image
Industrials - Trucking - NASDAQ - US
$ 39.62
-1.47 %
$ 2.45 B
Market Cap
54.27
P/E
EARNINGS CALL TRANSCRIPT
EARNINGS CALL TRANSCRIPT 2024 - Q2
image
Operator

Good afternoon, and welcome to the Werner Enterprises Second Quarter 2024 Earnings Conference Call. All participants will be in listen-only mode. [Operator Instructions] After today's presentation there will be an opportunity to ask questions. [Operator Instructions] Please note this event is being recorded.

I would now like to turn the conference over to Chris Neil, Senior Vice President of Pricing and Strategic Planning. Please go ahead..

Chris Neil Senior Vice President of Pricing & Strategic Initiatives

Good afternoon, everyone. Earlier today, we issued our earnings release with our second quarter results. The release and a supplemental presentation are available in the Investors section of our website at werner.com. Today's webcast is being recorded and will be available for replay later today.

Please see the disclosure statement on Slide 2 of the presentation as well as the disclaimers in our earnings release related to forward-looking statements. Today's remarks contain forward-looking statements that may involve risks, uncertainties and other factors that could cause actual results to differ materially.

The company reports results using non-GAAP measures, which we believe provides additional information for investors to help facilitate the comparison of past and present performance. A reconciliation to the most directly comparable GAAP measures is included in the tables attached to the earnings release and in the appendix of the slide presentation.

On today's call with me are Derek Leathers, Chairman and CEO; and Chris Wikoff, Executive Vice President, Treasurer and CFO. Derek will provide an overview of our Q2 results and update on our strategic priorities for 2024 and our market outlook. Chris will cover our financial results in more detail and provide an update on our guidance for the year.

I'll now turn the call over to Derek..

Derek Leathers Chairman & Chief Executive Officer

driving growth in core business, driving operational excellence as a core competency and driving capital efficiency. Relative to our first priority, we are focused on controlling the controllables and implementing changes that position us to maximize leverage when the market inflects.

Dedicated trucks represented 65% of our fleet at the end of the quarter. One-Way miles per truck increased for the fifth consecutive quarter. Mexico portfolio volumes increased low teens compared to the prior year period.

Our One-Way service offering gained strength in the northeast through our ECM segment that received several new business awards in the quarter. We remain confident in our ability to bridge the gap from recent results to our long-term target range although pace and timing remains difficult to predict.

We are making good progress on our second priority of driving operational excellence as a core competency. Measurable progress is being made on safety performance due to our investment in quality professional drivers, evolved training programs and newer equipment. We are starting to realize a new pace of benefit from our technology investment.

Our Truckload, Logistics and Intermodal business has now migrated to our EDGE TMS platform and the transition of our One-Way business is progressing as planned. This is a multiyear journey and we continue to be encouraged by the results.

The synergies and value of a single freight platform will enhance both our customers experience and our operational capability, as well as provide additional opportunities to grow revenue and reduce costs. Our cost savings initiatives continue to expand, growing to over $45 million. And finally, our third priority, driving capital efficiency.

We had another strong quarter of operating cash flow from ongoing favorable trends in working capital. We continue with intentionality in our capital allocation, including $60 million of share repurchases during the quarter. CapEx spend and fleet age remain low. We will continue to update you on our progress against these priorities.

Turning to Slide 7 to discuss our current view of the market. While it remains too early to call an inflection, we are encouraged by signs of tightening. Freight demand has been steady but competitive. One-Way freight conditions in particular improved midway through the quarter and continued into July.

We experienced a tighter environment during Roadcheck week, which led to improving spot rates, and those gains have held. While we recognize broader spot indices underperformed Q2 seasonality, our One-Way segment maintained higher spot rates during the last half of the quarter, enabled by strong execution and freight selection tools.

We experienced more seasonal freight trends with better demand on the West Coast related to certain projects. We expect typical seasonality leading up to peak season in the fall. Recent conversations with customers are encouraging relative to inventory levels.

Moving to Slide 8, before turning it over to Chris to discuss our Q2 results in more detail, I want to take a moment to recognize our Mexico colleagues. July marked the 25th anniversary of our operations in Mexico.

Together with our carrier partners, many of whom we have relationships spanning multiple decades, we have built a premium and large scale Mexico operation with a broad portfolio of services over nearly every crossing location across our southern border.

We have a first class terminal in Laredo that includes a dry and refrigerated transload facility within our property boundaries, providing a high degree of product integrity and security.

Several of our management team members in Mexico have been with us for nearly all of our journey and they manage a workforce of over 200 associates with over half of them located in numerous offices throughout Mexico, including Mexico City, Guadalajara, Monterrey and Queretaro.

We are uniquely positioned to assist our customers as they expand into Mexico with our 25 years of relevant experience, including cross-border regulatory expertise, expansive footprint and customer specific approach.

We were recently honored to celebrate this achievement with many of our Mexico-based associates, customers and partner carriers at our Annual Transportation Forum here in Omaha.

We would not be one of the largest and most reliable cross-border transportation companies without their support and we look forward to many, many more years of excellent customer service and growth. I will now turn it over to Chris..

Chris Wikoff Executive Vice President, Treasurer & Chief Financial Officer

first, rate improvement in One-Way; second, incremental growth for existing fleets in Dedicated at a higher contribution margin as we return to normalized volume; third, normalization in the used equipment market; and fourth, structural improvements through our cost saving initiatives coupled with tech enabled synergies.

Let's turn to Slide 12 to review our fleet metrics. TTS average trucks declined to 7,630 during the quarter. We ended second quarter with the TTS fleet down 2% sequentially and 8% year-over-year. TTS revenue per truck per week net of fuel increased during the quarter by 3% and has increased year-over-year 21 of the last 26 quarters.

Within TTS for the second quarter, Dedicated revenue net of fuel was $289 million, down 7%. Dedicated represented 63% of segment revenue compared to 64% a year ago. Dedicated average trucks decreased 7% to 4901 trucks. At quarter end dedicated represented 65% of the TTS fleet.

