Susquehanna Financial Group LLLP Frank Morgan - RBC Capital Markets LLC Gary Lieberman - Wells Fargo Securities LLC Joshua Raskin - Barclays Capital, Inc. Gary P. Taylor - JPMorgan Securities LLC Ralph Giacobbe - Citigroup Global Markets, Inc.

(Broker) Justin Lake - Wolfe Research LLC Kevin Mark Fischbeck - Bank of America Merrill Lynch.

Operator

Good morning. My name is Mike and I will be your conference operator today. At this time, I would like to welcome everyone to the Community Health Systems' Third Quarter Investor Call. All lines have been placed on mute to prevent any background noise. After the speakers' remarks, there will be a question-and-answer session.

I will now turn the call over to you, Mr. Ross Comeaux, Director of Investor Relations. You may begin your conference..

Ross W. Comeaux - Community Health Systems, Inc.

Thank you, Mike. Good morning and welcome to Community Health Systems' third quarter conference call. Before we begin the call, I'd like to read the following disclosure statement. This conference call may contain certain forward-looking statements, including all statements that do not relate solely to historical or current facts.

These forward-looking statements are subject to a number of known and unknown risk, which is described in headings such as Risk Factors in our Annual Report on Form 10-K and other reports filed with or furnished to the Securities and Exchange Commission.

As a consequence, actual results may differ significantly from those expressed in any forward-looking statements in today's discussion. We do not intend to update any of these forward-looking statements. Yesterday afternoon, we issued a press release with our financial statements and definitions and calculations of adjusted EBITDA and adjusted EPS.

For those of you listening to the live broadcast of this conference call, a supplemental slide presentation has been posted to our website. We will be referring to those slides during this earnings call. As a remainder, our results exclude Quorum Health Corporation and our joint venture in Las Vegas that was sold to Universal Health Services.

All calculations we will be discussing exclude discontinued operations, loss from early extinguishment of debt, impairment of long-lived assets, expenses incurred related to the company's spin-off of Quorum Health Corporation, impairment of goodwill, expenses related to government and other legal settlements and related cost, expenses incurred related to the divestiture of the Home Health division, the gain on the sale of investments and unconsolidated affiliates, expense from fair value adjustments related to the HMA legal proceedings accounted for at fair value, underlying the CVR agreement, and related legal expenses.

With that said, I'd like to turn the call over to Mr. Wayne Smith, Chairman and Chief Executive Officer. Mr.

Smith?.

Wayne T. Smith - Community Health Systems, Inc.

Thank you, Ross. Good morning and welcome to our third quarter conference call. Larry Cash, our President of Financial Services and Chief Financial Officer is with me on the call today along with Tim Hingtgen, our President and Chief Operating Officer. First, it goes without saying that we're not pleased with our performance during the third quarter.

Over the years, we've seen some variability, but our inconsistent performance recently and in the third quarter simply has not been good enough. Operationally, we've experienced a great deal of change over the past few quarters. Assimilation of the HMA hospitals has been more difficult than anticipated.

Our recent spin-off of Quorum Health, a realignment of our divisions, a number of new division Presidents and Vice Presidents, the promotion of our new Chief Operating Officer, consolidation on many of our back office functions and IT conversions.

While we believe all of these changes will ultimately help to strengthen the company for our better long-term success, some of these changes have created challenges in the near term.

And while we're confident in the outlook for our business and the new leadership team that we've put in place, we have not been satisfied with our performance over the past few quarters. Execution of our initiatives and strategies coupled with our infrastructure changes and refinement of our portfolio should well position us for the future.

Our EBITDA margin was $10.6 million in the third quarter, well below our expectations. We believe our continued focus on operational enhancements and portfolio rationalization will yield positive margins and leverage improvements in the fourth quarter and into 2017.

With regard to the third quarter, we did not achieve the net revenue growth that we had expected, a number of our expense items were higher than we projected. Both of these factors impacted our EBITDA for the quarter. Larry will go through the results from the third quarter in more detail in a minute.

Turning to our physician practices, we saw progress in the third quarter on both the top-line and EBITDA line on a year-over-year basis. As a reminder, we had a record number of employed physicians in 2015 and the first half of 2016.

While we have slowed the rate at which we are hiring new physicians following a record growth last year, we are still hiring new doctors in critical areas, with a focus on high acuity and in-patient services and in growth opportunity hospitals.

In terms of physicians starting practice, starting employment with CHS, we experienced a 22% decrease in the third quarter of 2016 versus the third quarter of 2015. That said, we hired a record number of physicians in the third quarter of 2015, where physicians starting employment was up 48%.

We're seeing increased physician productivity across portfolio of employed providers, and we have improved the newly hired physician startup process. For the back half of 2016, we expect physicians starting employment will be approximately 30%, below the second half of 2015, which is below our prior forecast of approximately 40%.

As we think about our physician practice performance, we expect to see additional improvements in the fourth quarter of 2016, and we expect to drive continued incremental improvement in 2017 and 2018. I'll ask Tim, our new President and Chief Operating Officer, to provide some more additional comments on our operations later in the call.

Moving to the portfolio rationalization, we're working to move a more substantial group of hospitals in markets – move to a more substantial group of hospitals in markets.

Along these lines, we announced two definitive agreements to divest assets which since our second quarter earnings call in early August, and we expect additional announcements prior to the fourth quarter earnings call.

First, on September 29, we disclosed that we had signed a definitive agreement for the sale of four hospitals and their associated assets to subsidiaries of Curae Health. Those facilities were located in Amory, Mississippi, Batesville, Mississippi, Clarksdale, Mississippi, and Sebring, Florida.