Dedicated revenue per truck per week increased slightly year-over-year, growing 25 of the last 26 quarters. While our per truck production is trending well, the impact from certain fleet losses, as a result of maintaining our pricing discipline, drove fewer trucks at the end of the quarter.

We will continue to exhibit discipline and value customers who are looking for the reliability, scale, safety and service of our proven dedicated model.

Although not yet widespread, we have seen demand improvement within some of our existing fleets and with an improving market, we are positioned well to further penetrate new verticals and other hard-to-serve freight opportunities at reinvestable margins.

In our One-Way business for the second quarter, trucking revenue net of fuel was $169 million, a decrease of 4% versus prior year. Average truck count declined 11% to 2730 trucks. Revenue per truck per week was up 8% year-over-year. One-Way bid season is mostly complete.

We started to experience improved results in more recent bids, but also recognized that lower contract rates from earlier bid events will become effective during the quarter.

However, with better freight choices expected in the second half, we will be methodical and proactive in transitioning our One-Way portfolio to higher rates throughout the end of the year and into 2025.

Regarding production and utility, as expected, we’ve realized another quarter of production gains, achieving just 2% less total miles versus prior year with 11% fewer trucks, we expect the favorable trend to continue, although year-over-year improvements will moderate. In addition, our Power Only offering within Logistics segment continues to grow.

Our One-Way Truckload miles combined with Power Only miles, are up 4% year-over-year, showing strong growth in our overall One-Way offering, including asset and asset light alternatives.

This is unique and in a tighter freight market with better rates, the combination of One-Way production gains plus Power Only volume growth translates to improved ROI and provides for more optionality for our customers. Turning now to our Logistics segment on Slide 13.

In the second quarter, Logistics revenue was $209 million, representing 27% of total second quarter revenues. Revenues were down 7% year-over-year but grew 3% sequentially. Revenue in Truckload Logistics declined 10% and shipments decreased 8%.

Shipments increased 2% sequentially as volumes from new business came on board during the quarter and volumes from the existing customer base were generally steady. As previously mentioned, our Power Only solution again represented a growing portion of the Truckload Logistics volume in the quarter.

Intermodal revenues, which make up approximately 13% of segment revenue, increased 17% year-over-year due to 34% more shipments, partially offset by a 13% decrease in revenue per shipment. Final Mile revenues increased sequentially but decreased 9% year-over-year.

As expected, we produced operating income in Logistics after falling just short of breakeven in the first quarter. Adjusted operating income was $1.7 million in the second quarter.

Adjusted operating margin was 0.8%, down 160 basis points year-over-year, driven by rate and gross margin compression, but increased 140 basis points sequentially due to higher brokerage and Power Only shipments, improved brokerage gross margins, improvements in Final Mile and continued cost savings from integration and technology.

It continues to be a very competitive operating environment which is pressuring Logistics margins in the short term. We do expect operating margins to improve modestly later in the year due to our cost savings and technology enhancements.

In the meantime, we are controlling what we can, including improving revenue quality, as well as building our infrastructure and technology to continue to provide industry leading service and expertise at greater scale.

Moving to Slide 14 to discuss our cost savings program, we have expanded our 2024 savings target from $40 million previously communicated to an excess of $45 million. Over $27 million of savings have already been recognized and we have a clear line of sight on the rest of the program.

We are currently focused on developing the next phase of our program for 2025. Let’s review our cash flow on Slide 15. We ended the second quarter with $70 million in cash and cash equivalents.

Operating cash flow remained strong at $109 million for the quarter or 14% of total revenue, very consistent with prior year as we continue to realize efficiency in working capital. As expected, net CapEx continues to trend down. Second quarter was $99 million, down $52 million or 35% year-over-year.

As a percent of revenue year-to-date, net CapEx is less than 8% of revenue compared to over 15% for the same period last year. Yet we continue to maintain a low average age of fleet at 2.1 years on trucks and trailers averaging below five years.

As a result, free cash flow through the first half of this year was $79 million or 5% of total revenues, up 350 basis points year-over-year. Total liquidity at quarter end was $470 million, including cash and availability on a revolver. During the quarter, a term loan with $87.5 million outstanding matured and was absorbed into our revolver capacity.

Moving to Slide 16, we ended the quarter with $670 million in debt, up $73 million or 12% sequentially and up $30 million or 5% compared to a year earlier. On a net debt basis, year-over-year change was up less than 1%. Net debt-to-EBITDA was 1.4 times, driven by EBITDA margin compression over the past 12 months.

We have a very healthy balance sheet, access to capital, relatively low leverage and no near-term maturities in our debt structure. On Slide 17, let’s recap our strategic priorities related to capital allocation.

We continue to prioritize strategic reinvestment in the business while also being balanced over the long-term between returning capital to shareholders, reducing debt and funding M&A. For the first half of the year we generated nearly $80 million free cash flow. We utilized $18 million for dividends and $67 million for share repurchase.

During the quarter, our Board approved a new $5 million share repurchase program replacing the prior program. We invested $60 million towards share repurchases during the quarter at an average share price of $37.04. We have 3.9 million shares remaining under the Board approved program.

Let’s continue on Slide 18 and a review of our full year 2024 guidance. Our full year fleet guidance remains down 6% to down 3%. We are down 7% year-to-date. We see potential for net growth in Dedicated in the second half, but remain focused on maintaining price and margin discipline across our portfolio.

For 2024, we now expect net CapEx between $225 million and $275 million, down from $250 million to $300 million previously. As always, the lion share is for trucks and trailing equipment, but we remain focused on investing in technology, terminals and talent.

Dedicated revenue per truck grew year-over-year and is expected to remain within our full year guidance range of 0% to 3%. One-Way Truckload revenue per total mile decreased 2.7% in the second quarter and 4% in the first half within our guidance range.

We expect the year-over-year change in the third quarter to be down 3% to flat as we see increasing opportunity for favorable rate changes going forward. Equipment and property gains were $4.6 million in the first half of the year. We now anticipate lower equipment values to remain for longer.