We are pleased to see these assets join Curae, which is a hospital operator focused on non-urban facilities. Second, on October 17, we announced a definitive agreement to sell an 80% ownership interest in our Home Health division to the subsidiary of Almost Family for $128 million, including working capital.

Our Home Health business accounts for approximately $200 million of annual revenues, and we're excited to now partner with Almost Family in the home health space. It's worth noting that we're maintaining an interest in our Home Health business to help ensure that our patients receive quality post-acute care coordination.

Now, we would like to update you on the assets that we planned to divest. Today, we're working on seven divesture transactions that include 17 hospitals, homecare and non-hospital real estate transaction. These assets account for $2 billion of annual revenue and mid-single digit EBITDA margins.

Estimated proceeds from these transactions include working capital are projected to generate $1.2 billion of proceeds. The non-hospital real estate assets including transaction do not generate EBTIDA, and the proceeds from the transaction are estimated to be 10% to 15% of the $1.2 billion.

We expect closing dates for these seven divesture transactions to be between the fourth quarter of 2016 and the second quarter of 2017. And a substantial portion of these proceeds will be used for further debt reduction.

It is also worth noting that the interest level in our assets is extremely higher, we're receiving interest from a number of parties and we'll provide updates as we receive definitive agreements and reach the close of the transactions.

Before we get into the quarter and our updated guidance, we also wanted to briefly mention the preliminary discussions we're having with advisors. As a reminder, we disclosed on September 19 that with the assistance of advisors, we're exploring a variety of strategic options with financial sponsors as well as other potential alternatives.

The discussions are in a preliminary stage and there's no set timeline established for the review. There can be no certainty that the exploration will result in any kind of transaction. The company does not expect to make further public comment regarding these transactions, while our exploration process takes place.

Now moving back to the quarter and the full-year guidance, here are some of the third quarter key metrics adjusted to exclude legal settlements and related expenses as well as other items. Cash flow from operations were $824 million during the first nine months of 2016.

That compares to adjusted cash flow from operations of $721 million during the first nine months of 2015. Larry will provide more detail on our cash flow performance. On a same-store basis, adjusted admissions decreased 1.5% and surgeries were down 0.4%.

Adjusted EBITDA was $465 million, and Larry, again, will provide more facts impacting our results in just a minute. Adjusted EPS was a negative $0.35. We are revising our 2016 guidance as follows. Net revenues less provision for doubtful accounts are anticipated to be $18.3 billion to $18.5 billion.

Same-store hospital adjusted admissions is anticipated to be down 0.3%, up to 0.3%. Adjusted EBITDA is anticipated to be $2.2 billion to $2.275 billion. Income from continuing operations per share is anticipated to be $0.30 to $0.50 based on weighted average diluted shares outstanding of 111.5 million to 112.5 million.

As it relates to our pending HMA legal matters, there's no material changes since our last earnings call. We continue to reevaluate the estimated liabilities covered by the CVRs on a quarterly basis. Our current estimate, including probable legal fees continue to reflect there will be no payment to the CVR holders.

I'm pleased to announce that an agreement in principle has been reached that resolves the shareholder derivative case action, the derivative case. The case arose from allegations leveled by Tenet against our company and our Directors, as we tried to buy them in 2011.

The terms of the settlement remain confidential until presented to the court for approval. The monetary portion of the settlement will be funded by our D&O insurance carriers. Larry will now discuss our results further and provide you with other information.

Larry?.

W. Larry Cash - Community Health Systems, Inc.

Thank you, Wayne. Before we discuss the specifics of our third quarter, we like to talk about our third quarter adjusted EBITDA performance compared to the 2016 adjusted EBITDA guidance that we discussed at second quarter conference call.

As a reminder, our guidance for second half of the year contemplated EBITDA improvement from payer mix, volume improvement, physician practice, expense reduction and other factors. We'd expect to achieve about 30% of these benefits in the third quarter and the balance in the fourth quarter.

Overall, there were a number of items that weighed on our third quarter actual versus unknown expectations which we will walk through below. First, our acquisitions in La Porte, Indiana, and Fayetteville, Arkansas, are performing well and tracking relatively in line of our projections.

For third quarter, HITECH was $5 million benefit, which was approximately $8 million less than expected due to timing but this should be recorded in the fourth quarter. We now expect HITECH to come in around $70 million for the full year.

We had $10 million less than expected due to Medicaid reimbursement reductions primarily in Texas on a payer mix and volume improvement. Volumes came in below our forecast of approximately 1.7%, compared to our prior guidance. This decline was approximately $35 million EBITDA reduction in our third quarter compared to our EBITDA expectation.

In terms of physician practice, we did make about $10 million improvement during the third quarter, but the performance was about $10 million less than we anticipated. On the HIM expenses as well as our Central Business Office supply chain, our third quarter experience was in line with our projections.

Finally, on the expense front, we did not meet our forecast, as operating expenses were about $40 million greater than our estimate, due primarily to higher than forecasted payroll expenses, including health insurance costs.

Combined, these items contributed about $103 million to the shortfall from the third quarter adjusted EBITDA performance expectations. Before discussing year-to-year change in our third quarter results, it's worth noting the same-quarter sequential change from the second quarter of 2016 to third quarter of 2016.

In terms of differences in the calendar, we estimate July 4th holiday occurring on Monday versus Saturday in 2015, so approximately $20 million reduction of revenue. And again we had 92 calendar days in the second quarter versus 91 calendar days.