As a result, we are lowering our range and now expect gains in the range of $7 million to $13 million, down from $10 million to $20 million previously. Our tax rate in the second quarter was 24.2%. Year-to-date is 28%, reflecting certain onetime discrete items in the first quarter. We expect this to level out throughout the year.

Our full year guidance range remains between 24.5% to 25.5%. The average age of our truck and trailer fleet at the end of the second quarter was 2.1 and 4.9 years respectively, unchanged from the end of 2023. I’ll now turn it back to Derek..

Derek Leathers Chairman & Chief Executive Officer

Thank you, Chris. It was another challenging quarter for our industry, but we stayed the course and focused on controlling the controllables. We are encouraged by our higher sequential operating income and are proud of our safety record and low, preventable accident frequency.

We are actively taking steps to enhance our operations and advance competitive strength in the marketplace by strategically investing in our business, reducing costs and optimizing cash flow. We remain focused on providing a high level of service to our valued customers.

We improved One-Way miles per truck and we are growing in total One-Way miles, including Power Only, and we are continuing to grow in Mexico, which is supported by the global secular trend to nearshore. We made further progress on our cost savings initiatives and returned logistics back to profitability despite ongoing pressures.

As a result of the intentional evolution in our business, Werner has never been stronger. We are more diversified company and better positioned to capitalize on a market turn. We are a cycle-tested team and our historical results demonstrate our ability to generate earnings power as the market improves and demand accelerates.

With that, let us open it up for questions..

Operator

We will now begin the question-and-answer session. [Operator Instructions] The first question comes from Eric Morgan with Barclays. Please go ahead..

Eric Morgan

Hey, good afternoon. Thanks for taking my question. I guess I wanted to ask, on peak season, Derek, you mentioned expecting normal seasonality leading up to peak. I think you also called out some project opportunities that have materialized around the West Coast.

So, just wondering if you could expand a bit on that and what you’re hearing from customers. And I guess specifically interested in your comment on modest, sequential improvement. I think in earnings sequentially, if that’s more a 3Q comment or maybe extending into 4Q as well. I appreciate it..

Derek Leathers Chairman & Chief Executive Officer

Sure, Eric, thanks for the question. So, I think it’s early for us to be trying to give any kind of definitive prediction on peak season. I think as you picked up in our opening remarks, what you heard was lots of signs that seem to be indicating a return to kind of normal seasonality right now.

We’ve seen things like the stickiness of road check and it kind of having enduring the period post road check, at least in our network, relative to spot rates.

We’ve seen project opportunities like you talked about, we’ve seen kind of return to value as it relates to the value of trailer pools and asset-based carriers being favored slightly over brokerage by certain customers.

And frankly, just the overarching theme relative to customer conversations where they’re back in the business of wanting to make sure that we’re having discussions about being prepared for what their needs may look like, being prepared for what their demand may reflect, and as they start thinking and analyzing more where they’re at from an inventory perspective, making sure that we’re able and capable to be able to stand up support for their needs.

All of that kind of leads me to believe, although it’s still early and we’re certainly not predicting an inflection point on the call today, that things are starting to feel back to normal.

If I look externally at external data, another thing I would point to is the increased rejection rates as of late, kind of the stickiness of some of those trends, all of which sort of point to an equilibrium or balanced type of market situation.

So not one that’s yet tight, but one that’s certainly more balanced than it’s been previously, and something we really haven’t seen since kind of mid-summer 2022 was the last time we saw rejection rates at that level.

As far as the modest, sequential improvement part of the question, the reality is we are still inheriting rates that were negotiated through this early cycle bid season in Q1 that are now coming to implementation phases or already been implemented.

Those are countered by more recent conversations and bid activity that are reflective of flat to even positive type results.

So, when you put those two in the mix, and I think it’s only prudent to talk in terms of modest improvement sequentially from Q2 to Q3, we'll still steer clear of Q4 for today's purposes because I do think we're at a dynamic point in the market..

Eric Morgan

Appreciate that. And maybe just a quick clarification on the guidance for tractor count going from down 7% to potentially down 3% to 6%.

Did you say that would be coming from Dedicated? Or is the One-Way business potentially where you could add a few tractors if things start to improve?.

Derek Leathers Chairman & Chief Executive Officer

Yes, it still wouldn't be our desire to add tractors in One-Way. We've got great optionality in One-Way between our Power Only product, our brokerage capabilities through logistics, and other ways by which we could step up and serve a customer to include even intermodal and the growth we've seen there. We're really focused on Dedicated.

The pipeline is strong right now. The number of bid opportunities year-over-year is up significantly at this point from where it was a year ago. It's still a competitive market and we're still going to be disciplined with price. So modest improvement in terms of Dedicated truck growth.

But that's really driven by us taking a disciplined approach to how we're going to think about pricing and making sure whatever we enter into on a multi-year agreement is something that can stand the test of time and is reflective of a customer looking for true high quality, Dedicated service..

Eric Morgan

Great, thanks a lot. Appreciate it..

Derek Leathers Chairman & Chief Executive Officer

Thank you..

Operator

The next question is from Bruce Chan with Stifel. Please go ahead..

Bruce Chan

Hey, good afternoon, gents. Just want to follow-up on some of your comments around the cost saves. I think you mentioned that, that was going up to north of $45 million. Maybe just wondering if you can offer a little bit more color into what sorts of incremental changes are involved in that process relative to last year.

And then just as we think about some of this persistent softness here, how much additional leverage do you have and what are you kind of watching in terms of, kind of guiding when to make the decision to make the dial-up those cost saves even more or maybe even dial it back?.

Derek Leathers Chairman & Chief Executive Officer

Yes, I'll start at the macro and turn it to Chris to kind of follow up with some specifics.

But at the macro level, I think the thing that we've been really focused on, or something that's been important in my vision is making sure that we're cutting costs in a structural way, things that are sustainable, that we think can carry forward into future periods, but also making sure that we're not cutting for the short term from a quarter-to-quarter perspective per se.

I think we're close enough to the end that we want to be prepared and ready. We've been focused on enhancing our operational capabilities, further integrating our acquisitions, making sure that the team is poised to respond very quickly and very efficiently as this market turn plays out of.

And to do that, you've got to make sure you've got the right players on the field. And so it's been a prudent approach, it's been a strategic approach, and one certainly when there's been friction. I've been pushing for the long game, making sure that this business is set up and poised for the turn.

With that, I'll turn it over to Chris with some more commentary on the specifics..

Chris Wikoff Executive Vice President, Treasurer & Chief Financial Officer

Yes, not a ton to add there, Bruce, but just to confirm some of the maybe comments that we had in the prepared remarks. We're making great progress there. Its $27 million realize year-to-date, we are increasing the 2024 program from $40 million to $45 million or more for the year.

That gets us to about $90 million, just shy of $90 million over two years. And we are already looking at beyond 2024 of the art of the possible there.

Being mindful of an upcycle, not cutting into the bone, but really continuing to focus on some of those things, Derek mentioned operation, innovation, productivity gains, leveraging technology and M&A integration, all of which leads to these savings programs being largely structural and sustainable..

Bruce Chan

Okay, I appreciate that. And then just quick housekeeping follow-up on the net CapEx reduction. I imagine that's coming from the One-Way fleet comments that Derek made earlier and possibly from Dedicated, but maybe just a little color on what's driving that reduction..

Derek Leathers Chairman & Chief Executive Officer

Yes, I think there's two parts to it, really, Bruce. The first one is really just as part of any ongoing cost analysis and focused approach to every dollar we spend. You also start making sure that we're re-examining and re-justifying any and all capital projects.

But since the bulk of what we do in CapEx, let's be honest is all in trucks and trailers, the simple reality of some of the disciplined approach we've taken to pricing, which has led to walk away kind of moments for us from opportunities that we feel are not sustainably priced, has led us to fleet guidance that is also down, which has led us to revise what it would take to keep the fleet age, where we wanted to prepare for eventual emission changes, and really have this particular fleet in a great position going forward.

So I like where we've landed. We're not going to spend money just to spend it. We want to make sure that we're very thoughtful with every dollar of capital allocation.

And at this point, we just felt it was prudent to kind of claw that back some because we believe the fleet is exactly where we want it, it's sized appropriately, and the discipline will lead the day as to whether or not that number would ever need to be expanded.

But the range gives us room to do so and to operate within between now and the back half..

Bruce Chan

Okay, very helpful. Thank you..

Derek Leathers Chairman & Chief Executive Officer

Thank you..

Operator

The next question is from Daniel Imbro with Stephens Inc. Please go ahead..

Daniel Imbro

Yep. Hey, thanks. Good afternoon, everybody. Derek, want to start a longer term one? Just as we think about the path back towards that long term, 12% to 17% kind of TTS margin, obviously, this year is going to be depressed, and we've locked in a lot of Dedicated business near these rates, but cost savings are going better, I guess.

Can you update us? Is this going to be a 2025 event where you can get back into that range? That going to get pushed out further to the right? Just given kind of how you're seeing the macro today, how are you thinking this product progresses over the next year, year and a half as we move back towards that?.

Derek Leathers Chairman & Chief Executive Officer

Yes, great question. Obviously, it's a very heavy focus here inside this building it's something we've done a lot of analysis on. It's tough to give you timing without also trying to predict the exact inflection point. And since we can't do that, we're not really signed up at this point to an exact date and time on the return. It's a long term goal.

It's one that we believe we have a bridge to get to. Chris will break that down here in a second. But what I'm excited about right now is, the positioning we put the organization into the focus that we've applied and discipline to our pricing so that we don't have a lot of makeup work to do with an organic business inside the building.

And what we need to do is to go both improve that, but also be opportunistic relative to Dedicated opportunities that they come to us. The fleet mix isn't exactly where we'd like it. We'd like to see Dedicated as a larger percentage of the fleet.

We know logistics synergies continue to develop with the Reed acquisition and the tech-enabled investments that we've been making. So there's a lot of different opportunities in front of us, and Chris will break some of those down for you for now..

Chris Wikoff Executive Vice President, Treasurer & Chief Financial Officer

Yes. So, Daniel, we talked about some of those levers and the components that make up that bridge getting back to the long term range. We're still confident in doing that.

Obviously, the pace and timing is difficult to predict, but those levers that we mentioned, the rate improvement in One-Way, the demand improvement coming back on Dedicated for existing fleets, but adding more trucks as a result of that at a higher contribution margin, plus just having more value in the back-haul, normalization of the used equipment market, and getting back to some lift in the resale values, and then everything we're doing around those structural changes, those are the levers.

We've got confidence in that. And I would just point out, you know, we've, in TTS, we've had five consecutive quarters of sequential decline in operating income until second quarter. So adjusted operating income margin went from 4.1% to 4.3% Q1 to Q2, or net of fuel went from 4.7% to 5%.

So that's a modest improvement, but it's an improvement nonetheless. And we expect that to continue, although modestly..

Daniel Imbro

Yes. Appreciate that. And then maybe as a follow-up, Chris, within the guide, if I can just focus on the Logistics side, I think the slides mentioned the brokerage margins would be down sequentially. Normally, Logistics, or it has some degradation quarter-over-quarter, but normally you're not running at a 99.7% [ph].

So I guess, do you expect Logistics to remain in the black in the third quarter? Could we take a step back? Or what are some of the puts or takes as we move from 2Q to 3Q on the Logistics OR [ph] side? Thanks..

Chris Wikoff Executive Vice President, Treasurer & Chief Financial Officer

Yes, no, good question. We do expect sequential improvement in operating income in Logistics as we move forward. So we intend to stay in the black there..

Daniel Imbro

Thanks so much. Best of luck..

Derek Leathers Chairman & Chief Executive Officer

Thank you..

Operator

The next question is from Scott Group with Wolfe Research. Please go ahead..