This means an extra calendar day that offset the July 4th revenue headwind, but additional calendar day contributed some additional expenses in the third quarter versus the second quarter. Now I'm going to talk about substantial same-store change in our results. As a reminder, calculations discussed in the call exclude the items noted earlier.

On a same-store basis for the quarter, we note the following. At the end of the third quarter 2016 versus second quarter, net revenue declined 0.4%, admissions were down 1.1% and adjusted admissions decreased 0.6% sequentially. Our ER business were up 4% while our surgeries decreased 1.8%.

On a same-store basis, HITECH was $24 million reduction in our third quarter EBITDA performance sequentially. Overall, on the same-store operating expenses, ex-HITECH increased 0.6% for the third quarter versus the second quarter, while we had anticipated a much larger reduction.

Now, we'll discuss the results of the third quarter on a quarter-over-quarter basis. As a reminder, calculations exclude the items noted earlier.

Same-store basis for the quarter in the third quarter 2015 versus 2016, net revenues increased 1.2%, which is comprised of a 2.8% increase in net revenue per adjusted admission, a 1.5% decrease in volume or adjusted admissions.

In-patient admissions declined 2.1%, probably about 100 basis points of that relates to flu and respiratory and about 60 basis points relates to OB and deliveries, and about 50 basis points relates to profit (15:43) readmissions. Our ER business were up 0.4%, our surgeries decreased 0.4% primarily due to the drop in outpatient growth.

Let me describe a few same store trends between our former HMA facilities and our legacy CHS facilities. For the third quarter of 2015 versus the third quarter of 2016, the former HMA facilities had a 3.6% decrease in admissions.

This compares to 1.2% decline in legacy, a 2.4% decrease in adjusted admissions for HMA compared to 1% decrease in legacy, a decrease in surgery cases improved 1.9%, while legacy experienced a 1.1% growth. A decrease in net revenue of 0.6% for HMA, which is an improvement over the previous trends compared to 2.1% increase in legacy facilities.

Our net outpatient revenue before bad debts currently represent about 57% of our revenue, which is in line with the second quarter.

Our consolidated revenue payer mix for the third quarter 2016 compared to the third quarter of 2015, Managed Care & Other increased 250 basis points, Medicare decreased 90 basis points, Medicaid decreased 140 basis points and self-pay decreased 20 basis points.

On a year-to-date basis, consolidated revenue payer mix for managed care increased 120 basis points and Medicare decreased 40 basis points, Medicaid decreased 70 basis points and self-pay decreased 10 basis points.

Our consolidated charity plus self-pay discounts plus bad debts for the three months comparative periods has increased from 25.4% to 27.4% of adjusted revenue, a 200 basis point increase. This increase is driven primarily by higher self-pay discounts as a percentage of total revenue.

Exchange visits for the third quarter 2016 increased 6% over the third quarter 2015. On same-store expense items, our salaries and benefits as a percentage of net revenue increased 110 basis points and the biggest increases were in health insurance policy which is up 30 basis points quarter-over-quarter.

Physician salaries and expenses were up about 10 basis points and our salaries for the transition services contributed about 10 basis points.

Supply expense, as a percentage of net revenue, for same-store increased 20 basis points, driven primarily by higher implant costs and we continue to increase our inpatient surgical case mix and having some growth in outpatient procedures with higher supply costs.

Other operating expense as a percentage of net revenue on the same-store increased 90 basis points. The increases in the third quarter 2016 versus the third quarter 2015 were driven by higher medical specialist fees, expenses related to community commitments and information system expense and Medicaid supplemental program costs.

Now going to cash flow. Our cash flow provided by operations for the quarter is $178 million compared to $111 million from the prior-year quarter. For the first nine months of 2016, our reported cash flow from operations is $810 million. This increased 32% over the prior year of $615 million. Adjusted included legal severance related expenses.

Cash flows from operations was $824 million in the first nine months of 2016. This compares to adjusted cash flow from operations of $721 million for the first nine months of 2015.

During the first nine months, adjusted cash flow from operations was up 14%, improved over $100 million and in terms of year-over-year increase during the first nine months a couple of items to note, the timing of payments for payroll was partially offset for payments of accounts payable that contributed about $40 million in a slower growth accounts receivable contributed approximately $90 million.

Our cash flow from operations guidance for 2016 is $1.2 billion (19:59). Moving to the balance sheet, at the end of the third quarter, we had approximately $15.1 billion of the long-term debt, which is down from $16.6 billion since the start of the year.

As Wayne mentioned earlier, we are now working on seven divesture transactions plus the non-hospital real estate transactions, which could result in $1.2 billion in incremental proceeds including working capital.

We expect these again to close sometime in the fourth quarter through the second quarter of 2017, and we'll expect to use most of these proceeds for further debt reduction. I'd now like to comment on our bank covenants, our main two tests under the credit burning (20:44) secured net leverage and ratio and interest coverage ratio.

Secured net leverage ratio is calculated as a ratio of total secured debt, less unrestricted cash and cash equivalent to consolidated EBITDA, while the interest rate coverage is the ratio of consolidated EBITDA as defined – compared to consolidated interest expense for the period under the EBITDA calculations and above ratios it's a trailing 12-month calculation against the net income of certain pro forma adjustments that account for the impact of material acquisitions through divestitures, adjustments for interest or taxes or depreciation and amortization, and net income attributable to non-controlling interests, stock compensation, restructuring costs and the financial impact of other non-cash or non-recurring items during the 12-month period ending September 30, 2016, secured net leverage ratio of financial covenant limited ratio of secured debt as defined to less than 4.25 to 1, and for the 12-month period end of September 30, the interest ratio financial covenant and the credit facility limited ratio consolidated EBITDA or consolidated interest to greater than or equal to 2.0.