Scott Group

Hey, thanks. Afternoon. So I know just following up on that last question, I think last quarter you talked about modest sequential improvement as well, and the trucking, or improved about 30 basis points.

Is that sort of what you're talking about, just directionally? Again, as we think about Q3, I know that's probably a little bit more specific than you guys usually talk on OR, just I don't know, just want to try and help get expectations in the right place..

Derek Leathers Chairman & Chief Executive Officer

Yes, Scott, I was going to start my answer with, that's more specific than we normally talk about, OR so I appreciate your commentary there. Look, we believe that the opportunity is there, especially based on some recent events and recent customer interactions, to improve from Q2 to Q3 as a level set.

If you look back over a 10 year history or horizon with Werner, about half the time Q2 to Q3, earnings actually go down about half the time they go up. Those are kind of rough goalposts to think about. We are – we are currently of the opinion you will see improvement Q2 to Q3, but it will be modest. And the emphasis is on the word modest.

And tying back to the same commentary from Q1 to Q2 gives you some framework to think about..

Scott Group

Okay, that's helpful.

And then for next year, any thoughts on CapEx? And I know there's talk about a pre-buy, or are you guys, how do you think about the pre-buy? Is that something that makes sense for Werner?.

Derek Leathers Chairman & Chief Executive Officer

Yes, I think it's a complicated one right now. I mean, I love our positioning, Scott, meaning that our fleet, as we sit here today, is exactly where we wanted. It hasn't aged any. It hasn't found itself in a position where we've got to kind of refresh or make up for any aging of the fleet, like others may be in a position to have to do.

So we're able to go into 2025 in a pretty good place. We'll certainly want to hold serve on our fleet age and make sure, especially if we were to some of this Dedicated pipeline was to come to fruition. You could see CapEx impacted by our need to grow into that Dedicated opportunity, but it's got to be priced right. It's got to be reinvestable.

It's got to be the right kind of customer. And so we're going to make sure and be methodical about all of the above. We're not putting out 2025 CapEx guidance right now, but it's not our current stance that we're going to be driven heavily by any kind of pre-buy methodology.

We're going to come into it as fresh as we can and be thoughtful with how we conclude our final negotiations on truck and trailer purchases for 2025.

The last thing I'll say is with some of the back, the political backdrop going on right now and some of the friction, let's just say that's taking place relative to where some of the submission stuff ultimately lands and some of the mandates versus regulations versus actual already passed requirements and whether or not there could be a retrenching of some of those, it's just too early to talk too much about it.

And then the final thought on the subject that I do think is relevant is just OEM capacity constraints in general. I think the fear that most would have if they were, if I was part of the investor community is trucking going to go out and make some massive pre-buy in advance of these regulatory changes.

And I think the simple reality is the OEM ability to support something like that this time is fundamentally different than it's been in last cycles. There's been numerous reports that talk about sort of a hard cap of around $300 million, a more likely cap somewhere in the neighborhood of $285 million.

Either one of those numbers is a lot closer to replacement level than it is any kind of meaningful pre-buy level if you look at it from historical standards, both of which put us in a really good position as an industry, not to repeat some mistakes of the past and end up right back in an overcapacity situation..

Scott Group

Very helpful. Thank you Derek, for your thoughts..

Derek Leathers Chairman & Chief Executive Officer

Thank you, Scott..

Operator

The next question is from Ken Hoexter with Banc of America. Please go ahead..

Adam Roszkowski

Hi, this is Adam Roszkowski on for Ken Hoexter. Thanks for taking the question. Maybe, Derek, on that capacity comment you noted how your view is based on a return to seasonality on the demand side and some project activity.

Maybe just an update on the state of capacity exits and what you're seeing here the quarter-to-date?.

Derek Leathers Chairman & Chief Executive Officer

Yes. We continue to monitor and we continue to see, as everyone does, ongoing attrition of capacity. Both the employment data, net attrition of registration data, the pace of that attrition, although not maybe elevating any kind of meaningful uptick, it's still there, it's ever present.

We think people are out of the money that they may have accumulated during the COVID years. I think lenders have been lenient to a fault and I think you'll see a change in that behavior as market conditions improve. So I think there's still a whole lot of people that are going to not make it out of the other end of this very dark time.

So as we look and we think about our business, what gives us confidence in that sentiment is the conversations we're having with customers. We recently just held our annual customer forum here in Omaha. We had a billion-and-a-half, roughly revenue under one room.

Had conversations over a multi day period with many of our best customers and largest customers. And really across the board, they still find value in these high quality, well capitalized fleets like Werner. And I think that positions us also as market conditions tighten, to be on the front end of feeling that impact.

And that's why some of our data differs a little bit from some data that may be out there from a macro perspective like my commentary about spot rates and holding serve post road check. That differs from what you might see on a DAT load board, but it doesn't mean that it's not what's happening every day in our network as we speak.

So we're preparing for the turn, we're ready for it. And as again not to be overly repetitive, but we really like our positioning right now and the work we've put into getting prepared..

Adam Roszkowski

Got it. That's helpful. Thanks. And then on logistics, so expected operating income to kind of improve sequentially. What does that imply for gross margins? I mean, you mentioned the pressure, but is that sequential pressure on gross margins? Maybe just any thoughts there? Thanks..

Chris Wikoff Executive Vice President, Treasurer & Chief Financial Officer

Yes. Adam, this is Chris. We've had four quarters of holding around 15% of gross margin within truckload brokerage. There's a lot of work underway of refining that portfolio, focusing on higher revenue quality as we go forward in effort to sustain gross margin and mitigate as much of that margin squeeze as we get through the turn.

So we are working on that. There's also other things that can influence favorably gross margin and logistics, including as we continue to have strength in the power only growth, which is at a higher margin. We've had six quarters of sequential growth in power only up double digit percent year-over-year in both revenue and volume.