The company was in compliance with all such covenants at September 30, 2016 with a secured net leverage ratio of 3.95% and interest rate coverage about 2.55%. Our interest rate cushion on our secured debt leverage ratio is about 7%, and our EBITDA cushion on interest coverage is about 27%.

Turning to CapEx, our CapEx for the third quarter was $151 million or 3.5%. Our year-to-date CapEx is $561 million or 4% of net revenue. During the nine months, our CapEx was $696 million, 2015, that was 4.8% of revenue. As a reminder, we spent about $100 million last year on our good performing facility in Birmingham, Alabama.

Our CapEx guidance for 2016 will be in the range of $725 million to $800 million. I'll now walk through our 2016 adjusted EBITDA bridge. Year-to-date, our adjusted EBITDA was $1.66 billion.

When we start with adjusted EBITDA, our current run rate without HITECH for the third quarter, $460 million, and I will walk through some of the changes expected in the balance of the year.

We expect HITECH incentives of $15 million for the fourth quarter 2016, and which implies about $69 million for the full-year expected increase in Medicaid reimbursement primarily in Texas to improve $10 million during the fourth quarter.

Physician practice performance is expected to improve $20 million, health information management centralization should drive EBITDA improvement of approximately $5 million. Seasonal and service line improvements in Florida are expected to contribute $30 million EBITDA in the fourth quarter.

Reductions in expenses related to some community commitments of $10 million and other improvements are expected to deliver $25 million as it relate to payroll management, supply management and the normal improvement in payer mix for the fourth quarter. I will now turn it back over to Wayne..

Wayne T. Smith - Community Health Systems, Inc.

Thank you, Larry. Since our last earnings call in early August, we announced promoting Tim Hingtgen as our new President and Chief Operating Officer. Tim was serving as our Executive Vice President of Operations at the time, and he has now moved into a new role as our President and Chief Operating Officer starting on September 3.

Tim had joined CHS back in 2008 from another public hospital company (24:28) successful division of presidents and with a track record of driving solid same-store net revenue growth, expense management and EBITDA margin expansion.

We're confident that his proven effectiveness and leadership capabilities will help to drive further execution across our divisions. Tim has now been in his new role for the past 10 month, and we've asked Tim to make some additional comments on our business this morning..

Tim L. Hingtgen - Community Health Systems, Inc.

Thank you, Wayne. Before I comment on our operations, I wanted to first take a step back and share some of the thoughts I have gathered about the company during my last eight years.

For starters, we have a strong foundation on which to build upon with over 150 hospitals, strong access points, a number of key regional networks, as well as a solid track record in terms of quality and producing excellent patient outcomes.

We also have great people throughout our organization, including high-performing physicians, healthcare practitioners, hospital operators, and management executives.

While we have some hospitals that are not performing at our level of expectation, we have a large number in our portfolio that are performing exceptionally well generating solid volume and revenue growth as well as improved EBITDA margin.

We are also achieving solid results across both the number of service lines and in many of our geographic markets. As we think about the fourth quarter and moving into 2017, we are focused on a number of initiatives to strengthen our base business and improve our overall efficiency.

While there are certainly a number of other areas where I'm concentrating, including more medium- to long-term strategic goals, the two areas receiving the most attention in the near-term are both volume and revenue initiatives and expense management.

First on volumes; clearly we were not satisfied with our volume performance during the third quarter. July was weak, and we simply did not perform well enough during the final two months of the quarter to offset the slow start. We have a number of revenue initiatives that we are either rolling out or strengthening.

These efforts are focused around service line improvement targeting higher acuity, physician practice improvement, ED volume development, and a number of others. In terms of ED volume development, we recently opened a new freestanding ED in the Lutheran Health Network in Fort Wayne, Indiana, the ninth in our company.

By the end of the fourth quarter, we will have also introduced consumer-focused online scheduling options for EDs and urgent cares in a number of our most competitive markets.

And hospital executives and ED clinicians at each facility remain intently focused on delivering the highest level of ER throughput intended to enhance the safety and service to their patients. Looking at our portfolio from a geographical standpoint, Florida remains a key market with our company.

During the fourth quarter and into 2017, we are expecting to see improved revenue performance in Florida from a combination of seasonality, service line improvement, and incremental investments into that market.

In terms of the broader potential for future revenue growth, we still see high opportunity in the ongoing development of the former HMA portfolio to a level that reflect the more favorable trends of our CHS legacy hospitals as called out in slide nine of the supplemental slide presentation.

Second, expense management is a high priority for the company and especially for me. Operating expenses came in above our forecast during the third quarter.

By facility, we've examined our cost structure and are actively driving expense reduction on the salary, wage, and benefits line from better FTE management, or by implementing more contemporary staffing plans that better match the volumes and reimbursement at some facilities.

The achievement of identified improvement opportunities is being closely monitored. We also see opportunities to reduce costs in our supplies and then other operating expense lines through various market-specific initiatives and a heightened focus on purchasing compliance within our GPO.

To facilitate local medical staff support for these opportunities, we're working closely with hospital Chief Medical Officers in our largest markets are offering the (28:10) support of our corporate physician and clinical leaders to the entire portfolio.

We believe this approach is driving more rapid implementation that will yield Q4 benefit and beyond. In terms of both our volume initiatives and expense management, we did not meet our own expectations in the third quarter.

We are working to achieve improved execution, visibility and accountability, and prioritization of high-value statistics across the organization to drive better EBITDA margin performance and increased shareholder value.

Finally, I would like to highlight a new framework that we introduced across the company in September to coordinate and prioritize the resources available to our hospitals via CHS's various clinical, operational, and gross subject matter experts.

Through this new model, we are able to more quickly target and deploy resources to market that could show the quickest return in terms of care delivery, volumes, or earnings. We've also seen earning results with length of stay improvement, ED throughput, and nurse recruitment and staffing.

I expect sustained improved results in the months and years ahead.

Wayne?.

Wayne T. Smith - Community Health Systems, Inc.

Thank you, Tim. We're pleased to have Tim in this new role and look forward to seeing the operational improvements that we expect him to deliver. At this point, Mike, we're ready to open up for questions. We'll limit everyone to one question, so several of you have time on this call.

But as always, we are available, if you need, you can get in touch with us at area code 615-465-7000.

Mike?.

Operator

And your first question is from A.J. Rice from UBS..

A.J. Rice - UBS Securities LLC

Thanks. Hi, everybody. Just maybe to talk about a little further what you're trying do with the divesture program. I know when you started way back with the spinout of Quorum and some early divestitures, it seemed to me your focus was primarily on getting rid of non-strategic assets and focusing on the network hospital portfolio in particular.

It seems like it's evolved a little bit over time where an element of it is certainly paying down debt as well. Is there an objective for how much debt you'd like to pay down, say, by the end of next year, or whatever point from the divestiture program? And I guess you added this quarter to the properties that you're potentially selling.

Is that an ongoing process that we could see more additions in the next few quarters?.

Wayne T. Smith - Community Health Systems, Inc.

Yeah, A.J. Look this process, we knew when we bought HMA, just as when we acquired Triad that we would have to rationalize our portfolio that we had facilities that did not fit. So that's one of the reasons that we had so many facilities, the reason we did the spin to start with.

And then as we kind of look to the future, we want to make sure that we are in sustainable markets where we have good opportunity to deploy our resources and our capital so that we can expand in those markets going forward.

So we will continue to look at properties, we'll continue to evaluate our properties in terms of ones that we think are beneficial. It's not just network location, we have a lot of hospitals that are competitive. We talked about Birmingham a lot. Birmingham is doing extremely well.

We have a number of hospitals in Alabama, but nothing that close to Birmingham in terms of the network. But we have a lot of standalone facilities too we've got across the country that are very good facilities, performing extremely well.

So we will continue to look at this process and we will do it by the ones we've identified in this group that we're working on now. As you said, we've added a few to it, but we think we're on the right track here. We haven't set any specific target number in terms of debt pay-down.

We're more concerned about having improved margins and making sure that our operations work efficiently and our performance improves as well. So, as Larry said, we have a lot of interesting people and we're selling these hospitals at a good multiple. So it should be very helpful as we move forward.

Larry, you want to add to it?.

W. Larry Cash - Community Health Systems, Inc.

I'll just add, one of the things we're focused on is we're trying to get somewhere around 8 to 10 times EBITDA for these transactions. Fortunately we've got some NOL, which will help on the taxes for some of these facilities.

We do look at the tax basis of what we're trying to sell and we also try to make sure if something we get started, we try to get it done. There would be some facilities that we may start a process that don't go and get done, we'll find something else.

We have increased it each quarter that we've made the conference call from May to August to now, and we think this is a pretty good price for the facilities both on a percentage of revenue and on a multiple of EBITDA which will help delever the company, and more importantly help the margins going forward as Wayne said..

Wayne T. Smith - Community Health Systems, Inc.

So, A.J., I would add to this. These are good facilities. There is good physicians and employees working in these facilities. We're highly sensitive as we think about this, we think about facilities and where they're located and who they might work with that might be more productive than being part of our system when it's all said and done.

So it is a well thought out and a careful process as we kind of move forward..

Operator

The next question is from Brian Tanquilut from Jefferies..

Brian Gil Tanquilut - Jefferies LLC

Hey, good morning, guys. Larry, as I think about the leverage gap, it drops to four times in 2017. I think you laid it out that you're trying to get the divestures done by mid next year at the latest.

So how should we think about that as we do the lookback? And then the other component of the question is just as HMA's assets continue to deteriorate from a same-store perspective, how does that come into play, obviously, with EBITDA being the denominator in the leverage computation? Thanks..

W. Larry Cash - Community Health Systems, Inc.

We laid out attrition, we got here. Attrition did come down in the third quarter on the senior secured debt. It's in pretty good shape on the interest test. Selling the assets at a pretty good multiple like this will be helpful. We expect to have some sales done before that stepdown.

The other thing is and we've generally like to have a bit more of a cushion and we may consider trying to change that stepdown sometime next year or sometime before next year and when it applies.

But we're in good shape now and expect to be in good shape at the end of December, but we will consider doing that and think about that with our financial advisors. But as it relates to the senior secured, selling these type of assets at a multiple we're selling at is very, very helpful to the senior secured test..

Operator

The next question is from Chris Rigg from Susquehanna Financial..

Chris Rigg - Susquehanna Financial Group LLLP

Hi. Good morning, guys. Just to think about the HMA facilities, kind of looks like their performance is starting to flatten out at least a little bit. I was wondering if you could just give us some details around whether – just to compare this legacy CHS versus HMA, physician attrition, CEO turnover.

And just generally speaking, do you think we're near an inflection point in the next quarter or two where things could start to get better? Or is it still too early to call? Thanks a lot..

W. Larry Cash - Community Health Systems, Inc.

Let me make one comment and maybe others will want to add. We did highlight that the revenue, which has been running roughly 2% down, was down 0.6%. That's probably one of the better quarters they've had. We did comment on the last call if you went back and looked at the hospitals they've owned since 2012, and they were down 7% or 8%, admissions 4%.