So if some mix continues to change there, that's positive. So that's the gross margin perspective. And then we've continued to take out cost in SG&A, and operating expenses through technology, through integration. Overall, the operating expenses and logistics in the second quarter are down 10% year-over-year, so good progress there.

All of that put together gives us confidence that we'll continue to see sequential improvement there in operating income, even with some of the margin squeeze with the turn in the end cycle..

Derek Leathers Chairman & Chief Executive Officer

And that was well stated, and I have nothing to add to that part of the answer. What I would say, though, in addition to all of that, the other reality is, as Chris alluded to, some of the synergies we're seeing through the tech enabled investment that we've been making and what we now fully implemented in logistics.

It's my belief that we've got to prepare for a world as we go into the out years of 2025, 2026 and beyond, where 15% is going to be a very competitive number.

And the real goal, the real aspirational expectation is how do you take 15% and turn it into a meaningful improvement in bottom line OI and that can be done, that will be done through some of the productivity gains that we're picking up over time.

So we're both excited about the opportunity to expand gross margin, but also in a world will be competitive as far as the eye can see. We've got to make sure we're more and more efficient and that tech is allowing us to do more with less, and we are encouraged by early signs..

Adam Roszkowski

Thank you..

Operator

The next question is from Jason Seidl with TD Cowen. Please go ahead..

Jason Seidl

Thank you, operator. Hey, Derek and Chris and team wanted to touch a little bit on your outlook. If you look at some of the news out there for the low end consumer, it seems that there's some pressure out there. Whether you listen to McDonald's or Pepsi, and you guys have always had a little bit more outsized exposure.

Are you forecasting maybe a little bit of a change in some of your end markets? Are you seeing something different?.

Derek Leathers Chairman & Chief Executive Officer

Yes, great question. I think there's a multi part answer there. I'll try to be brief. First off, yes, we are expanding verticals in which we participate.

As we look at our dedicated fleet exposure, we are continuing to expand and our bandwidth and our ability to serve, looking for like kind of opportunities, meaning very hard to serve, driver involved, defensible positions. But it doesn't have to be in that retail segment.

In addition, on one way same thing, we've been expanding the engineered portion of our fleet, some of the cross border Mexico, which is not nearly as retail focused as the rest of our portfolio, and then expanding into growing verticals that are as part of Warner Premium services.

And the work we're doing there with really kind of higher value, harder to serve, higher expectations, and more difficult transit. All of the above is one of those things that's – that's taking place as we look forward, but then back to the original part of the question around the consumer.

We're certainly not planning this the next several quarters based on any kind of sudden uptick in consumer strength. Instead, it's our belief that that consumer has been more resilient than we would have originally expected. They are staying stronger for longer, but we are very exposed into the discount retail space. They're doing really well.

They tend to do really well during these times. And even across our dedicated portfolio, we're growing across the majority of all of our discount retailers because their business is growing and their needs become more complex as that growth takes place.

So it's not a demand driven or consumer driven kind of model as we think about building this bridge back to our long term operating margins. It's more execution, analysis, engineering, and then lining up with the right type of customer..

Jason Seidl

That's great color, Derek. And a follow up, you talked about how your spot is a little bit different than sort of the generic spot that we see posted out there from some of the providers. And you're not the first large trucking company that has told us that.

What's sort of the difference between the spot rate that you guys see versus that sort of load board spot rate?.

Chris Neil Senior Vice President of Pricing & Strategic Initiatives

Thanks for the question, Jason. This is Chris Neil. I think there's a number of reasons for it. We saw a spot that increased with road check week and it continued into the July 4th holiday and we were able to retain a good chunk of those gains.

I think as a carrier with some scale and an ability to execute, we have access to customer load boards and other places of opportunity there that are less commoditized than the traditional live load, live unload part of spot. And so I think it's just as a bigger carrier, we've got a better opportunity there to serve other customers.

In addition to that, we have several tools that consider network balance. And so those tools have helped us to identify, provide good recommendations on freight selection. Freight obviously optionality and freight selection then will help drive improved spot rates.

And then in addition, although not widespread yet, we have had opportunities to participate in some projects with some customers. And I think you've got to have scale and capability in order to be considered for some of those projects.

So all those things I think together enable us to maybe play in a little different place in terms of the spot market than maybe some of the more commoditized parts of that piece of the network..

Derek Leathers Chairman & Chief Executive Officer

One thing I would add to that, the one thing I would add to that as well is some of the very intensive work we've been doing over the last several weeks is analyzing our network, understanding where we have that optionality that Chris refers to and what that network leverage might look like as it relates to an improving freight market.

Traditionally, Warner has been very conservative in the spot market. We're still at, as we sit here today, very, very minimally exposed to spot.

But we have done the analysis and we are comfortable that as we are, as we sit here today, roughly 20% of our one way network, one way fleet would be available to participate in spot market opportunities, project opportunities, and or other ways by which we could influence the end rate per mile within the network. We're prepared to do so.

We will be doing so as opportunities present itself. Whether it gets to 20 is really up to our customer base and those interactions that we have in the interim, because we're going to make sure that we get that one way network back to a reinvestable level..

Jason Seidl

That makes sense.

And you mentioned projects, and are you anticipating project work to tick up here in the back half of the year noticeably?.

Derek Leathers Chairman & Chief Executive Officer

I think it's too early to say noticeably, but if you go all the way back to Q4 commentary a year ago, we talked about volume of project opportunities was actually pretty strong. Problem was, it didn't come along with the appropriate rates and premiums that that kind of volume requires from us, from an ability to serve it.

And so this year, if we were to look and plan towards normal seasonality, I think it will be an opportunity for rates to be reflective of the complexity of doing that work.

It's too early to tell how strong that volume will be, but even in late Q2 and into Q3, we have some project work underway as we speak, and that's certainly something that's been a couple years since we've been able to see take place..

Jason Seidl

Appreciate the time, gentlemen..

Derek Leathers Chairman & Chief Executive Officer

Thank you..

Operator

The next question is from Tom Wadewitz with UBS. Please go ahead..