They've gotten better through this nine-month period, and they got better in 2014 when we owned it, 2015, and a bit better now.

They are struggling a little bit with surgeries, which is something we're very focused on little bit with volume, but the revenue and some of that's because of the work we've done on managed care and trying to get a little bit more managed care business. I think they will continue to improve.

I think we're getting close (36:34) and clearly they will not be at the legacy this year, but we think sometime next year at the HMA facilities, as Tim said and Wayne just referred, I think we'll see them close the gap and doing quite well that with some of the assets we sell will be HMA and some of the legacy that will help their performance..

Wayne T. Smith - Community Health Systems, Inc.

So just in terms of process, as you know, we had to change a number of executives in HMA facilities. We've done IT conversions. We've had a lot of work to do. We've recruited a lot of physicians and maybe too aggressively, but I think, we're beginning to see that there is a real opportunity here in those facilities.

And again, we continue to think about these facilities the same way we do any facility that we've acquired, long-term how it's going to work, is it going to be sustainable for us, and is it in a sustainable market. And we like Florida a lot obviously because of the fact the demographics are so good..

W. Larry Cash - Community Health Systems, Inc.

Just one other point. The physician satisfaction, the employee satisfaction has improved since we got it and it's closing in on (37:41) legacy is, which is a good thing. The other is we've started our safety program that we talk about where we reduced (37:48) safety events roughly 75% or so.

We're making similar progress in HMA hospitals, which will help those relationship with physicians, and that's well underway there..

Operator

The next question is from Frank Morgan from RBC Capital..

Frank Morgan - RBC Capital Markets LLC

Good morning. Larry, and maybe Tim could have some comments here, as I look through your walk-through from the third quarter to the balance of the year, I was hoping you could prioritize the big three items to get to fourth quarter guidance.

It seemed like it's more on the seasonality side and the service line adds along with physician practices and other. So I was just hoping you could kind of go through those categories, maybe a little more detail on exactly what you see is the most likely drivers to get to those numbers for improvement.

And then the follow-up would just be if you take the third-quarter number in your walk-through guidance, is that a good number to annualize off of as we start thinking about 2017, understanding that that's probably independent of any divestitures? Thanks..

W. Larry Cash - Community Health Systems, Inc.

Yeah. The HITECH is in pretty good shape. The government just approved a 90-day test, which is helpful. Medicaid reimbursement should be good, the physician health information management, we've been making progress on that.

About two-thirds of the $30 million is seasonality, which we believe it would be similar to what it has been historically for Florida. Some of the service lines takes a little bit more work. The reduction expenses here outlined at $10 million is a pretty good number. The other improvements around the payroll, supplies and payer mix.

Payer mix should improve. A lot of y'all follow managed-care companies as we follow also. Usually the managed care mix gets better in the fourth quarter versus the third, and so that would be helpful. Plus we've gotten some increases in the fourth quarter that weren't there in the third quarter, so that would be there.

The physician practices will take some good work. We've got a lot of talented people working on it. But I think that's probably one that we will take some pretty good execution to get done. That's probably the one that would be in – probably the service line in Florida will take some good execution..

Operator

The next question is from Gary Lieberman from Wells Fargo..

Gary Lieberman - Wells Fargo Securities LLC

Maybe just to stick with the roll forward. As you look back to the prior quarters, you had a number of disappointing quarters.

Sort of what can you do differently or what do you plan to do differently, so that you are able to achieve the improvement in the walk forward that you've outlined here?.

W. Larry Cash - Community Health Systems, Inc.

There's probably more detailed support around the physician practice where it's been more – the team has been together a little bit longer.

They didn't make a lot of progress in the third quarter, not as much as we wanted, and it's outlined on numbers of issues and both to do with some of the less starting physicians getting once (40:36) better or a little bit of attrition activities, some of the volume activity, and it will be monitored a lot more effectively I think.

Tim also said one of his number one priorities is on the expense management, I think that will help in the other improvement category around the payroll and supplies activity.

The payer mix, we didn't make a big change in the volume, the ranges were down 0.2%, right now year-to-date, and we got a range negative 0.3% to positive 1.3% and there's a lot of effort, but we didn't count on volume being the big driver here in the fourth quarter. We do think that our improvements are achievable (41:12).

What the problem last quarter and clearly on the expense side, the payroll was not managed as well. Generally we improve man-hours for adjusted admission.

They used to stay flat or went slightly in the wrong way, and in the health insurance, we got some efforts underway on the health insurance, made a little progress in the third quarter, but not near what we needed to be. And I think we did make some progress in supplies.

They were up 20 basis points in the third quarter versus I think 90 basis points a year. In the quarter before that, there was a lot of efforts in different programs on the supplies both in plants and other activities. We did make some progress in the third quarter on drugs, and we continue to do that.

So, it's a very focused effort and I don't know, Tim, do you want to add anything to that?.

Wayne T. Smith - Community Health Systems, Inc.

Yeah. Just a minute before we get there. I just want to – I think we're better today than we have been in the past in terms of our capability to analyze and get to and solve problems quickly. Tim has done a great job in terms of organizationally making sure that we follow through.

We have a lot more discipline today than we had in the last three or four quarters or so. And Tim might talk a bit about a few of the initiatives that we have both on the revenue side and expense side, but we have enhanced initiatives and a lot of discipline behind that.

So, that's the reason I feel confident that we're going to make good progress here in the next quarter and 2017..

Tim L. Hingtgen - Community Health Systems, Inc.

Sure.

I'd like to add that our divisions presidents have had more time to work with these hospitals, some of them new to their portfolio of assets they are managing, and that has entailed some more one-to-one deep dives and reconciliation of their performance to whether volumes are materializing as expected or not and where volumes don't materialize, we are able to shift our cost structure much more quickly this quarter.

We've gone through a very, very extensive bridge plan process for Q3 to Q4, and as Wayne said, each division has upped their reviews and monitoring of achievement of the supply line. We've also rolled out a considerable amount of near-term expense reduction items related to supplies.

As I mentioned in my comments, we're working closely with the medical staffs to make sure that we get the best pricing with the best product and with the buy-in of those medical staffs to help us accelerate on that.

One other item that we did that I'd like to comment on is, we've identified a grouping of our hospitals, who are of high opportunity that have not had the earnings performance that they historically have had.

Those are group of hospitals that the division leadership and their hospital executives have come together on, built a very, very detailed action plan to make sure that we get the resources and play to help restore them to their prior levels of earnings and growth. And we're starting to see some of the early impact of that as well..

W. Larry Cash - Community Health Systems, Inc.

One thing, just I know a lot of people have been talking about Hurricane Matthew and we didn't show it as a go backwards here, but we also had about a similar amount of issues in one of our Pennsylvania hospitals, then went the other way in the third quarter, so those two offset.

So, some people have made a reference to Hurricane Matthew and that's how we handled it..

Operator

The next question is from Josh Raskin from Barclays..

Joshua Raskin - Barclays Capital, Inc.

Thanks, good morning. I guess, I just want to juxtapose all the physician additions. I think Wayne mentioned it was a record level of recruitment last year in the third quarter and then when you look at surgery volumes, I think you mentioned HMA ran about 500 basis points behind the legacy assets.

And so, I'm just curious with all the physician recruitment, why – I understand why you're seeing a little bit more losses on the salaried physicians, but why are we not seeing sort of that uptick in volumes or is it just maybe these are not surgeons that are getting recruited et cetera, just any color there?.

Wayne T. Smith - Community Health Systems, Inc.

Tim, do you want to talk about it?.

Tim L. Hingtgen - Community Health Systems, Inc.

Sure. We are tracking the ramp up of our new providers and where we're not seeing that improvement, we've added extra resources in terms of directors of physician outreach to help integrate those new surgeons or procedure list into the communities.

Everyone of our new providers in Florida, for instance, we have a very specific plan as to how we can help them grow their clinic encounters and then ultimately grow the network and the hospital's growth in the future..

Wayne T. Smith - Community Health Systems, Inc.

We've also gone back and looked at acuity in our facilities, and determined whether or not we did get enough surgeons and how we might enhance our acuity. And so we're working now to focus our recruiting on those kinds of physicians more than primary care..

W. Larry Cash - Community Health Systems, Inc.

Yeah, I think probably last year, there was a fair amount of recruitment was in the primary care section, and it's targeted a little bit better this year..

Operator

The next question is from Gary Taylor from JPMorgan..

Gary P. Taylor - JPMorgan Securities LLC

Hi, good morning. Two-part question. One, given the pretty substantial increase in Europe public market's borrowing costs. I wondered if you could comment on your view of the relative attractiveness of refinancing.

And then the second question is, given the really substantial loss of shareholder value, could you just comment on the rationale for putting the poison pill in place?.

Wayne T. Smith - Community Health Systems, Inc.

Well, let me do the first about the public market as far as debt. There is no real immediate refinancings that we got to do right now. I think the next one is sometime August of 2018. And I think still the senior secured debt that we can do would be reasonably attractive, especially if we perform as we've outlined here in the fourth quarter.

The REIT activity we did do, we called out a real estate REIT transaction that we hope to get done in the next couple of months. And we'll disclose it when we close. And it would be either – it's the non-hospital assets, so it's either medical office building or office building or radiology diagnostic center or something like that.

We're not opposed to – we got a lot of physician joint ventures and partnerships which become problematic if we're doing a lot of REIT activity. There may be some smaller hospitals that could work for us in a REIT, we haven't gone on that path yet, but we're looking at it from the MOB perspective..

Tim L. Hingtgen - Community Health Systems, Inc.

So the primary reason that we put in the pill really was to give our process that we have going on an opportunity to work. And to sort of prevent somebody from buying so many shares as they end up controlling the process instead of our board controlling the process.

And as a short-term pill, it's over within April, and I think it will give us time to work through this, I don't know what will come out of this, but it will give us an opportunity to work through the process. So, it's really more about that.

It certainly was not directed, we have talked to our large shareholders were not directed in trying to do anything different other than to let the process work..

Operator

The next question is from Ralph Giacobbe from Citi..

Ralph Giacobbe - Citigroup Global Markets, Inc. (Broker)

Thanks. Anyway to get a sense of how much of volume pressure is maybe just related to your markets in general versus market share losses you're seeing.

And then you mentioned some of the revenue improvement, any thoughts on expectation on when you would see that come through and to the extent that revenue trends or organic revenue trends remain 1% to 2%, do you have enough on the cost side essentially to offset the negative leverage of that type of revenue? Thanks..

W. Larry Cash - Community Health Systems, Inc.

Let me take the latter part of that first. We would clearly have a lot of cost opportunity, the cost has been going up too much, and I think the efforts are here to try to improve the cost.

We do believe that the payer mix will continue to improve, that we're seeing right now a pretty good managed care payer mix and decent increases in that and we're looking hopefully this year and next year from that perspective.