Tom Wadewitz

Yes. Good afternoon. Apologize if I missed this, but I wanted to get a little more perspective just on how we ought to model the dedicated truck count looking forward. I think you had kind of telegraphed that there'd be some reductions in second quarter when we saw that in fleet.

But how do you think about dedicated fleet size in 3Q and 4Q and what's the risk that you kind of see further competitive pressures cause that to decline, or you feel pretty comfortable that you're kind of stable with that fleet level?.

Derek Leathers Chairman & Chief Executive Officer

Yes. Tom, I mean, nothing's certain until the ink is dry. But clearly if you look at fleet size overall right now and you look at long end of year or back half fleet guidance, it implies some stabilization. We also commented, and I'll reiterate that the dedicated pipeline is very strong.

Where the rubber meets the road, though, is pricing discipline versus customer expectation. And so we're enthused about the number of opportunities, the number of biddable events, the amounts of trucks right now in the queue.

And the year-over-year difference is significant in terms of dedicated demand and trucks currently either being bid or out – or already out to bid. The question will become how many of those land our bend if there is one, is toward truck growth and dedicated in the back half, but time will tell.

The important factor right now at this point in the cycle is maintaining discipline, doing what's right for our shareholders, and making sure that whatever trucks we're putting into service, I can turn around and buy one to replace it when it's time to do so..

Tom Wadewitz

What do you think is driving that pipeline to be stronger? Is that because that sounds more optimistic like? I think some of the competitive commentary earlier in the year was a lot more cautious about increased pressure. But if you're seeing that pipeline stronger, that seems constructive.

So what do you think is behind that?.

Derek Leathers Chairman & Chief Executive Officer

Yes, I don't know that there's a difference between the early and the later commentary. The pipeline has been pretty strong throughout. It's the competitive pressure part, meaning the number of bidders, number of how low will somebody go, whether they understand the business well enough at the time they're pricing it.

There's always a bit of a disadvantage of incumbency and Dedicated. We know the business. We're operating the business, and we realize the differences between the RFP and the real world. And so at times, that that could be a headwind. And so we did telegraph that we thought it might be in a couple of cases. And as it turned out, it was.

We don't see similar headwinds right now as we look forward on any kind of significant fleet losses. Yes, there's going to be some work to still be done, but we're more encouraged by the quality of those bids that are in-house, the quality of the underlying customer, and the fact that they view their supply chain as a strategic advantageous.

Those kind of customers understand the importance of best-in-class, Dedicated, not just somebody that's slapped a logo on the side of the door. And so we're going to continue to differentiate through the work that we do every day. And I think the opportunity for us to get back on a growth trajectory and Dedicated is in front of us..

Chris Wikoff Executive Vice President, Treasurer & Chief Financial Officer

Hey, Tom, I would just add one quick statistic to that. Where we sit right now in the third quarter, we see more net wins being implemented in the Dedicated fleet than losses being realized for the quarter.

We obviously still have a couple more months to go, but in terms of that net growth and Dedicated in the second half relative to the first in order to get back into that guidance given where we're at, mid-year, we're on our way..

Tom Wadewitz

Okay. So you think even in 3Q, we ought to see that truck move up a bit..

Chris Wikoff Executive Vice President, Treasurer & Chief Financial Officer

Given what we're seeing at this time?.

Tom Wadewitz

Yes. Okay. Thanks for the time. Appreciate it..

Derek Leathers Chairman & Chief Executive Officer

Thank you..

Operator

The next question is from Bascome Majors with Susquehanna. Please go ahead..

Bascome Majors

Derek, you talked yourself about the kind of mixed seasonality you typically see in 3Q. And if we look back historically, though, 4Q is typically up. I think it's 11 years out of the last 12 years.

And I was just curious if you could frame a little more granularly what it is you're seeing in July that gives you confidence that this will be on the better side of that historic seasonality.

And what gives you so much pause about really talking in any way, shape or form about the fourth quarter, given how consistent that is other than, I guess last year was the one year out of those 12 years that you didn't grow sequentially. Thank you..

Derek Leathers Chairman & Chief Executive Officer

Yes. Thank you for the question. So few things, when I was talking earlier about Q2 to Q3, that seasonality is the one that is, or that earnings trend is one that's a bit of a coin toss over a decade plus period in terms of whether it goes up or goes down. Obviously, Q3 to Q4 almost always goes up.

The granular look that you ask for would be things like, as I sit here today, what gives me optimism? Rejection rates that have continued to kind of hold steady at and around 5%.

That tends to be a line in the sand relative to the market being at equilibrium, spot projects coming up and being implemented and ran over a more extended period, projects that start and then get extended further than originally anticipated. All of those things give me optimism.

The pause about trying to predict Q4 is everything from the election to the war in Ukraine to the reality of the stressed consumer, all of the geopolitical issues that are going on with the Suez Canal and labor issues at the ports.

There are so many unknowns between now and Q4 that I just think it would be inappropriate for me to get too granular at this point. I'd rather focus on the reality of the work we're doing to reposition this network, the work we're doing to understand the optionality within One-Way to be able to flex up in a stronger market.

The work that's already taken place, and as Chris mentioned, his resulting in Dedicated fleets being implemented in the short term, that is outpacing any losses due to price differences. Those are the things that I think drive long-term value, and those need to be done and we need to be prepared and ready to execute.

So that's where our efforts are going to be. I can't predict the future any better than anybody else, but there is a lot of positivity afoot that it's going to take time to play out and come to the bottom line. I want to be clear about that because we still have inherent headwinds on gains on sale and that equipment market being under duress.

We still have headwinds from bids that were negotiated in Q1 that are implemented, and we're still living with some of that rates. Although we held the line on rate better than most, as seen through our rate per mile reduction, year-over-year being lesser than almost anyone's. So we like our positioning.

We're ready to, we're ready and prepared to improve from here, but it is going to be modest, it's going to be slow going, but we're going to work to maximize its potential..