On the revenue trend, I think CHS is fairly in good shape for the year, the HMA facilities are not, and I think we are continuing to make a lot of progress trying to get involved in a lot of volume, losses are probably more predominantly in the HMA facilities, so they go hand-in-hand there, so we've improved the HMA facilities.

From a volume perspective, the revenue got a little better more from mix, the revenue will get better now after the overall company get better..

Operator

The next question is from Justin Lake from Wolfe..

Justin Lake - Wolfe Research LLC

Hey, guys. Just recovering from that Justine. So, I just wanted to....

Wayne T. Smith - Community Health Systems, Inc.

(49:56)..

Justin Lake - Wolfe Research LLC

Thanks. Just in terms of volumes, one of the thing is that we keep hearing from the urban-based hospitals is just, look it's a tough market in terms of volume in general, and therefore they're going and spending more time in dollars, investing in rural and suburban outreach, trying to take share, especially on the higher acuity side.

I'm just curious, is there some way that you have to measure your market share in terms of – what you're keeping, I stemming out migration has always been part of the model in terms of hiring physicians and all that, but are you seeing any impact from that and is there anything you could do to stop it if you are?.

Wayne T. Smith - Community Health Systems, Inc.

Well, we've done a couple of things in terms of the – we have established transfer centers over the past year around the country, so that even facilities that we don't own have one place to call and there are a number of other people who have done this as well, but we've seen a lot of success in our transfer centers.

We also have worked very hard in the last quarter or so to make sure that we don't have any people that leave us, that don't get seen, so that our throughput in terms of our EDs and our physicians' offices has been greatly enhanced.

We're putting in centralized scheduling in our physicians' offices across the country, which is another way that we can help that as well.

So I think we're addressing the issue; look, there's a lot of competition, and we're fully aware of the competition and we're competitive and we're happy to be in this where we have an opportunity to gain market share ourselves doing a number of things.

I don't know, Tim, do you want to add to that or not?.

Tim L. Hingtgen - Community Health Systems, Inc.

I want to echo the focus on our access points, whether that be the freestanding EDs, the emergency department throughput, urgent cares, anything that there is more consumer focus, we certainly have put more energy and attention to achieving best-in-class metrics for those..

W. Larry Cash - Community Health Systems, Inc.

Justin, if you look at the categories where we're losing volume, flu and respiratory, and I think that's got a lot to do with the practice of medicine and it's down 100 basis points or about half the volume in-patient volume growth.

Our OB and delivery, I think other people would have called that out as just not as much OB newborn activity, that's probably about 60 basis points, and in readmissions, it has lots to do with the practice of medicine changing. So (52:21) we probably are losing, maybe losing some market share.

When you look at the absolute drop in the admissions and where it's occurring, it's generally in those three categories and that's predominantly tied to a lot of the type of markets we operate in..

Operator

And we have time for one more question. The last question is from Kevin Fischbeck from Merrill Lynch..

Kevin Mark Fischbeck - Bank of America Merrill Lynch

Okay. Great. Thanks.

Just wanted to see if we could get a sense of what you think the real kind of 2016 EBITDA base is if we breakout all of the deals that you've done throughout 2016 if you take out the EBITDA performance at the beginning of the year, UHS, et cetera? And then also take out, I guess, it sounds like you're saying about $100 million of EBITDA for what you're going to sell next year.

What is the starting point 2016 adjusted number that we can think of and then how do you think about growing that base into 2017?.

W. Larry Cash - Community Health Systems, Inc.

Kevin, you're right if we finish up the year somewhere in the $2.2 billion to $3.8 billion range. There is probably $75 million tied up for the QHC and $20 million or $25 million for Las Vegas and we don't expect many of the transactions to close. There is roughly $100 million thereabouts that would come out.

The issue is when it's going to come out? Majority of it will come out probably in the first half of the year. There could be some of these transactions – could be more transactions there. So, that would be a starting point there. When you look at 2017, there'd be less HITECH, probably at least half the HITECH would probably go away.

We've got a lot of initiatives around the supply chain, sourcing, central business office activity, some improvements to physician practices we're doing will be there again, so most activity you see in the fourth quarter around physician practices and other improvements would be there for the whole year, the next year.

And then, we've sort of got another year of some of the consolidation effort on the business office and the HIM activities. So, that's some of the things we're thinking about that will help. And I think some of the volume initiatives that Tim talked about would cause a little bit better volume and revenue in 2017 than we'd have in 2016..

Operator

I will now turn the call back over to Mr. Smith for closing comments..

Wayne T. Smith - Community Health Systems, Inc.

Thank you again for spending time with us this morning. We're very focused on our strategies that we've outlined earlier. You will see us improve, as we always have done historically.

We want to specifically thank our management team, staff, hospital chief executive officers, hospital chief financial officers and chief nursing officers and division operators for their continued focus on operations. Once again if you have a question, you can always reach us at area code 615-465-7000..

Operator

This concludes today's conference call. You may now disconnect..

ALL TRANSCRIPTS
2024 Q-3 Q-2 Q-1
2023 Q-4 Q-3 Q-2 Q-1
2022 Q-4 Q-3 Q-2 Q-1
2021 Q-4 Q-3 Q-2 Q-1
2020 Q-4 Q-3 Q-2 Q-1
2019 Q-4 Q-3 Q-2 Q-1
2018 Q-4 Q-3 Q-2 Q-1
2017 Q-4 Q-3 Q-2 Q-1
2016 Q-4 Q-3 Q-2 Q-1
2015 Q-4 Q-3 Q-2 Q-1
2014 Q-4 Q-3 Q-2 Q-1