Bascome Majors

Thank you for that thoughtful answer. And just to maybe put an emphasis on the 4Q piece in an earlier question, you talked about last year having plenty of project demand, but not appropriate project pricing to support the cost structure of that work that you and other carriers did.

When would we be far enough into the third quarter where you kind of know whether or not you're going to get the kind of pricing that typically supports that 4Q lift for the project work at Werner?.

Chris Wikoff Executive Vice President, Treasurer & Chief Financial Officer

Yes, I think it's going to become evident over the next 45 days. I think it could become evident even sooner than that as we continue to watch and monitor both attrition on the carrier side, employment data, rejection rates.

All of the above is not to mention, the retailers response to current inventory levels being at in balance or in many cases below balance, and what that destocking activity starts looking like.

Unfortunately, it's just not this day that we have that total visibility, and so we're going to be cautious in our guidance so that just to try to paint the clearest picture as we can. But certainly over the next, coming, over the coming weeks, it'll become much more clear..

Bascome Majors

Thank you..

Operator

And the final question today is from Chris Wetherbee with Wells Fargo. Please go ahead..

Chris Wetherbee

Hey, thanks. Good afternoon, guys. Maybe along a similar line, just thinking about the Dedicated fleet count and you got asked a bunch of questions about this, but I guess I'm curious what would sort of get you to the upper band of the additions in the back half of the year.

Does it go sort of into this dynamic of sort of improving fundamentals in the space as we get into the fourth quarter? Just want to get some sense of kind of how you're building that bridge. It sounds like the pipeline is pretty visible.

Is it just simply sort of getting more out of the pipeline or does it also include some macro uplift as well?.

Derek Leathers Chairman & Chief Executive Officer

No, I think it really comes down to win rate. I mean, if I was to fully expose our current Dedicated pipeline or, and this may be true for others as well in the industry, I think most people would be shocked at how many trucks are in that pipeline at any given time, both in number of bids, number of customers, and also total truck count.

So it really comes down to kind of what that win rate looks like and whether we use a traditional win rate over a 10 year period or we use a more depressed win rate. That's been the case maybe over the last 18 months. We know that when the market's loose, that win rate goes down.

We know when the market gets equilibrium we get to a long term run rate, and we know when it's tight. The win rate is even higher than that. I think we're relatively speaking at equilibrium today.

So the win rate starts to tick up from where it's been, but isn't at a level that we're yet able to give any kind of overly bullish commentary or exact truck counts. There's a lot of decisions that will be made in the next 30 days. We'll be making our case as to why we're the best choice and best able to serve that customer.

And we'll know more as we get further in the quarter. I wish, I could tell you more than that. The pipeline and the activity is strong. It's a matter of when we're from here..

Chris Wetherbee

And then one quick follow up just on the One-Way Truckload side, I guess. I'm curious about the opportunities for utilization as we get into the second half of the year. Assuming we do see some improvement in overall activity, you get more of the project business.

How much can utilization sort of add to the One-Way Truckload business?.

Derek Leathers Chairman & Chief Executive Officer

Yes, great question. I mean, we are really proud. I'll start with that. We're really proud of the progress our One-Way team has made with utilization. It's kind of the ultimate control to controllables. You can't do much about rate in a fragmented market like the one that One-Way division finds itself in.

But you can go out and efficiently utilize the assets and you can do everything in your power to make sure that every one of those assets is producing as much as it possibly can. And to have double digit year-over-year increases in production is not easy to come by, but it's intentional. The comps get tougher as we go forward.

There's no doubt about that. It's our belief that we're going to hold, serve and make incremental improvements from here. But where we're at from a production standpoint is kind of best-in-class and we're going to work to push that envelope further. It also ties into some of my opening comments about our 25th anniversary in Mexico.

We're seeing growth in Mexico. We're participating in the near shoring. We have a dominant position there. Those typically are longer length of haul, more efficient loads. They're difficult to do. It takes expertise to pull it off and do it effectively, but we're well positioned to do all of the above.

So all of that lends me or gives me confidence in our ability to continue to put up great production numbers. But it will be incremental from here and the comps will get tougher. That's just a reality of the project that started about a year ago in great earnest..

Chris Wetherbee

Okay, that's very helpful. Thanks so much. Appreciate it..

Derek Leathers Chairman & Chief Executive Officer

Thank you..

Operator

This concludes our question-and-answer session. I would like to turn the conference back over to Derek Leathers for any closing remarks..

Derek Leathers Chairman & Chief Executive Officer

Thanks, Gary. I want to thank everybody for being with us today. As we've discussed on several earnings calls, this has been the worst freight environment I've seen in 30 plus years in the industry. That said, we are focused on preparing for the coming inflection. We're focusing on controlling what we can and improving execution throughout the business.

We've taken actions to improve the operations across the portfolio and drive structural cost savings that will position us better for better operating leverage as things improve.

While it's difficult to forecast exact timing of market tightness, we have a long history of performance when market dynamics normalize, and we're prepared to deliver on that promise once again. While fleet reductions are a reality, so is the pricing discipline that drove the decrease.

We remain committed to our customers, but we must achieve reinvestable margins to justify longer term capital commitments. In short, we're taking actions now that have better positioned the business for an improving freight market.

I'll close by thanking our over 13,000 associates for their dedication and commitment to our customers and each other as we keep America moving. While it's been tougher for longer over the past couple of years, Werner is structurally stronger company today with a lot to be excited about. As this down cycle nears its natural end.

As we transition from the current environment into a more normalized one, we are poised to capitalize and deliver shareholder value. I'd like to thank you all for your interest in Werner. And I hope you all enjoy the rest of your day..

Operator

The conference is now concluded. Thank you for attending today's presentation. You may now disconnect..

ALL TRANSCRIPTS
2024 Q-3 Q-2 Q-1
2023 Q-4 Q-3 Q-2 Q-1
2022 Q-4 Q-3 Q-2 Q-1
2021 Q-4 Q-3 Q-2 Q-1
2020 Q-4 Q-3 Q-2 Q-1
2019 Q-4 Q-3 Q-2 Q-1
2018 Q-4